Crazy Europe: House of Habsburg
-
Sorry for posting so many times.
I think I've figured this out. My boat has 2 movement. If I move my boat 1 space in combat move (but don't fight), it still loses all of its movement.
I was not aware of this behavior and kept thinking it was the triggers malfunctioning. I tested by moving a boat 0 zero spaces, it would have 3 movement in NC phase. I move it 2 spaces, it has 1 movement. Then I moved it 1 space, and it had 1 movement. I thought the trigger didn't fire.
-
@crazyg Correct. You can only move a non-air unit during combat move or non-combat move not both.
-
@redrum
You can move land in both -
@crazyg Land and naval should work the same. I'm not sure if you trigger additional movement after combat move if they then could move again. But at least ignoring bonus movement/triggers/resets, land/sea units can only move during combat or non-combat move.
-
Tested it on Revised. Tanks can move 1 space in both phases.
Edit: Duh blitz. I'm a fool. As long as its the engine and not my own error, I'm fine with it.
-
Its uploaded to Git
-
@crazyg, @redrum
Wow... wow had me scratching my head over this. Glad everyone is on, or at least near the same page... (I think I'm just going to throw the book at @wc_sumpton)Cheers...
-
@crazyg said in Crazy Europe: House of Habsburg:
Tested it on Revised. Tanks can move 1 space in both phases.
Edit: Duh blitz. I'm a fool. As long as its the engine and not my own error, I'm fine with it.
By intended rules, since Classic, a Tank cannot move 1 space in both phases, in any case. It cannot move of 1 space to friendly during combat move (tho TripleA doesn't support this restriction). It can move 1 space into a hostile territory, conquering it, but, then, it cannot move again during non combat move.
-
@crazyg
Quick question, I see that the France line in the 'triggerAttachmentDeactivateMoveBonus' trigger has been commented out. When Sweden activates one of the givesMovement bonuses, the bonuses will stay active until Habsburg_Monarchy turn, which will give France those bonuses for free and they could use them during the combatMove phase.Just wondering
Cheers...
-
You can have bigger non combat movement 2 ways.
- Triggering higher values in non combat, then triggering back lower in combat move.
- (without triggers) By the units giving bonus movement to themselves and having the step that gives this movement during non combat move (default is during combat move).
When I tested number 1 (triggering in and out movement to make for higher non combat movement) the only substantial issue I had was that ships that unloaded were able to move again, by the difference.
Doing it with number 2 (steps giving bonus during NCM, and not CM) the issue I had was that if allies had turns one after the other, the units during the CM phase of the ally going second would have the bonus movement, since the bonus was reset only in the moment it was given (you can get around this limit with a dummy player to reset it).edit: Edited to clarify.
-
Hosting a no-tech dice game of the latest 30 minutes ago right now in lobby, if any1 is interested.
-
@cernel said in Crazy Europe: House of Habsburg:
Doing it with steps giving bonus during NCM, and not CM, the issue I had was that if allies had turns one after the other, the units during the CM phase of the ally going second would have the bonus movement, since the bonus was reset only in the moment it was given (you can get around this limit with a dummy player to reset it).
Don't understand your question. In this case a trigger is called before the CM of every player to remove the NCM bonus, (if the bonus is there or not). Another trigger is call before NCM only if the player has the necessary Tech to assign the bonus.
Just trying to get a clear understanding of you question here.
Cheers...
-
@wc_sumpton Not a question.
Edit: You can have bigger non combat movement 2 ways. Either by triggering higher values in non combat, then triggering back lower in combat move, or, without triggers, by the units giving bonus movement to themselves and having the step that gives this movement during non combat move (default is during combat move). If you go with the first solution, the steps I mentioned are irrelevant (you don't need steps, just triggers). Was just talking about my experiences in the past, not specifically what you are doing here.
-
@cernel
I see said the blind man.Cheers...
-
@wc_sumpton Edited my previous post to clarify. It was about my experiences in doing higher non combat movement, not about how you are specifically doing it here. Also, I've not tested again in more than 1 year, so these things may or may not still be true.
-
@wc_sumpton
Not intentional, I'm at the gym, will fix when I'm back.@Cernel
Step properties are very buggy in my experience. I attempted to use them, but the step property to make units not receive bonus movement in combat move phase never did anything. I recall them working correctly a long time ago, but I've tried to minimize my use of this feature because it often led to hair pulling frustration (PoS 2 has very limited information about them).This map has to trigger them on and off anyways because different nations can have different movement speeds. I could do the TWW thing but this way seemed easier (though I could be wrong about that)
-
@cernel
I understand what you are say. I just miss read it the first time. In HoH the bonus movement is granted by a tech, so whichever route that is taken 'change the movement value' or 'givesMovement' we still need the trigger to grant to only those that have the Tech before NCM and remove it prior the next players CM. So only the NCM step need to be set to true if we use 'givesMovement' because the trigger removes the bonus.I understand that this is different then what you are saying, I just misread you post the first time.
Cheers...
-
@crazyg So, it has been some time, but steps always worked perfectly fine for me (beside the limiting behaviour to have 1 single step for giving and resetting the bonus movement, that anyway it is intended and documented). I'm worried about what you say, so I'll have to test it, to see if they got bugged off recently (if so, I hope the developers will fix).
-
If one would want to be a purist, keeping triggering values endlessly in the various phases is sort of a hack. The non-hacky way to do this (if it even works, since I've not tried in a long time) would be to have all players units different (pikemen_France, pikemen_Habsburg…), having a step that disables bonus movement during all combat move phases and a step that enables bonus movement during all non combat movement phases; then, the tech would trigger the bonus movement self given on the unit only once. As I said, the only limit of a non combat bonus system (if it still works) is that the reset bonus is the step that gives it, so you need to alternate turns between alliances, because if you have two allies going one after the other, having the same kind of units, then, the second one will have the bonus during combat movement (this doesn't really make sense, but it is how it works; it would be better if the bonus are reset when the normal movement is) but, now that I think about it, in this case, giving different units (pikemen_France, pikemen_Habsburg…) already solves this issue; so the system I just described should actually work fully.
Edited a thing I overlooked.
-
@cernel
Yes that would work, it was discussed earlier. This seemed like the easier path though. Especially since I might want to add more techs and things like support attachments can get really complex when all 8 nations have different units.You mentioned you played a few games, could I pick your brain about unit balance and starting positions?
Updated 1 missing "France". Let me know if you find other problems.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better đź’—
Register Login