@prastle I post my view
I was in our ToC game with General_Zod and since beginning we set: not edition at all, I tried some edit and he didn't allowed me, so the rule was set to NO edition.
In Round 13 General_Zod attacked Japan with 3 BMRs+7 fighters+3 inf+1tank, I defended with 6 fighters+4 inf+2 art+AA, in AA shot I got a six of four, so only got one fighter off, then battle continue and remain 2 Japanese fighters vs 2 BMRs+1 tank, he got the planes and I got 1 shot, he lost the tank and battle was over, as I didn't allowed edition he left the game. It was clear the rule of NO edition, so he won the battle but didn’t take Japan. It is clear that a rule set should be obeyed, as he didn’t let me edit all the way... Certainly there are mistakes when one is gaming, that's the game! If we have a rule we have to respect that, even if it is a mistake!
I think that in other game organizations (Axis & Allies.org, atwar-game, GTO, etc.,) there isn’t any chance to edit as default and as we set it in our game before beginning, I’d asked some editing and clearly General_Zod said “No editing at all during the game…” so we continue as that and therefore don’t recognize any editing as it had been set, just to continue the game. If he had announced his intentions he should get them in the battlefield and its result could be a GG, but then a mistake and I’m in my right to continue the game. Saved by the edge! Mistakes are what make lose or win a game. There is the map, the game and the results, not cheating, if we committed mistakes or errors, as I did through the game, we had to pay for! I’m not going to support a mistake that could cost me the game and the game job I did as it’s shown. But Not Edition! That’s the game!
About dice, it was terrible for me all the game (as seen in the map), in the opening Japan lost three planes as unusual; my first and only BMRs from Germany and Japan were lost at the first intent to bombing and in the same turn; got a lot of sixes when 5 or 4s were needed and in Japan battle I had a terrible dice and he had a lucky one (even as calculator shown opposite), but then his mistake and please don’t blame me for that, we establish Not Edition! That’s the game! And also I don’t complain for luck as the random system is as it is and had shown from the beginning who as the luck.
Anyhow, I recognize General_Zod is a great experienced gamer and a friend, but should be most careful in those details that make to win or lose a game.