Battle for Arda 2.0.6 - alkexr (Evil) vs redrum (Good)
-
@alkexr said in Battle for Arda 2.0.6 - alkexr (Evil) vs redrum (Good):
(without significant difference from the actual game).
Well, at the cost of trading 4-ish uruk pikes or something, but taking them doesn't seem to be free (counterattacks etc.), so TUV-wise it should be close.
-
@alkexr Yeah, that should prevent Lorien taking Westfold (could also use 2 Gondor rangers as well to make it like 15%) though I think then Rohan can actually get enough to defend Hornburg with Saruman having the 6 or so less units.
-
@redrum Now I could counter-speculate what I would do differently, and if we keep counter-counter-speculating, we end up playing out a new game in the head. But in the end the two (interlinked) questions we have are:
- Should we continue this game as is, or should we start over
- Should we balance the map in a way that allows Saruman to take Hornburg turn 2 or not
-
@alkexr Aye. I definitely think we should continue as even if Saruman/Rohan plays out a bit differently then it normally would, we can still test the rest of the map as I don't think there have been too many errors else where.
We definitely do need to test Saruman's opening and counters to it a bit more though.
-
TripleA Turn Summary: Saruman round 2
TripleA Turn Summary for game: Middle Earth - Battle for Arda, version: 2.0.6
Game History
Round: 2 Combat Move - Saruman Saruman loses 0 PUs for violating West Ered Nimraiss neutrality. Saruman loses 0 PUs for violating Isen South Banks neutrality. 1 dunlending_wildman moved from Adorn to West Ered Nimrais Saruman take West Ered Nimrais from Neutral 1 uruk_warrior moved from Adorn to Isen South Bank Saruman take Isen South Bank from Neutral 1 halforc moved from Isen North Bank to Lond Daer 3 uruk_warriors moved from West March to Lond Daer 1 warg_rider moved from Greyflood East Bank to Eregion 1 warg_rider moved from Swanfleet to Eregion 3 halforcs and 1 uruk_warrior moved from North Enedwaith to Eregion 4 dunlending_wildmen moved from Trihyrne to Ered Nimrais 1 dunlending_wildman moved from East Methedras to Hornburg 1 dunlending_wildman moved from Trihyrne to Hornburg 1 halforc moved from Gap of Rohan to Hornburg 9 uruk_warriors moved from West March to Hornburg 1 wizard moved from Gap of Rohan to Hornburg 2 fire_of_orthancs moved from Nan Curunír to Hornburg 1 dunlending_wildman moved from Methedras to Nimrodel Saruman take Nimrodel from Lorien 1 dunlending_wildman moved from Methedras to Limlight Saruman take Limlight from Lorien 1 dunlending_wildman moved from Methedras to North Fangorn Saruman take North Fangorn from Lorien 3 dunlending_wildmen moved from Isengard to South Fangorn 1 dunlending_wildman moved from Isengard to South Fangorn 2 uruk_warriors moved from West March to Westfold 2 crebains moved from Isengard to Westfold 1 uruk_warrior moved from South Enedwaith to Lond Daer 3 uruk_pikemen moved from Gap of Rohan to Westfold Purchase Units - Saruman Saruman buy 1 dunlending_wildman, 3 halforcs and 4 uruk_pikemen; Remaining resources: 0 PUs; Combat - Saruman Battle in Hornburg Saruman attack with 2 dunlending_wildmen, 2 fire_of_orthancs, 1 halforc, 9 uruk_warriors and 1 wizard Gondor defend with 2 rangers; Rohan defend with 1 factory, 1 fortress and 6 walls siege fire in Hornburg : 5/0 hits, 5,00 expected hits 5 walls owned by the Rohan lost in Hornburg 2 fire_of_orthancs owned by the Saruman lost in Hornburg Saruman roll dice for 2 dunlending_wildmen, 1 halforc, 9 uruk_warriors and 1 wizard in Hornburg, round 2 : 6/1 hits, 6,08 expected hits Rohan roll dice for 1 fortress, 2 rangers and 1 wall in Hornburg, round 2 : 3/0 hits, 3,00 expected hits 2 dunlending_wildmen owned by the Saruman, 1 halforc owned by the Saruman, 1 fortress owned by the Rohan, 1 wall owned by the Rohan and 2 rangers owned by the Gondor lost in Hornburg Saruman win, taking Hornburg from Rohan with 9 uruk_warriors and 1 wizard remaining. Battle score for attacker is 51 Casualties for Rohan: 1 fortress and 6 walls Casualties for Saruman: 2 dunlending_wildmen, 2 fire_of_orthancs and 1 halforc Casualties for Gondor: 2 rangers Battle in Westfold Saruman attack with 2 crebains, 3 uruk_pikemen and 2 uruk_warriors Rohan defend with 1 helming_warrior and 1 riddermark_militia Saruman roll dice for 2 crebains, 3 uruk_pikemen and 2 uruk_warriors in Westfold, round 2 : 2/1 hits, 2,08 expected hits Rohan roll dice for 1 helming_warrior and 1 riddermark_militia in Westfold, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0,08 expected hits 1 riddermark_militia owned by the Rohan, 1 helming_warrior owned by the Rohan and 1 crebain owned by the Saruman lost in Westfold Saruman win, taking Westfold from Rohan with 1 crebain, 3 uruk_pikemen and 2 uruk_warriors remaining. Battle score for attacker is 3 Casualties for Saruman: 1 crebain Casualties for Rohan: 1 helming_warrior and 1 riddermark_militia Battle in Lond Daer Saruman attack with 1 halforc and 4 uruk_warriors Neutral defend with 1 bowman, 1 factory and 1 wall Saruman roll dice for 1 halforc and 4 uruk_warriors in Lond Daer, round 2 : 2/1 hits, 2,17 expected hits Units damaged: 1 wall owned by the Neutral Neutral roll dice for 1 bowman and 1 wall in Lond Daer, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0,83 expected hits 1 halforc owned by the Saruman and 1 bowman owned by the Neutral lost in Lond Daer Saruman roll dice for 4 uruk_warriors in Lond Daer, round 3 : 2/0 hits, 2,00 expected hits Neutral roll dice for 1 wall in Lond Daer, round 3 : 0/1 hits, 0,50 expected hits 1 wall owned by the Neutral lost in Lond Daer Saruman loses 0 PUs for violating Lond Daers neutrality. Saruman win, taking Lond Daer from Neutral with 4 uruk_warriors remaining. Battle score for attacker is 8 Casualties for Saruman: 1 halforc Casualties for Neutral: 1 bowman and 1 wall Battle in Eregion Saruman attack with 3 halforcs, 1 uruk_warrior and 2 warg_riders HighElves defend with 1 elven_archer charge fire in Eregion : 1/1 hits, 0,67 expected hits 1 elven_archer owned by the HighElves lost in Eregion Saruman win, taking Eregion from HighElves with 3 halforcs, 1 uruk_warrior and 2 warg_riders remaining. Battle score for attacker is 6 Casualties for HighElves: 1 elven_archer Battle in South Fangorn Saruman attack with 4 dunlending_wildmen Rohan defend with 1 bowman Saruman roll dice for 4 dunlending_wildmen in South Fangorn, round 2 : 1/0 hits, 1,00 expected hits Lorien roll dice for 1 bowman in South Fangorn, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0,33 expected hits 1 dunlending_wildman owned by the Saruman and 1 bowman owned by the Rohan lost in South Fangorn Saruman win, taking South Fangorn from Lorien with 3 dunlending_wildmen remaining. Battle score for attacker is 1 Casualties for Saruman: 1 dunlending_wildman Casualties for Rohan: 1 bowman Battle in Ered Nimrais Saruman attack with 4 dunlending_wildmen Gondor defend with 1 ranger Saruman roll dice for 4 dunlending_wildmen in Ered Nimrais, round 2 : 1/0 hits, 1,00 expected hits Gondor roll dice for 1 ranger in Ered Nimrais, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0,58 expected hits 1 dunlending_wildman owned by the Saruman and 1 ranger owned by the Gondor lost in Ered Nimrais Saruman win, taking Ered Nimrais from Gondor with 3 dunlending_wildmen remaining. Battle score for attacker is 2 Casualties for Saruman: 1 dunlending_wildman Casualties for Gondor: 1 ranger Non Combat Move - Saruman 1 crebain moved from Westfold to Gap of Rohan 2 halforcs moved from Adorn to Fords of Isen 1 uruk_warrior moved from West March to North-South Road 1 uruk_warrior moved from Isengard to North-South Road Place Units - Saruman 1 dunlending_wildman, 3 halforcs and 4 uruk_pikemen placed in Isengard Turn Complete - Saruman Saruman collect 62 PUs; end with 62 PUsCombat Hit Differential Summary :
Saruman : -0,33 Neutral : -0,33 Lorien : 0,67 siege fire in Hornburg : : 0,00 charge fire in Eregion : : 0,33 Gondor : 0,42 Rohan : 0,92 -
TripleA Turn Summary: Angmar round 2
TripleA Turn Summary for game: Middle Earth - Battle for Arda, version: 2.0.6
Game History
Round: 2 Combat Move - Angmar 1 dragon moved from Forodwaith to North Arnor 1 dragon moved from Forodwaith to North Arnor 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from Carn Dûm to North Arnor 1 dragon moved from Forodwaith to North Downs 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from Eagle's Eyrie to Langwell Angmar take Langwell from Northmen 1 orc_marauder moved from Eagle's Eyrie to East Rhudaur 5 orc_marauders and 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from Carn Dûm to North Downs 1 orc_marauder and 2 snaga_skirmishers moved from Weathertop to Midgewater 3 orc_marauders, 1 snaga_skirmisher and 5 trolls moved from West Rhudaur to Weather Hills 1 nazgul, 6 orc_marauders, 1 snaga_skirmisher and 3 warg_riders moved from Weathertop to Weather Hills 3 orc_marauders and 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from Forodwaith to Mount Gundabad 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from East Angmar to North Downs 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from South Angmar to Weather Hills 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from Ettenmoors to Trollfells 2 snaga_skirmishers moved from Ettenmoors to Ettendales 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from North Misty Mountains to Ettenmoors Purchase Units - Angmar Angmar buy 1 dragon, 3 snaga_skirmishers and 1 wall; Remaining resources: 1 PUs; Combat - Angmar Battle in North Arnor Angmar attack with 2 dragons and 1 snaga_skirmisher Arnor defend with 1 bowman and 3 man_at_armss antiair fire in North Arnor : 1/1 hits, 0,25 expected hits Units damaged: 1 dragon owned by the Angmar Angmar roll dice for 2 dragons and 1 snaga_skirmisher in North Arnor, round 2 : 3/1 hits, 2,42 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 bowman and 3 man_at_armss in North Arnor, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0,83 expected hits Units damaged: 1 dragon owned by the Angmar 3 man_at_armss owned by the Arnor lost in North Arnor antiair fire in North Arnor : 0/1 hits, 0,25 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 2 dragons and 1 snaga_skirmisher in North Arnor, round 3 : 3/1 hits, 2,42 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 bowman in North Arnor, round 3 : 1/1 hits, 0,33 expected hits Units damaged: 1 dragon owned by the Angmar 1 bowman owned by the Arnor lost in North Arnor Angmar win, taking North Arnor from Arnor with 2 dragons and 1 snaga_skirmisher remaining. Battle score for attacker is 17 Casualties for Arnor: 1 bowman and 3 man_at_armss Battle in Midgewater Angmar attack with 1 orc_marauder and 2 snaga_skirmishers Arnor defend with 1 bowman Angmar roll dice for 1 orc_marauder and 2 snaga_skirmishers in Midgewater, round 2 : 1/0 hits, 1,00 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 bowman in Midgewater, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0,33 expected hits 1 bowman owned by the Arnor lost in Midgewater Angmar win, taking Midgewater from Arnor with 1 orc_marauder and 2 snaga_skirmishers remaining. Battle score for attacker is 5 Casualties for Arnor: 1 bowman Battle in North Downs Angmar attack with 1 dragon, 5 orc_marauders and 2 snaga_skirmishers Arnor defend with 1 bowman and 2 dunadan_guards antiair fire in North Downs : 1/1 hits, 0,25 expected hits Units damaged: 1 dragon owned by the Angmar Angmar roll dice for 1 dragon, 5 orc_marauders and 2 snaga_skirmishers in North Downs, round 2 : 3/1 hits, 3,17 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 bowman and 2 dunadan_guards in North Downs, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 1,25 expected hits Units damaged: 1 dragon owned by the Angmar 2 dunadan_guards owned by the Arnor and 1 bowman owned by the Arnor lost in North Downs Angmar win, taking North Downs from Arnor with 1 dragon, 5 orc_marauders and 2 snaga_skirmishers remaining. Battle score for attacker is 21 Casualties for Arnor: 1 bowman and 2 dunadan_guards Battle in Weather Hills Angmar attack with 1 nazgul, 9 orc_marauders, 3 snaga_skirmishers, 5 trolls and 3 warg_riders Arnor defend with 1 bowman and 1 dunadan_guard charge fire in Weather Hills : 1/0 hits, 1,00 expected hits formation fire in Weather Hills : 1/1 hits, 0,33 expected hits 1 warg_rider owned by the Angmar and 1 bowman owned by the Arnor lost in Weather Hills Angmar roll dice for 1 nazgul, 9 orc_marauders, 3 snaga_skirmishers, 5 trolls and 2 warg_riders in Weather Hills, round 2 : 9/0 hits, 9,00 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in Weather Hills, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0,33 expected hits 1 dunadan_guard owned by the Arnor lost in Weather Hills Angmar win, taking Weather Hills from Arnor with 1 nazgul, 9 orc_marauders, 3 snaga_skirmishers, 5 trolls and 2 warg_riders remaining. Battle score for attacker is 6 Casualties for Angmar: 1 warg_rider Casualties for Arnor: 1 bowman and 1 dunadan_guard Non Combat Move - Angmar 2 dragons moved from North Arnor to North Downs Place Units - Angmar 1 dragon and 1 snaga_skirmisher placed in Carn Dûm 2 snaga_skirmishers and 1 wall placed in Mount Gundabad Turn Complete - Angmar Angmar collect 47 PUs; end with 48 PUs 3 units repaired.Combat Hit Differential Summary :
formation fire in Weather Hills : : 0,67 charge fire in Weather Hills : : 0,00 Arnor : -0,08 antiair fire in North Downs : : 0,75 Angmar : 1,00 antiair fire in North Arnor : : 0,50 -
TripleA Turn Summary: Mordor round 2
TripleA Turn Summary for game: Middle Earth - Battle for Arda, version: 2.0.6
Game History
Round: 2 Combat Move - Mordor 1 winged_nazgul moved from West Ephel Dúath to sz 22 2 uruk_warriors moved from Desolation of the Morannon to South Undeep 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from Dagorlad to South Undeep 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from Dead Marshes to South Undeep 1 winged_nazgul moved from Field of Cormallen to Cair Andros 2 uruk_pikemen moved from Minas Morgul to Cair Andros 3 uruk_pikemen moved from Field of Cormallen to Cair Andros 5 snaga_skirmishers moved from Crossroads to Cair Andros 1 spider moved from Crossroads to Cair Andros 1 olog_hai and 1 orc_marauder moved from Field of Cormallen to Nindalf 1 orc_marauder and 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from West Ephel Dúath to Crossings of Poros 1 winged_nazgul moved from Minas Morgul to Crossings of Poros 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from Emyn Arnen to Crossings of Poros 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from Emyn Arnen to South Ithilien Mordor take South Ithilien from Gondor 2 olog_hais moved from Minas Morgul to Henneth Annûn 11 orc_marauders and 10 snaga_skirmishers moved from Mountains of Shadow to East Osgiliath 1 orc_marauder moved from Emyn Arnen to East Osgiliath 2 catapults and 2 snaga_skirmishers moved from Minas Morgul to East Osgiliath 2 snaga_skirmishers moved from North Ithilien to East Osgiliath 6 orc_marauders and 2 snaga_skirmishers moved from Field of Cormallen to East Osgiliath 2 uruk_warriors moved from Crossroads to Dead Marshes 5 orc_marauders and 2 snaga_skirmishers moved from Crossroads to East Osgiliath 1 olog_hai and 2 uruk_warriors moved from Cirith Ungol to East Osgiliath 2 catapults moved from Cirith Ungol to Crossroads Purchase Units - Mordor Mordor buy 1 orc_marauder, 4 uruk_pikemen and 4 uruk_warriors; Remaining resources: 0 PUs; Combat - Mordor Battle in Cair Andros Mordor attack with 5 snaga_skirmishers, 1 spider, 5 uruk_pikemen and 1 winged_nazgul Gondor defend with 3 walls Mordor roll dice for 5 snaga_skirmishers, 1 spider, 5 uruk_pikemen and 1 winged_nazgul in Cair Andros, round 2 : 4/1 hits, 3,58 expected hits Units damaged: 2 walls owned by the Gondor Gondor roll dice for 3 walls in Cair Andros, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0,75 expected hits Units damaged: 1 spider owned by the Mordor 1 wall owned by the Gondor lost in Cair Andros Mordor roll dice for 5 snaga_skirmishers, 1 spider, 5 uruk_pikemen and 1 winged_nazgul in Cair Andros, round 3 : 3/1 hits, 3,83 expected hits Gondor roll dice for 2 walls in Cair Andros, round 3 : 0/1 hits, 0,50 expected hits 2 walls owned by the Gondor lost in Cair Andros Mordor win, taking Cair Andros from Gondor with 5 snaga_skirmishers, 1 spider, 5 uruk_pikemen and 1 winged_nazgul remaining. Battle score for attacker is 24 Casualties for Gondor: 3 walls Battle in East Osgiliath Mordor attack with 2 catapults, 1 olog_hai, 23 orc_marauders, 18 snaga_skirmishers and 2 uruk_warriors Gondor defend with 1 factory and 4 walls siege fire in East Osgiliath : 2/0 hits, 2,00 expected hits 2 walls owned by the Gondor lost in East Osgiliath Mordor roll dice for 2 catapults, 1 olog_hai, 23 orc_marauders, 18 snaga_skirmishers and 2 uruk_warriors in East Osgiliath, round 2 : 16/0 hits, 16,00 expected hits Gondor roll dice for 2 walls in East Osgiliath, round 2 : 1/0 hits, 1,00 expected hits Units damaged: 1 olog_hai owned by the Mordor 2 walls owned by the Gondor lost in East Osgiliath Mordor win, taking East Osgiliath from Gondor with 2 catapults, 1 olog_hai, 23 orc_marauders, 18 snaga_skirmishers and 2 uruk_warriors remaining. Battle score for attacker is 32 Casualties for Gondor: 4 walls Battle in sz 22 Mordor attack with 1 winged_nazgul Gondor defend with 2 dromunds Mordor roll dice for 1 winged_nazgul in sz 22, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0,67 expected hits Gondor roll dice for 2 dromunds in sz 22, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0,67 expected hits Units damaged: 1 winged_nazgul owned by the Mordor retreated to sz 22 Battle in Nindalf Mordor attack with 1 olog_hai and 1 orc_marauder Gondor defend with 1 spearman trample fire in Nindalf : 0/1 hits, 0,50 expected hits Mordor roll dice for 1 olog_hai and 1 orc_marauder in Nindalf, round 2 : 1/0 hits, 1,00 expected hits Gondor roll dice for 1 spearman in Nindalf, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0,08 expected hits 1 spearman owned by the Gondor lost in Nindalf Mordor winGondor win with 2 dromunds remaining, taking Nindalf from Gondor with 1 olog_hai and 1 orc_marauder remaining. Battle score for attacker is 5 Casualties for Gondor: 1 spearman Battle in Henneth Annûn Mordor attack with 2 olog_hais Gondor defend with 1 factory and 1 spearman trample fire in Henneth Annûn : 1/0 hits, 1,00 expected hits 1 spearman owned by the Gondor lost in Henneth Annûn Mordor win, taking Henneth Annûn from Gondor with 2 olog_hais remaining. Battle score for attacker is 5 Casualties for Gondor: 1 spearman Battle in South Undeep Mordor attack with 2 snaga_skirmishers and 2 uruk_warriors Neutral defend with 1 bowman and 1 scout flank fire in South Undeep : 0/1 hits, 0,17 expected hits Mordor roll dice for 2 snaga_skirmishers and 2 uruk_warriors in South Undeep, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 1,17 expected hits Neutral roll dice for 1 bowman and 1 scout in South Undeep, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0,25 expected hits 1 scout owned by the Neutral lost in South Undeep Mordor roll dice for 2 snaga_skirmishers and 2 uruk_warriors in South Undeep, round 3 : 1/1 hits, 1,17 expected hits Neutral roll dice for 1 bowman in South Undeep, round 3 : 1/1 hits, 0,25 expected hits 1 snaga_skirmisher owned by the Mordor and 1 bowman owned by the Neutral lost in South Undeep Mordor loses 0 PUs for violating South Undeeps neutrality. Mordor win, taking South Undeep from Neutral with 1 snaga_skirmisher and 2 uruk_warriors remaining. Battle score for attacker is 6 Casualties for Neutral: 1 bowman and 1 scout Casualties for Mordor: 1 snaga_skirmisher Battle in Crossings of Poros Mordor attack with 1 orc_marauder, 2 snaga_skirmishers and 1 winged_nazgul Gondor defend with 2 rangers antiair fire in Crossings of Poros : 0/1 hits, 0,33 expected hits Mordor roll dice for 1 orc_marauder, 2 snaga_skirmishers and 1 winged_nazgul in Crossings of Poros, round 2 : 2/1 hits, 1,58 expected hits Gondor roll dice for 2 rangers in Crossings of Poros, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0,67 expected hits 2 rangers owned by the Gondor lost in Crossings of Poros Mordor win, taking Crossings of Poros from Gondor with 1 orc_marauder, 2 snaga_skirmishers and 1 winged_nazgul remaining. Battle score for attacker is 12 Casualties for Gondor: 2 rangers Non Combat Move - Mordor 1 winged_nazgul moved from sz 22 to sz 23 1 winged_nazgul moved from Crossings of Poros to East Osgiliath 1 winged_nazgul moved from Cair Andros to East Osgiliath Place Units - Mordor 1 orc_marauder, 1 uruk_pikeman and 3 uruk_warriors placed in Minas Morgul 3 uruk_pikemen placed in Cirith Ungol 1 uruk_warrior placed in Morannon Turn Complete - Mordor Mordor collect 79 PUs; end with 79 PUs 5 units repaired.Combat Hit Differential Summary :
Mordor : -1,00 Neutral : 0,50 trample fire in Nindalf : : -0,50 Gondor : -0,67 flank fire in South Undeep : : -0,17 antiair fire in Crossings of Poros : : -0,33 trample fire in Henneth Annûn : : 0,00 siege fire in East Osgiliath : : 0,00 -
TripleA Turn Summary: Arnor round 2
TripleA Turn Summary for game: Middle Earth - Battle for Arda, version: 2.0.6
Game History
Round: 2 Combat Move - Arnor 2 dunadan_guards moved from Amon Sûl to Midgewater 1 bowman moved from Mitheithel Bank to Midgewater 1 dunadan_guard moved from Amon Sûl to Weathertop 1 man_at_arms moved from Hoarwell Bank to West Rhudaur Arnor take West Rhudaur from Angmar 1 dunadan_guard moved from North Arthedain to North Arnor Purchase Units - Arnor Arnor buy 6 bowmen and 1 man_at_arms; Remaining resources: 0 PUs; Combat - Arnor Battle in North Arnor Arnor attack with 1 dunadan_guard Angmar defend with 1 snaga_skirmisher Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in North Arnor, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in North Arnor, round 3 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in North Arnor, round 4 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in North Arnor, round 5 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in North Arnor, round 6 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in North Arnor, round 7 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in North Arnor, round 8 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in North Arnor, round 9 : 1/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits 1 snaga_skirmisher owned by the Angmar lost in North Arnor Arnor win, taking North Arnor from Angmar with 1 dunadan_guard remaining. Battle score for attacker is 4 Casualties for Angmar: 1 snaga_skirmisher Battle in Midgewater Arnor attack with 1 bowman and 2 dunadan_guards Angmar defend with 1 orc_marauder and 2 snaga_skirmishers Arnor roll dice for 1 bowman and 2 dunadan_guards in Midgewater, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0.75 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 1 orc_marauder and 2 snaga_skirmishers in Midgewater, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0.25 expected hits 1 snaga_skirmisher owned by the Angmar and 1 bowman owned by the Arnor lost in Midgewater Arnor roll dice for 2 dunadan_guards in Midgewater, round 3 : 0/1 hits, 0.50 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 1 orc_marauder and 1 snaga_skirmisher in Midgewater, round 3 : 0/1 hits, 0.17 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 2 dunadan_guards in Midgewater, round 4 : 0/1 hits, 0.50 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 1 orc_marauder and 1 snaga_skirmisher in Midgewater, round 4 : 1/1 hits, 0.17 expected hits 1 dunadan_guard owned by the Arnor lost in Midgewater Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in Midgewater, round 5 : 0/1 hits, 0.25 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 1 orc_marauder and 1 snaga_skirmisher in Midgewater, round 5 : 0/1 hits, 0.17 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in Midgewater, round 6 : 0/1 hits, 0.25 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 1 orc_marauder and 1 snaga_skirmisher in Midgewater, round 6 : 1/1 hits, 0.17 expected hits 1 dunadan_guard owned by the Arnor lost in Midgewater Angmar win with 1 orc_marauder and 1 snaga_skirmisher remaining. Battle score for attacker is -17 Casualties for Arnor: 1 bowman and 2 dunadan_guards Casualties for Angmar: 1 snaga_skirmisher Battle in Weathertop Arnor attack with 1 dunadan_guard Angmar defend with 1 snaga_skirmisher Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in Weathertop, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 1 snaga_skirmisher in Weathertop, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0.08 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in Weathertop, round 3 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 1 snaga_skirmisher in Weathertop, round 3 : 0/1 hits, 0.08 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in Weathertop, round 4 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 1 snaga_skirmisher in Weathertop, round 4 : 0/1 hits, 0.08 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in Weathertop, round 5 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 1 snaga_skirmisher in Weathertop, round 5 : 1/1 hits, 0.08 expected hits 1 dunadan_guard owned by the Arnor lost in Weathertop Angmar win with 1 snaga_skirmisher remaining. Battle score for attacker is -8 Casualties for Arnor: 1 dunadan_guard Non Combat Move - Arnor 2 dunadan_lancers moved from Baranduin East Bank to Fornost 1 dunadan_lancer moved from Brandywine East Bank to Fornost 1 dunadan_lancer moved from East-West Road to Fornost 1 bowman, 2 dunadan_guards and 3 man_at_armss moved from North Arthedain to Baranduin East Bank 1 man_at_arms moved from South Lhûn to North Arthedain 1 man_at_arms moved from Lhûn Tributary to North Arthedain 1 bowman and 1 man_at_arms moved from Brandywine Bridge to Baranduin East Bank 1 dunadan_guard and 1 man_at_arms moved from Hoarwell Bank to Amon Sûl Place Units - Arnor 5 bowmen placed in Fornost 1 bowman and 1 man_at_arms placed in Amon Sûl Turn Complete - Arnor Arnor collect 32 PUs; end with 32 PUsCombat Hit Differential Summary :
Arnor : -4.25 Angmar : 2.75 -
TripleA Move Summary: Gondor round 2
TripleA Move Summary for game: Middle Earth - Battle for Arda, version: 2.0.6
Game History
Round: 2 Combat Move - Gondor 6 rangers moved from Anórien to Cair Andros 3 tower_guards moved from West Osgiliath to Cair Andros 8 tower_guards moved from Minas Tirith to Cair Andros 3 man_at_armss moved from Lossarnach to Cair Andros 5 man_at_armss, 4 spearmen, 6 tower_guards and 2 trebuchets moved from Pelennor Fields to Cair Andros -
@alkexr Need OOL for Cair Andros.
-
@redrum damage spider, snaga, uruk, kill spider
-
@redrum BTW I dare you to do this in high luck
-
@alkexr Yeah, this is a very good example of where LL and dice differ in strategy. Though I would still attack in dice just with less units.
-
TripleA Turn Summary: Gondor round 2
TripleA Turn Summary for game: Middle Earth - Battle for Arda, version: 2.0.6
Game History
Round: 2 Combat Move - Gondor 6 rangers moved from Anórien to Cair Andros 3 tower_guards moved from West Osgiliath to Cair Andros 8 tower_guards moved from Minas Tirith to Cair Andros 3 man_at_armss moved from Lossarnach to Cair Andros 5 man_at_armss, 4 spearmen, 6 tower_guards and 2 trebuchets moved from Pelennor Fields to Cair Andros Purchase Units - Gondor Gondor buy 1 man_at_arms and 10 tower_guards; Remaining resources: 0 PUs; Combat - Gondor Battle in Cair Andros Gondor attack with 8 man_at_armss, 6 rangers, 4 spearmen, 17 tower_guards and 2 trebuchets Mordor defend with 5 snaga_skirmishers, 1 spider and 5 uruk_pikemen Gondor roll dice for 8 man_at_armss, 6 rangers, 4 spearmen, 17 tower_guards and 2 trebuchets in Cair Andros, round 2 : 10/1 hits, 10.58 expected hits Units damaged: 1 spider owned by the Mordor Mordor roll dice for 5 snaga_skirmishers, 1 spider and 5 uruk_pikemen in Cair Andros, round 2 : 3/1 hits, 3.17 expected hits 3 man_at_armss owned by the Gondor, 4 uruk_pikemen owned by the Mordor and 5 snaga_skirmishers owned by the Mordor lost in Cair Andros 5 man_at_armss owned by the Gondor, 2 trebuchets owned by the Gondor, 17 tower_guards owned by the Gondor, 4 spearmen owned by the Gondor and 6 rangers owned by the Gondor retreated to Pelennor Fields Mordor win with 1 spider and 1 uruk_pikeman remaining. Battle score for attacker is 40 Casualties for Gondor: 3 man_at_armss Casualties for Mordor: 5 snaga_skirmishers and 4 uruk_pikemen Non Combat Move - Gondor 1 man_at_arms moved from Lossarnach to Anórien 1 spearman moved from Sirith to Pelennor Fields 1 man_at_arms and 3 spearmen moved from Lebennin to Minas Tirith 1 spearman moved from West Gondor to Pinnath Gelin 1 spearman moved from Dunharrow to West Gondor 1 oathbreaker moved from Harrowdale to Paths of the Dead 7 oathbreakers moved from Harrowdale to Entwade 5 swan_knights moved from Lebennin to Sirith 9 man_at_armss and 1 spearman moved from Gilrain to Sirith 2 dromunds moved from sz 22 to sz 21 Place Units - Gondor 8 tower_guards placed in Minas Tirith 2 tower_guards placed in Edhellond 1 man_at_arms placed in Edhellond Turn Complete - Gondor Gondor collect 63 PUs; end with 63 PUs 1 unit repaired.Combat Hit Differential Summary :
Mordor : -0.17 Gondor : -0.58 -
TripleA Turn Summary: Northmen round 2
TripleA Turn Summary for game: Middle Earth - Battle for Arda, version: 2.0.6
Game History
Round: 2 Combat Move - Northmen 1 woodman moved from Dáin's Halls to Forodwaith Northmen take Forodwaith from Angmar 1 beorning_warrior moved from Gladden Fields to Hithaeglir Northmen take Hithaeglir from Orcs 2 raiders moved from Dale to Anduin Bank 1 raider moved from Dale to South Rhovanion 2 raiders moved from Esgaroth to East Bight 1 raider moved from Esgaroth to North Rhûn 1 woodman moved from Misty Mountains Foothills to Gladden River Northmen take Gladden River from Orcs 1 beorning_warrior and 1 woodman moved from Lands of the Éothéod to Langwell Purchase Units - Northmen Northmen buy 2 beorning_warriors, 8 raiders and 1 woodman; Remaining resources: 1 PUs; Combat - Northmen Battle in Langwell Northmen attack with 1 beorning_warrior and 1 woodman Angmar defend with 1 snaga_skirmisher Northmen roll dice for 1 beorning_warrior and 1 woodman in Langwell, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0.50 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 1 snaga_skirmisher in Langwell, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0.08 expected hits 1 snaga_skirmisher owned by the Angmar lost in Langwell Northmen win, taking Langwell from Angmar with 1 beorning_warrior and 1 woodman remaining. Battle score for attacker is 4 Casualties for Angmar: 1 snaga_skirmisher Battle in Anduin Bank Northmen attack with 2 raiders DolGuldur defend with 1 uruk_warrior Northmen roll dice for 2 raiders in Anduin Bank, round 2 : 1/0 hits, 1.00 expected hits DolGuldur roll dice for 1 uruk_warrior in Anduin Bank, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0.17 expected hits 1 uruk_warrior owned by the DolGuldur lost in Anduin Bank Northmen win, taking Anduin Bank from DolGuldur with 2 raiders remaining. Battle score for attacker is 8 Casualties for DolGuldur: 1 uruk_warrior Battle in North Rhûn Northmen attack with 1 raider Rhun defend with 1 spearman Northmen roll dice for 1 raider in North Rhûn, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0.58 expected hits Rhun roll dice for 1 spearman in North Rhûn, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits 1 spearman owned by the Rhun lost in North Rhûn Northmen win, taking North Rhûn from Rhun with 1 raider remaining. Battle score for attacker is 5 Casualties for Rhun: 1 spearman Battle in East Bight Northmen attack with 2 raiders DolGuldur defend with 1 orc_marauder and 1 uruk_warrior Northmen roll dice for 2 raiders in East Bight, round 2 : 1/0 hits, 1.00 expected hits DolGuldur roll dice for 1 orc_marauder and 1 uruk_warrior in East Bight, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits 1 orc_marauder owned by the DolGuldur lost in East Bight Northmen roll dice for 2 raiders in East Bight, round 3 : 1/0 hits, 1.00 expected hits DolGuldur roll dice for 1 uruk_warrior in East Bight, round 3 : 0/1 hits, 0.17 expected hits 1 uruk_warrior owned by the DolGuldur lost in East Bight Northmen win, taking East Bight from DolGuldur with 2 raiders remaining. Battle score for attacker is 14 Casualties for DolGuldur: 1 orc_marauder and 1 uruk_warrior Battle in South Rhovanion Northmen attack with 1 raider DolGuldur defend with 1 orc_marauder Northmen roll dice for 1 raider in South Rhovanion, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0.58 expected hits DolGuldur roll dice for 1 orc_marauder in South Rhovanion, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0.17 expected hits 1 orc_marauder owned by the DolGuldur lost in South Rhovanion Northmen win, taking South Rhovanion from DolGuldur with 1 raider remaining. Battle score for attacker is 6 Casualties for DolGuldur: 1 orc_marauder Non Combat Move - Northmen 1 beorning_warrior moved from Lands of the Éothéod to Rhimdath 1 beorning_warrior moved from Lands of the Éothéod to Misty Mountains Foothills 1 beorning_warrior moved from Lands of the Beornings to Carrock 2 beorning_warriors moved from Lands of the Éothéod to Carrock 2 bears moved from Dáin's Halls to Lands of the Beornings 1 woodman moved from Dáin's Halls to Framsburg 10 barding_infantrys and 3 beorning_warriors moved from Lands of the Bardings to Long Marshes 1 raider moved from North Woodland Realm to Old Forest Road 1 raider moved from Long Marshes to Old Forest Road 3 raiders moved from Esgaroth to Old Forest Road 4 eotheod_cavalrys moved from Dáin's Halls to Old Forest Road 1 barding_infantry moved from Withered Heath to West Iron Hills Place Units - Northmen 2 beorning_warriors and 1 woodman placed in Framsburg 3 raiders placed in Beorn's Hall 3 raiders placed in Dale 2 raiders placed in Esgaroth Turn Complete - Northmen Northmen collect 53 PUs; end with 54 PUsCombat Hit Differential Summary :
DolGuldur : -0.83 Rhun : -0.33 Northmen : 1.33 Angmar : -0.08 -
TripleA Move Summary: Lorien round 2
TripleA Move Summary for game: Middle Earth - Battle for Arda, version: 2.0.6
Game History
Round: 2 Combat Move - Lorien 2 elven_wardens and 1 galadhrim_longbowman moved from Cerin Amroth to East Vales of Anduin 1 elven_warden moved from West Vales of Anduin to East Vales of Anduin 3 elven_wardens and 2 galadhrim_longbowmen moved from Naith to East Vales of Anduin 1 galadhrim_longbowman and 1 huorn moved from South Lórien to sz Upper Anduin 2 1 galadhrim_longbowman, 1 huorn and 1 swan_boat moved from sz Upper Anduin 2 to sz Upper Anduin 3 1 galadhrim_longbowman and 1 huorn moved from sz Upper Anduin 3 to East Vales of Anduin 1 ent and 1 huorn moved from Wellinghall to North Fangorn 1 ent and 1 huorn moved from Wellinghall to South Fangorn -
@alkexr Need OOL for East Vales of Anduin.
-
- damage troll
- kill warg rider
- kill bat
- kill troll
- kill warg scout
-
TripleA Turn Summary: Lorien round 2
TripleA Turn Summary for game: Middle Earth - Battle for Arda, version: 2.0.6
Game History
Round: 2 Combat Move - Lorien 2 elven_wardens and 1 galadhrim_longbowman moved from Cerin Amroth to East Vales of Anduin 1 elven_warden moved from West Vales of Anduin to East Vales of Anduin 3 elven_wardens and 2 galadhrim_longbowmen moved from Naith to East Vales of Anduin 1 galadhrim_longbowman and 1 huorn moved from South Lórien to sz Upper Anduin 2 1 galadhrim_longbowman, 1 huorn and 1 swan_boat moved from sz Upper Anduin 2 to sz Upper Anduin 3 1 galadhrim_longbowman and 1 huorn moved from sz Upper Anduin 3 to East Vales of Anduin 1 ent and 1 huorn moved from Wellinghall to North Fangorn 1 ent and 1 huorn moved from Wellinghall to South Fangorn Purchase Units - Lorien Lorien buy 3 elven_wardens and 2 galadhrim_longbowmen; Remaining resources: 0 PUs; Combat - Lorien Battle in North Fangorn Lorien attack with 1 ent and 1 huorn Saruman defend with 1 dunlending_wildman Lorien roll dice for 1 ent and 1 huorn in North Fangorn, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 1.42 expected hits Saruman roll dice for 1 dunlending_wildman in North Fangorn, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0.25 expected hits 1 dunlending_wildman owned by the Saruman lost in North Fangorn Lorien win, taking North Fangorn from Saruman with 1 ent and 1 huorn remaining. Battle score for attacker is 4 Casualties for Saruman: 1 dunlending_wildman Battle in South Fangorn Lorien attack with 1 ent and 1 huorn Saruman defend with 3 dunlending_wildmen Lorien roll dice for 1 ent and 1 huorn in South Fangorn, round 2 : 2/1 hits, 1.42 expected hits Saruman roll dice for 3 dunlending_wildmen in South Fangorn, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0.83 expected hits Units damaged: 1 huorn owned by the Lorien 2 dunlending_wildmen owned by the Saruman lost in South Fangorn Lorien roll dice for 1 ent and 1 huorn in South Fangorn, round 3 : 2/1 hits, 1.42 expected hits Saruman roll dice for 1 dunlending_wildman in South Fangorn, round 3 : 0/1 hits, 0.25 expected hits 1 dunlending_wildman owned by the Saruman lost in South Fangorn Lorien win, taking South Fangorn from Saruman with 1 ent and 1 huorn remaining. Battle score for attacker is 12 Casualties for Saruman: 3 dunlending_wildmen Battle in East Vales of Anduin Lorien attack with 6 elven_wardens, 4 galadhrim_longbowmen and 1 huorn Orcs defend with 1 troll, 1 warg_rider and 3 warg_scouts; DolGuldur defend with 1 bat flank fire in East Vales of Anduin : 0/1 hits, 0.75 expected hits Lorien roll dice for 6 elven_wardens, 4 galadhrim_longbowmen and 1 huorn in East Vales of Anduin, round 2 : 3/1 hits, 3.17 expected hits Units damaged: 1 troll owned by the Orcs Orcs roll dice for 1 bat, 1 troll, 1 warg_rider and 3 warg_scouts in East Vales of Anduin, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0.58 expected hits 1 warg_rider owned by the Orcs and 1 bat owned by the DolGuldur lost in East Vales of Anduin flank fire in East Vales of Anduin : 0/1 hits, 0.75 expected hits Lorien roll dice for 6 elven_wardens, 4 galadhrim_longbowmen and 1 huorn in East Vales of Anduin, round 3 : 3/1 hits, 3.17 expected hits Orcs roll dice for 1 troll and 3 warg_scouts in East Vales of Anduin, round 3 : 0/1 hits, 0.42 expected hits 1 troll owned by the Orcs and 2 warg_scouts owned by the Orcs lost in East Vales of Anduin flank fire in East Vales of Anduin : 0/1 hits, 0.25 expected hits Lorien roll dice for 6 elven_wardens, 4 galadhrim_longbowmen and 1 huorn in East Vales of Anduin, round 4 : 3/1 hits, 3.17 expected hits 1 warg_scout owned by the Orcs lost in East Vales of Anduin Lorien win, taking East Vales of Anduin from Orcs with 6 elven_wardens, 4 galadhrim_longbowmen and 1 huorn remaining. Battle score for attacker is 50 Casualties for DolGuldur: 1 bat Casualties for Orcs: 1 troll, 1 warg_rider and 3 warg_scouts Non Combat Move - Lorien 1 elven_warden moved from South Lórien to North Lórien Place Units - Lorien 1 galadhrim_longbowman placed in Wellinghall 3 elven_wardens and 1 galadhrim_longbowman placed in Caras Galadhon Turn Complete - Lorien Lorien collect 26 PUs; end with 26 PUs 1 unit repaired.Combat Hit Differential Summary :
Saruman : -0.33 Lorien : 0.25 Orcs : -1.00 flank fire in East Vales of Anduin : : -1.75 -
TripleA Move Summary: Orcs round 2
TripleA Move Summary for game: Middle Earth - Battle for Arda, version: 2.0.6
Game History
Round: 2 Combat Move - Orcs 1 orc_marauder moved from Celebdil to South Lórien Orcs take South Lórien from Lorien 1 orc_marauder moved from Celebdil to Naith Orcs take Naith from Lorien 1 orc_marauder moved from Celebdil to Cerin Amroth 5 orc_marauders moved from Dimrill Dale to Cerin Amroth 1 balrog moved from Dimrill Dale to Cerin Amroth 6 goblin_shooters moved from Moria to Cerin Amroth 2 warg_riders moved from Hollin Ridge to Cerin Amroth 2 warg_scouts moved from Moria to West Methedras 3 warg_riders moved from Hollin Ridge to Bruinen Bank 1 goblin_shooter moved from Front Porch to Bruinen Bank 3 trolls moved from Dimrill Dale to Hithaeglir 1 orc_marauder moved from Fanuidhol to West Vales of Anduin Orcs take West Vales of Anduin from Lorien 1 orc_marauder moved from Fanuidhol to Hithaeglir 2 catapults moved from Hollin Ridge to Moria 3 trolls moved from Rhudaur to Eagle's Eyrie 2 goblin_shooters moved from Front Porch to Goblin Town 1 goblin_stabber moved from East Rhudaur to Hoarwell 1 goblin_stabber moved from High Pass to Goblin Town
