Roger's Scenario Thread
-
Name The Rising Sun WW2v3 AA boats
Description The Pacific War with a large map and destroyers with AA capability
linkGood Points
- Balanced scenario with many zones of conflict
Bad Points
- Ahistorical capitals and territory values
- No victory conditions
-
Name HellGate Europe 1944
Description The last year of the war in Europe on a small map with a deadline for the Allies
linkGood Points
- Fast-playing
- Interesting units
Bad Points
- Confusing, unimplemented victory conditions (I suggest just use an 8-turn deadline)
- Units not well balanced
-
Name World War I 1914
Description A port of A&A 1914 to TripleA
linkGood Points
- Fast-playing
Bad Points
- AI does not handle the 1 round limitation well (it does not retreat from losing battles)
- Unrealistic territory values
- Units can only be build in capitals, reducing strategic options
-
Name Roman Invasion-Alternate Alliances
Description Roman invasion of Britain in 43
link** Good Points
- Interesting situation
- Good unit art
**Bad Points
- No victory conditions
- Little effort to simulate the specifics of classical warfare
-
Name Hearts of Iron 2: Clash Of The Titans-Winter1942
Description World War 2 starting in late 1942, on a large map
linkGood Points
- Some interesting unit types
- China requires a major Japanese effort
Bad Points
- No victory conditions
- Allies don't have enough income to offset Russia's isolation
-
Name Iron Blitz 1942A Russia in the Axis
Description Classic game with neutral Russia
linkGood Points
- A different hypothetical situation
Bad Points
- Hard to achieve victory especially for Allies
- Limited options
-
Name Lord of the Rings" Middle Earth
Description The War of the Ring from the works of Tolkien
linkGood Points
- Nice map
Bad Points
- An uphill struggle for the evil forces, unlike the book where evil is stronger but need to move fast
- Mass production of unique units
- No victory conditions
-
Name Caribbean Trade War
Description The Caribbean in the Age of Sail
linkGood Points
- Interesting dynamic situation
- Some effort made to show the importance of fortresses
Bad Points
- Arbitrary alliances
- Ahistorical territory values
- Events not explained in notes or by notifications
- Sea movement too slow
- Fortresses not important enough
-
Name Europe - Alpha v3 Rules
Description AAE game using AA50 rules
linkGood Points
- Fast-playing
- AA50 rules work well
Bad Points
- Favors Germany strongly (but can be interesting to play as an Allied nation with AI)
- Victory conditions not implemented
-
Name Global 40 House Rules
Description Global game with lots of house rules
link
Note: I played this with all the options onGood Points
- Lots of interesting options, many adding realism
Bad Points
- Some the options are glitchy
- Still the favors the Axis substantially
-
Name Viking 2
Description Viking raids & conquests
linkGood Points
- Nice unit art
Bad Points
- Poor unit balance
- Little attempt to reflect the realities of Medieval warfare
-
Name Big World 1942: Factions
Description Big World with some extra nations added
linkGood Points
- Lots of interesting unit types
- Russia starts strong
Bad Points
- The unit types can confuse the AI (this is mentioned in the game notes)
-
Name Classic-Gold
Description The classic edition with some optional rules
linkGood Points
- Fast-playing
- Balanced
Bad Points
- Lacks some of the subtleties of the later editions
-
Name Ultimate Pants
Description WW2 on a large map with many playable nations
link**Good Points
- Lots of strategic options
- Straightforward unit set
- Many playable nations with viable options
**Bad Points
- Large number of nations slowz the game (but the unit density isn't bad)
- No victory conditions
- Russia gets in trouble because it is hard for the North American nations to exert pressure fast enough
- Many historical inaccuracies
-
Name Barbarossa
Description WW2 on the Revised Map with a June 41 start and Italy,China added as players
link
Good Points
- Fast-playing
- Some interesting new unit types
Bad Points
- No victory conditions
- Hard to distinguish between some unit types
-
Name Classic Iron Blitz 2nd Edition
Description The original Larry Harris game with some minor changes
link
**Good Points
- Fast-playing
- The AI plays well
**Bad Points
- Favors the Allies strongly unless the no Russian First Attack option used
- Japan can surge across Asia with ahistorical ease.
-
Name WW2 NWO 2.0 Neutrals Assigned
Description World War 2 in Europe on the New World Order map with minor powers included.
link
Good Points
- Lots of strategic options
- Special units for some power
Bad Points
- No victory conditions
- Not very historical
-
Name Classic: Iron Blitz 1942A Russia Neutral
Description Germany & Japan vs US & UK on the Classic map
link
Good Points
- A different version of WW2
Bad Points
- Favors the Axis
- Hard to actually achieve victory
-
Name Pacific" 1942
Description Axis & Allies: Pacific game with minor modifications
link
Good Points
- AI plays fast
Bad Points
- The key to Allied victory is bombing Japan, which the AI doesn't do and is not interesting to play out
- China falls too easily
-
Name Large Middle Earth - Third Age All Stars
Description War of the Ring on a detailed map
link
Good Points
- Lots of interesting themed units, with appropriate abilities
Bad Points
- The AI needs to be at Hard, and plays slowly
- The AI gets confused by the inability of most units to enter mountains
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login