Churchill's 1939 (thread 2)
-
@beelee You could try having 2 combat phases.
-
@rogercooper you cannot, during the second combat movement, move out of or through an area where a battle occurred during the first combat phase. You can move the EndTurn phase (which closes battles and resets everyone's movement) up in the order, but then you are doubling everybody's movement. One could design a game with smaller territories and double movement and then it might make sense.
-
@rogercooper sounds good to me
Other things I have planned: Scripted border conflicts using movement restrictions. They'd usually last one or two turns
Japan and GEACPS (maybe i should just rename them to Manchuko) start the game in border conflict with USSR, Japanese can use the opportunity to destroy the soviet eastern fleet, and the two can engage the other's armies (involved territories are Buryatia, Amur, Korea and both Machurias)
USSR goes into limited war with Axis Minors early in the game, to simulate the Winter War and the simultaneous occupation of Bessarabia- the Axis Minors player will have to decide, and most likely they will pull out of Bessarabia (movement restrictions will prevent soviets going any further) while fight them in Vyborg and Karelia
Not sure what more to add, will change GEACPS colour to closer to orange
-
@joseph-prince I think you will have hard time making scripted border conflicts work well. The AI will get confused (and I primarily play using the AI).
Of course for Finland, the Winter War was not a limited war.
-
@joseph-prince In case you're unaware of them, here are a couple 39 mods that may give you some ideas:
https://www.axisandallies.org/forums/topic/32236/oztea-s-1939-global-setup?page=1
@RogerCooper yea it'd work ok aginst the neutral TTys if the human was russian, but JPN/russia where one is the AI probably wouldn't. AI doesn't do good on the Global map anyway. PTV be the same I'd imagine
-
I've been busy replying to older posts, as it's been a long time since I've actually had a chance to go through them.
I have been playing this particular game and making my own adjustments. I suppose the biggest of them was defining Open Ocean Sea Zones and NOT allowing the Torpedo Boat units to venture into them.
The reason for this is because the AI was using them in mass to assist with transport convoys. Why use a 1 shot 2 Hit Battleship when you can use 4 Torpedo Boats, especially when they defend at 2?
The biggest drawback with this particular map is that it still uses the old overlay. Several of the territories were historically of greater value than those currently set, but changing them does not get reflected due to the overlay.
Other than that, it's a really nice map. -
@Stohrm Torpedo Boats or other cheap naval units are an interesting balance challenge for the exact reason you brought up, they’re liable to be built in swarms and used to obsolete the larger warships unless you add some special modifiers.
The coastal zones distinction was one that came to mind for me when I was drafting an outline for an expanded WWII unit roster. Mine wouldn’t be hard locked from entering ocean zones but would get a -1 combat penalty in those.
I actually considered Attack 2 / Defense 1 a more natural profile for a TB. That makes them more initiative dependent, and harder to use when combined with the penalty outside coastal zones.
You could throw in the Submarine’s inability to hit aircraft as an additional nerf to make planes an easy counter for torpedo boat spam. While a sub can hide, a torpedo boat doesn’t have that option.
Cruisers and battleships can handle TB spam much easier if they get two attack rolls per round, although that has strong balance implications - it makes them much better against planes as well, unless you can code the second attack roll to be incapable of hitting aircraft.
One final possibility is giving the cruiser and battleship pre-battle AA style shots against TBs to help thin out a swarm before it can attack.
-
@Vendetta You might want to prohibit torpedo boats from hitting airplanes and give planes a bonus against them. Vulnerability to air attack was a big problem for torpedo boats as they lacked significant AA capability.
-
You might want to prohibit torpedo boats from hitting airplanes
Good idea but can triplea do that ? I think unless you're "isSub" it'll fire at everything. If you use the isAA for attack or whatever, it will only work if it has a combat value.
So, just wondering how you'd do it.
-
@beelee Regular units can be limited. Here is a unit from by Pre-Gunpower Experiment mod.
<attachment name="unitAttachment" attachTo="infantry" javaClass="games.strategy.triplea.attachments.UnitAttachment" type="unitType"> <option name="movement" value="1"/> <option name="attack" value="2"/> <option name="defense" value="2"/> <option name="createsResourcesList" value="-1:PUs"/> <option name="canNotTarget" value="cavalry"/> </attachment> -
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
