Flames and Steel (official thread)
-
@KurtGodel7 You could try running both in manual tests and time out which way takes longer for you to play through a single complete game turn. If I’m reading this right, combat outcomes should still be the same either way, it’s more about which will move faster and feel better to play with?
-
@KurtGodel7 You could try running both in manual tests and time out which way takes longer for you to play through a single complete game turn. If I’m reading this right, combat outcomes should still be the same either way, it’s more about which will move faster and feel better to play with?
The disadvantage to the current method is that you're moving your air units at the beginning of every game round, and do not get to move your air units on your own turn. (Except that when you move a carrier the air on the carrier moves with it.)
The method I'm considering lets you move your air on your own turn. It feels more natural to move all three unit types on your own turn, instead of having air separate. The main disadvantage of the method I'm considering is that it would be too much like scrambling is for Global. With Larry Harris scrambling, you've done your combat move, and now you're waiting on your opponent to scramble or not scramble before you can actually fight. With my proposed idea, you've done your combat move, and now you're waiting on your opponent to either move fighters or not move fighters to intercept your bombers. If your opponent never got any phone calls, no knocks on the door, no interruptions from a housemate, never went to the fridge to get something to eat, never needed the bathroom, this would not be a problem.
Claude suggested an idea to make this less bad than scrambling for Global. The user could be given three choices for fighter allocation.
a) Decide manually
b) Avoid intercepting
c) Auto-interceptIf your opponent chooses a) then you're stuck with whatever delay the distractions in his life might create. But option c) is the most interesting. Essentially it assigns the AI the task of making interception decisions. The AI will use math to make its decisions. For example, a lone Chinese fighter should not intercept four Japanese dive bombers escorted by four Japanese fighters. The AI knows this or soon will. In most cases, I think it would be okay for a player to choose option c). If there's a major air war going on, a real battle for the skies type situation, then maybe the player sets it to option a) decide manually.
Also Claude offered an idea for speeding the game along wrt casualty selection. It has the thought of building a 60 second timer or something. If you haven't selected your casualty after 60 seconds, the AI will select one for you. This would be an optional feature.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login