Determining Unit Cost
-
@Schulz I think shore bombardment abuse is limited because your rules have it capped by number of units you’re landing, plus the Fighter has gotten comparatively cheaper and still attacks the Cruiser at 3 with its naval boost, so there’s a readily available counter to it. I wouldn’t worry too much about leaving it at 21.
Destroyer at 14 and Cruiser at 21 makes the cost ratio between them the same as the base game’s (and the Battleship fits the same ratio too if it stays at 35). They’ve all gotten a little cheaper compared to land units, which was something you were aiming for, which was what you were aiming for.
Right now the Cruiser has a 50/50 shot of being killed if a Fighter attacks it, while costing 5 PU more. If that makes it a bad build, consider giving the Cruiser an AA gun ability.
-
@Vendetta Fair enough, I think the battleships should have anti-air too then, since it would be awkward for cruisers to have it while the battleships don't.
Could the battleship cost be 37 then?
-
@Schulz Probably fine to leave it where it is. If CV is 32, than CV + 2 Fighter is 64. 2 Battleships at 35 is 70, so it’s slightly more expensive (1 Infantry worth).
The AA ability improves its odds in a defense situation where it’s being attacked by carriers (where the BBs were already favored) but doesn’t help it in an offense one where the BBs are attacking the CV (where the CV outperforms it). I think jacking the price up would be necessary only if you made AA fire work when the BB is attacking.
I’d probably cap them at 2 shots per ship so they don’t outscale CV fleet too easily (since only 2 planes can fit on a carrier) and scale that back to 1 shot if you find it becoming too oppressive against fighters.
But you can always adjust prices further if playtesting reveals one particular build strategy is easily outperforming the others. When you run test games, do a few where you try to follow normal balanced build strategies, but also try a few experiments where you only spam one unit or combination and see how that works.
-
@Vendetta All anti-air units do the same 1d6 vs each attacking plane. They don't shoot more no matter how many anti-air units are present, as long as the number of attacking enemy fighters remains the same.
I've always thought that a battleship should be 1 or 2 IPC more expensive than a cruiser + destroyer. Both 36 and 37 sound good to me.
-
@Schulz Try 36 then.
-
Fighters cost-effectively trade at 62% - 68% against pure destroyers. It's almost the same as against pure cruisers.
I'm not sure pure cruisers being as cost-effective as having pure destroyers against fighters is acceptable.
However, pure destroyers soundly defeat pure cruisers with 92% odds.
I think a cruiser should be 22 and a battleship 37.
-
Fighters cost-effectively trade at 62% - 68% against pure destroyers. It's almost the same as against pure cruisers.
I'm not sure pure cruisers being as cost-effective as having pure destroyers against fighters is acceptable.
Why not? The cruiser has to be good at something to be worth buying. If the destroyer is more efficient at fighting planes, more efficient against ships, and it can fight submarines, then there’s virtually no reason to ever buy cruisers. The only edge it would have is bombardment, which doesn’t repay that much value since it’s rarely used, fires only one shot per battle, and most of the time just kills an infantry. And the battleship can do that that anyway.
If you give AA to the cruiser and the battleship, the cruiser is more cost efficient for air defense since it’s the same amount of flak for a lower price. That lets you plot out separate niches for your three main surface combatants. Destroyer should be the the best against submarines, cruiser should be the best against planes, and battleship should be the best at fighting other ships. Now you have distinct reasons to buy all three instead of spamming one type.
However, pure destroyers soundly defeat pure cruisers with 92% odds.
I think a cruiser should be 22 and a battleship 37.
If destroyers are already OP against cruisers, the cruiser isn’t the one that needs to get nerfed.
-
I fell in love with your idea of making destroyers the best against submarines, cruisers the best against fighters, and battleships the best against other ships.
I think combat bonuses might be the only way to achieve this.
How about this one:

Air units' bonus damage vs. surface ships is removed.
Destroyers have +3 attack/defense against submarines, so pure destroyers cost-effectively trade at 80% with pure submarines. However, fighters hard-counter them cost-effectively with 95% odds.
Pure cruisers also counter pure destroyers with 65% odds, while pure fighters have 58%-ish odds against pure cruisers. Submarines hard-counter cruisers cost-effectively, however, even if destroyers are present. For example, 15 subs (180 TUV) have 87% odds against 6 cruisers + 4 destroyers (180 TUV).
Battleships now have a +2 attack/defense bonus against surface ships. They defeat both destroyers and cruisers 100% cost-effectively, but fighters defeat them with 87% odds. They are much worse against subs now.
Shore bombardment is more cost-effective now, though I guess capping it per invading troop and allowing naval bombardment casualties to return fire counterbalanced it.
Do you think the carrier cost should remain 32? Pure fighters only have 58%-ish odds against carriers + fighters, which defeats the purpose of making cruisers the best anti-air ships. Maybe they should cost 34 or 35.
-
@Schulz The one thing to be careful about with bonuses is that they don't discriminate who they target when you're in mixed fleets.
If I leave 1 submarine mixed into my battlefleet and you jump it with destroyers, your destroyers would be shooting at 4s against all of my ships, not just the sub.
Since destroyers haven't been given an AA shot against planes in your set, you could instead give them an AA shot that targets only submarines. Have it roll on a 2 or a 3 every round (and because destroyer cancels sub's first strike, this ASW shot will get the first strike advantage against subs), and leave the destroyer's normal combat value like you have it now.
With the battleship, set the main attack so it can't hit planes at all. Give them 1 AA shot @ 1 against planes that fires every round, so they're not helpless but still lose most of the time against planes. Now you can put their main attack value back up at 4 so they still hit hard on bombardment as well as against other ships.
Finally, give the cruiser its 3 attack back, plus 1 or 2 AA shots every round. Leave the Cruiser's main armament able to fire on all targets.
The last element is submarines - you wanted them to trade well against battleships or cruisers that don't have destroyer protection. For that, give the sub a +1 attack bonus if the enemy has cruisers or battleships (and maybe carriers too), and a -1 attack penalty if the enemy has destroyers (so against a mixed fleet, these should cancel out).
Now when a lone submarine attacks a cruiser, they both roll at 3, but the sub has the edge because of its first strike advantage - if its first roll hits, it wins the fight and automatically survives it. And the sub is much cheaper. 3 subs vs. a Battleship will also favor the subs.
And fighters are probably too weak against ships if they only attack at 2, I think I'd give planes their extra attack point bonus back.
-
@Vendetta I tested attacking 10 destroyers vs. 1 sub + 9 destroyers. Only 1 of the 10 destroyers rolled 4, and the rest rolled 1. They also all continued to roll 1 after the sub was taken as a casualty. They look fine to me as they are right now.
Yes, fighters have become slightly worse against cruisers. It now takes 3 fighters to sink 1 cruiser in low luck instead of 2. However, that's because cruisers themselves became worse against subs and battleships, while destroyers and battleships became worse against fighters.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login