Battle for Arda 2.0.6 - alkexr (Evil) vs redrum (Good)
-
TripleA Turn Summary: Rohan round 1
TripleA Turn Summary for game: Middle Earth - Battle for Arda, version: 2.0.6
Game History
Round: 1 Combat Move - Rohan 1 helming_warrior and 1 riddermark_militia moved from Hornburg to Westfold Purchase Units - Rohan Rohan buy 1 bowman, 2 kings_companys and 4 riddermark_militias; Remaining resources: 0 PUs; Combat - Rohan Battle in Westfold Rohan attack with 1 helming_warrior and 1 riddermark_militia Orcs defend with 1 warg_scout Rohan roll dice for 1 helming_warrior and 1 riddermark_militia in Westfold, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0.58 expected hits Orcs roll dice for 1 warg_scout in Westfold, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0.17 expected hits Rohan roll dice for 1 helming_warrior and 1 riddermark_militia in Westfold, round 3 : 1/1 hits, 0.58 expected hits Orcs roll dice for 1 warg_scout in Westfold, round 3 : 0/1 hits, 0.17 expected hits 1 warg_scout owned by the Orcs lost in Westfold Rohan win, taking Westfold from Orcs with 1 helming_warrior and 1 riddermark_militia remaining. Battle score for attacker is 7 Casualties for Orcs: 1 warg_scout Non Combat Move - Rohan 1 bowman moved from Hornburg to Helms Deep 1 helming_warrior moved from Hornburg to Glittering Caves 1 helming_warrior moved from Hornburg to Starkhorn 1 helming_warrior moved from Dunharrow to Glittering Caves 1 bowman moved from Hornburg to South Fangorn 2 bowmen and 3 riddermark_militias moved from Dunharrow to Snowbourn 3 bowmen and 6 riddermark_militias moved from Edoras to West Emnet 1 bowman and 2 riddermark_militias moved from Aldburg to Entwade 2 bowmen moved from Firienholt to Entwade 2 eorling_riders moved from East Emnet to The Wold 1 eorling_rider moved from Eastfold to The Wold 1 eorling_rider moved from Aldburg to The Wold 2 eorling_riders moved from West Emnet to The Wold 1 rohirric_scout moved from West Emnet to The Wold 3 kings_companys moved from Edoras to Entwade Place Units - Rohan 1 bowman, 2 kings_companys and 4 riddermark_militias placed in Edoras Turn Complete - Rohan Rohan collect 37 PUs; end with 37 PUsCombat Hit Differential Summary :
Orcs : -0.33 Rohan : -0.17 -
That 1 orc warg scout winning that battle @40% to block the attack on Sarumen is like a 150 TUV swing move. Definitely doesn't feel good on turn 1. Not sure if that is just an extremely risky move by Sarumen that is probably a bad idea or if the starting positions need tweaked. But that 1 battle to block it probably kept this game alive as otherwise I think Sarumen lost half of its units turn 1.
Also I think the placements for Helms Deep need fixed as it appears the first unit is invisible.
TripleA Developer with a Passion for AI: https://forums.triplea-game.org/topic/105/ai-development-discussion-and-feedback
-
@redrum You made a mistake, and that evens out the mistake I made with Saruman. I think balance-wise we are roughly on the correct track. (You should have sacrificed a huorn to take Westfold, it was clearly important enough.)
If Saruman doesn't make a mistake and does the first turn roughly like this, then Evil has about 7% chance to fail both Saruman's and the Orcs' screening attempt.
But I agree, it should be made clear whether Saruman + Orcs should be allowed to do this. So either 2 dunlendings should be moved 1 territory closer (to allow Saruman to 100% do this) or 2 dunlendings should be moved 1 territory farther (to make this move impossible).
-
@redrum said in Battle for Arda 2.0.6 - alkexr (Evil) vs redrum (Good):
Also I think the placements for Helms Deep need fixed as it appears the first unit is invisible.
It's at (0,0), and hopefully the factory is displayed there.
EDIT: oh, I see it now. I wanted to switch to using the dont_display_unit instead of placement hack in the next version anyway.
-
@alkexr Yeah, I didn't realize that the orc warg scout could get to Westfold. For some reason, I keep forgetting they can move through mountains as the other wargs can't and most cavalry can't. And agree that I should have used a Huorn as well though even with just the 2 elven cavalry, there was a pretty good chance of both of them surviving which would have prevented it as well. So both a missed move and 2 unlucky battles
So I guess your general thought is that Hornburg should fall to Saruman turn 2 given that they move most of their troops into position to attack it? Just trying to get a sense of where you think the balance lies.
-
@redrum said in Battle for Arda 2.0.6 - alkexr (Evil) vs redrum (Good):
So I guess your general thought is that Hornburg should fall to Saruman turn 2 given that they move most of their troops into position to attack it? Just trying to get a sense of where you think the balance lies.
With the current starting position yes, Hornburg should fall turn 2 (without significant difference from the actual game).
-
@alkexr said in Battle for Arda 2.0.6 - alkexr (Evil) vs redrum (Good):
(without significant difference from the actual game).
Well, at the cost of trading 4-ish uruk pikes or something, but taking them doesn't seem to be free (counterattacks etc.), so TUV-wise it should be close.
-
@alkexr Yeah, that should prevent Lorien taking Westfold (could also use 2 Gondor rangers as well to make it like 15%) though I think then Rohan can actually get enough to defend Hornburg with Saruman having the 6 or so less units.
-
@redrum Now I could counter-speculate what I would do differently, and if we keep counter-counter-speculating, we end up playing out a new game in the head. But in the end the two (interlinked) questions we have are:
- Should we continue this game as is, or should we start over
- Should we balance the map in a way that allows Saruman to take Hornburg turn 2 or not
-
@alkexr Aye. I definitely think we should continue as even if Saruman/Rohan plays out a bit differently then it normally would, we can still test the rest of the map as I don't think there have been too many errors else where.
We definitely do need to test Saruman's opening and counters to it a bit more though.
-
TripleA Turn Summary: Saruman round 2
TripleA Turn Summary for game: Middle Earth - Battle for Arda, version: 2.0.6
Game History
Round: 2 Combat Move - Saruman Saruman loses 0 PUs for violating West Ered Nimraiss neutrality. Saruman loses 0 PUs for violating Isen South Banks neutrality. 1 dunlending_wildman moved from Adorn to West Ered Nimrais Saruman take West Ered Nimrais from Neutral 1 uruk_warrior moved from Adorn to Isen South Bank Saruman take Isen South Bank from Neutral 1 halforc moved from Isen North Bank to Lond Daer 3 uruk_warriors moved from West March to Lond Daer 1 warg_rider moved from Greyflood East Bank to Eregion 1 warg_rider moved from Swanfleet to Eregion 3 halforcs and 1 uruk_warrior moved from North Enedwaith to Eregion 4 dunlending_wildmen moved from Trihyrne to Ered Nimrais 1 dunlending_wildman moved from East Methedras to Hornburg 1 dunlending_wildman moved from Trihyrne to Hornburg 1 halforc moved from Gap of Rohan to Hornburg 9 uruk_warriors moved from West March to Hornburg 1 wizard moved from Gap of Rohan to Hornburg 2 fire_of_orthancs moved from Nan Curun铆r to Hornburg 1 dunlending_wildman moved from Methedras to Nimrodel Saruman take Nimrodel from Lorien 1 dunlending_wildman moved from Methedras to Limlight Saruman take Limlight from Lorien 1 dunlending_wildman moved from Methedras to North Fangorn Saruman take North Fangorn from Lorien 3 dunlending_wildmen moved from Isengard to South Fangorn 1 dunlending_wildman moved from Isengard to South Fangorn 2 uruk_warriors moved from West March to Westfold 2 crebains moved from Isengard to Westfold 1 uruk_warrior moved from South Enedwaith to Lond Daer 3 uruk_pikemen moved from Gap of Rohan to Westfold Purchase Units - Saruman Saruman buy 1 dunlending_wildman, 3 halforcs and 4 uruk_pikemen; Remaining resources: 0 PUs; Combat - Saruman Battle in Hornburg Saruman attack with 2 dunlending_wildmen, 2 fire_of_orthancs, 1 halforc, 9 uruk_warriors and 1 wizard Gondor defend with 2 rangers; Rohan defend with 1 factory, 1 fortress and 6 walls siege fire in Hornburg : 5/0 hits, 5,00 expected hits 5 walls owned by the Rohan lost in Hornburg 2 fire_of_orthancs owned by the Saruman lost in Hornburg Saruman roll dice for 2 dunlending_wildmen, 1 halforc, 9 uruk_warriors and 1 wizard in Hornburg, round 2 : 6/1 hits, 6,08 expected hits Rohan roll dice for 1 fortress, 2 rangers and 1 wall in Hornburg, round 2 : 3/0 hits, 3,00 expected hits 2 dunlending_wildmen owned by the Saruman, 1 halforc owned by the Saruman, 1 fortress owned by the Rohan, 1 wall owned by the Rohan and 2 rangers owned by the Gondor lost in Hornburg Saruman win, taking Hornburg from Rohan with 9 uruk_warriors and 1 wizard remaining. Battle score for attacker is 51 Casualties for Rohan: 1 fortress and 6 walls Casualties for Saruman: 2 dunlending_wildmen, 2 fire_of_orthancs and 1 halforc Casualties for Gondor: 2 rangers Battle in Westfold Saruman attack with 2 crebains, 3 uruk_pikemen and 2 uruk_warriors Rohan defend with 1 helming_warrior and 1 riddermark_militia Saruman roll dice for 2 crebains, 3 uruk_pikemen and 2 uruk_warriors in Westfold, round 2 : 2/1 hits, 2,08 expected hits Rohan roll dice for 1 helming_warrior and 1 riddermark_militia in Westfold, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0,08 expected hits 1 riddermark_militia owned by the Rohan, 1 helming_warrior owned by the Rohan and 1 crebain owned by the Saruman lost in Westfold Saruman win, taking Westfold from Rohan with 1 crebain, 3 uruk_pikemen and 2 uruk_warriors remaining. Battle score for attacker is 3 Casualties for Saruman: 1 crebain Casualties for Rohan: 1 helming_warrior and 1 riddermark_militia Battle in Lond Daer Saruman attack with 1 halforc and 4 uruk_warriors Neutral defend with 1 bowman, 1 factory and 1 wall Saruman roll dice for 1 halforc and 4 uruk_warriors in Lond Daer, round 2 : 2/1 hits, 2,17 expected hits Units damaged: 1 wall owned by the Neutral Neutral roll dice for 1 bowman and 1 wall in Lond Daer, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0,83 expected hits 1 halforc owned by the Saruman and 1 bowman owned by the Neutral lost in Lond Daer Saruman roll dice for 4 uruk_warriors in Lond Daer, round 3 : 2/0 hits, 2,00 expected hits Neutral roll dice for 1 wall in Lond Daer, round 3 : 0/1 hits, 0,50 expected hits 1 wall owned by the Neutral lost in Lond Daer Saruman loses 0 PUs for violating Lond Daers neutrality. Saruman win, taking Lond Daer from Neutral with 4 uruk_warriors remaining. Battle score for attacker is 8 Casualties for Saruman: 1 halforc Casualties for Neutral: 1 bowman and 1 wall Battle in Eregion Saruman attack with 3 halforcs, 1 uruk_warrior and 2 warg_riders HighElves defend with 1 elven_archer charge fire in Eregion : 1/1 hits, 0,67 expected hits 1 elven_archer owned by the HighElves lost in Eregion Saruman win, taking Eregion from HighElves with 3 halforcs, 1 uruk_warrior and 2 warg_riders remaining. Battle score for attacker is 6 Casualties for HighElves: 1 elven_archer Battle in South Fangorn Saruman attack with 4 dunlending_wildmen Rohan defend with 1 bowman Saruman roll dice for 4 dunlending_wildmen in South Fangorn, round 2 : 1/0 hits, 1,00 expected hits Lorien roll dice for 1 bowman in South Fangorn, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0,33 expected hits 1 dunlending_wildman owned by the Saruman and 1 bowman owned by the Rohan lost in South Fangorn Saruman win, taking South Fangorn from Lorien with 3 dunlending_wildmen remaining. Battle score for attacker is 1 Casualties for Saruman: 1 dunlending_wildman Casualties for Rohan: 1 bowman Battle in Ered Nimrais Saruman attack with 4 dunlending_wildmen Gondor defend with 1 ranger Saruman roll dice for 4 dunlending_wildmen in Ered Nimrais, round 2 : 1/0 hits, 1,00 expected hits Gondor roll dice for 1 ranger in Ered Nimrais, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0,58 expected hits 1 dunlending_wildman owned by the Saruman and 1 ranger owned by the Gondor lost in Ered Nimrais Saruman win, taking Ered Nimrais from Gondor with 3 dunlending_wildmen remaining. Battle score for attacker is 2 Casualties for Saruman: 1 dunlending_wildman Casualties for Gondor: 1 ranger Non Combat Move - Saruman 1 crebain moved from Westfold to Gap of Rohan 2 halforcs moved from Adorn to Fords of Isen 1 uruk_warrior moved from West March to North-South Road 1 uruk_warrior moved from Isengard to North-South Road Place Units - Saruman 1 dunlending_wildman, 3 halforcs and 4 uruk_pikemen placed in Isengard Turn Complete - Saruman Saruman collect 62 PUs; end with 62 PUsCombat Hit Differential Summary :
Saruman : -0,33 Neutral : -0,33 Lorien : 0,67 siege fire in Hornburg : : 0,00 charge fire in Eregion : : 0,33 Gondor : 0,42 Rohan : 0,92 -
TripleA Turn Summary: Angmar round 2
TripleA Turn Summary for game: Middle Earth - Battle for Arda, version: 2.0.6
Game History
Round: 2 Combat Move - Angmar 1 dragon moved from Forodwaith to North Arnor 1 dragon moved from Forodwaith to North Arnor 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from Carn D没m to North Arnor 1 dragon moved from Forodwaith to North Downs 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from Eagle's Eyrie to Langwell Angmar take Langwell from Northmen 1 orc_marauder moved from Eagle's Eyrie to East Rhudaur 5 orc_marauders and 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from Carn D没m to North Downs 1 orc_marauder and 2 snaga_skirmishers moved from Weathertop to Midgewater 3 orc_marauders, 1 snaga_skirmisher and 5 trolls moved from West Rhudaur to Weather Hills 1 nazgul, 6 orc_marauders, 1 snaga_skirmisher and 3 warg_riders moved from Weathertop to Weather Hills 3 orc_marauders and 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from Forodwaith to Mount Gundabad 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from East Angmar to North Downs 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from South Angmar to Weather Hills 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from Ettenmoors to Trollfells 2 snaga_skirmishers moved from Ettenmoors to Ettendales 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from North Misty Mountains to Ettenmoors Purchase Units - Angmar Angmar buy 1 dragon, 3 snaga_skirmishers and 1 wall; Remaining resources: 1 PUs; Combat - Angmar Battle in North Arnor Angmar attack with 2 dragons and 1 snaga_skirmisher Arnor defend with 1 bowman and 3 man_at_armss antiair fire in North Arnor : 1/1 hits, 0,25 expected hits Units damaged: 1 dragon owned by the Angmar Angmar roll dice for 2 dragons and 1 snaga_skirmisher in North Arnor, round 2 : 3/1 hits, 2,42 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 bowman and 3 man_at_armss in North Arnor, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0,83 expected hits Units damaged: 1 dragon owned by the Angmar 3 man_at_armss owned by the Arnor lost in North Arnor antiair fire in North Arnor : 0/1 hits, 0,25 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 2 dragons and 1 snaga_skirmisher in North Arnor, round 3 : 3/1 hits, 2,42 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 bowman in North Arnor, round 3 : 1/1 hits, 0,33 expected hits Units damaged: 1 dragon owned by the Angmar 1 bowman owned by the Arnor lost in North Arnor Angmar win, taking North Arnor from Arnor with 2 dragons and 1 snaga_skirmisher remaining. Battle score for attacker is 17 Casualties for Arnor: 1 bowman and 3 man_at_armss Battle in Midgewater Angmar attack with 1 orc_marauder and 2 snaga_skirmishers Arnor defend with 1 bowman Angmar roll dice for 1 orc_marauder and 2 snaga_skirmishers in Midgewater, round 2 : 1/0 hits, 1,00 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 bowman in Midgewater, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0,33 expected hits 1 bowman owned by the Arnor lost in Midgewater Angmar win, taking Midgewater from Arnor with 1 orc_marauder and 2 snaga_skirmishers remaining. Battle score for attacker is 5 Casualties for Arnor: 1 bowman Battle in North Downs Angmar attack with 1 dragon, 5 orc_marauders and 2 snaga_skirmishers Arnor defend with 1 bowman and 2 dunadan_guards antiair fire in North Downs : 1/1 hits, 0,25 expected hits Units damaged: 1 dragon owned by the Angmar Angmar roll dice for 1 dragon, 5 orc_marauders and 2 snaga_skirmishers in North Downs, round 2 : 3/1 hits, 3,17 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 bowman and 2 dunadan_guards in North Downs, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 1,25 expected hits Units damaged: 1 dragon owned by the Angmar 2 dunadan_guards owned by the Arnor and 1 bowman owned by the Arnor lost in North Downs Angmar win, taking North Downs from Arnor with 1 dragon, 5 orc_marauders and 2 snaga_skirmishers remaining. Battle score for attacker is 21 Casualties for Arnor: 1 bowman and 2 dunadan_guards Battle in Weather Hills Angmar attack with 1 nazgul, 9 orc_marauders, 3 snaga_skirmishers, 5 trolls and 3 warg_riders Arnor defend with 1 bowman and 1 dunadan_guard charge fire in Weather Hills : 1/0 hits, 1,00 expected hits formation fire in Weather Hills : 1/1 hits, 0,33 expected hits 1 warg_rider owned by the Angmar and 1 bowman owned by the Arnor lost in Weather Hills Angmar roll dice for 1 nazgul, 9 orc_marauders, 3 snaga_skirmishers, 5 trolls and 2 warg_riders in Weather Hills, round 2 : 9/0 hits, 9,00 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in Weather Hills, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0,33 expected hits 1 dunadan_guard owned by the Arnor lost in Weather Hills Angmar win, taking Weather Hills from Arnor with 1 nazgul, 9 orc_marauders, 3 snaga_skirmishers, 5 trolls and 2 warg_riders remaining. Battle score for attacker is 6 Casualties for Angmar: 1 warg_rider Casualties for Arnor: 1 bowman and 1 dunadan_guard Non Combat Move - Angmar 2 dragons moved from North Arnor to North Downs Place Units - Angmar 1 dragon and 1 snaga_skirmisher placed in Carn D没m 2 snaga_skirmishers and 1 wall placed in Mount Gundabad Turn Complete - Angmar Angmar collect 47 PUs; end with 48 PUs 3 units repaired.Combat Hit Differential Summary :
formation fire in Weather Hills : : 0,67 charge fire in Weather Hills : : 0,00 Arnor : -0,08 antiair fire in North Downs : : 0,75 Angmar : 1,00 antiair fire in North Arnor : : 0,50 -
TripleA Turn Summary: Mordor round 2
TripleA Turn Summary for game: Middle Earth - Battle for Arda, version: 2.0.6
Game History
Round: 2 Combat Move - Mordor 1 winged_nazgul moved from West Ephel D煤ath to sz 22 2 uruk_warriors moved from Desolation of the Morannon to South Undeep 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from Dagorlad to South Undeep 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from Dead Marshes to South Undeep 1 winged_nazgul moved from Field of Cormallen to Cair Andros 2 uruk_pikemen moved from Minas Morgul to Cair Andros 3 uruk_pikemen moved from Field of Cormallen to Cair Andros 5 snaga_skirmishers moved from Crossroads to Cair Andros 1 spider moved from Crossroads to Cair Andros 1 olog_hai and 1 orc_marauder moved from Field of Cormallen to Nindalf 1 orc_marauder and 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from West Ephel D煤ath to Crossings of Poros 1 winged_nazgul moved from Minas Morgul to Crossings of Poros 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from Emyn Arnen to Crossings of Poros 1 snaga_skirmisher moved from Emyn Arnen to South Ithilien Mordor take South Ithilien from Gondor 2 olog_hais moved from Minas Morgul to Henneth Ann没n 11 orc_marauders and 10 snaga_skirmishers moved from Mountains of Shadow to East Osgiliath 1 orc_marauder moved from Emyn Arnen to East Osgiliath 2 catapults and 2 snaga_skirmishers moved from Minas Morgul to East Osgiliath 2 snaga_skirmishers moved from North Ithilien to East Osgiliath 6 orc_marauders and 2 snaga_skirmishers moved from Field of Cormallen to East Osgiliath 2 uruk_warriors moved from Crossroads to Dead Marshes 5 orc_marauders and 2 snaga_skirmishers moved from Crossroads to East Osgiliath 1 olog_hai and 2 uruk_warriors moved from Cirith Ungol to East Osgiliath 2 catapults moved from Cirith Ungol to Crossroads Purchase Units - Mordor Mordor buy 1 orc_marauder, 4 uruk_pikemen and 4 uruk_warriors; Remaining resources: 0 PUs; Combat - Mordor Battle in Cair Andros Mordor attack with 5 snaga_skirmishers, 1 spider, 5 uruk_pikemen and 1 winged_nazgul Gondor defend with 3 walls Mordor roll dice for 5 snaga_skirmishers, 1 spider, 5 uruk_pikemen and 1 winged_nazgul in Cair Andros, round 2 : 4/1 hits, 3,58 expected hits Units damaged: 2 walls owned by the Gondor Gondor roll dice for 3 walls in Cair Andros, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0,75 expected hits Units damaged: 1 spider owned by the Mordor 1 wall owned by the Gondor lost in Cair Andros Mordor roll dice for 5 snaga_skirmishers, 1 spider, 5 uruk_pikemen and 1 winged_nazgul in Cair Andros, round 3 : 3/1 hits, 3,83 expected hits Gondor roll dice for 2 walls in Cair Andros, round 3 : 0/1 hits, 0,50 expected hits 2 walls owned by the Gondor lost in Cair Andros Mordor win, taking Cair Andros from Gondor with 5 snaga_skirmishers, 1 spider, 5 uruk_pikemen and 1 winged_nazgul remaining. Battle score for attacker is 24 Casualties for Gondor: 3 walls Battle in East Osgiliath Mordor attack with 2 catapults, 1 olog_hai, 23 orc_marauders, 18 snaga_skirmishers and 2 uruk_warriors Gondor defend with 1 factory and 4 walls siege fire in East Osgiliath : 2/0 hits, 2,00 expected hits 2 walls owned by the Gondor lost in East Osgiliath Mordor roll dice for 2 catapults, 1 olog_hai, 23 orc_marauders, 18 snaga_skirmishers and 2 uruk_warriors in East Osgiliath, round 2 : 16/0 hits, 16,00 expected hits Gondor roll dice for 2 walls in East Osgiliath, round 2 : 1/0 hits, 1,00 expected hits Units damaged: 1 olog_hai owned by the Mordor 2 walls owned by the Gondor lost in East Osgiliath Mordor win, taking East Osgiliath from Gondor with 2 catapults, 1 olog_hai, 23 orc_marauders, 18 snaga_skirmishers and 2 uruk_warriors remaining. Battle score for attacker is 32 Casualties for Gondor: 4 walls Battle in sz 22 Mordor attack with 1 winged_nazgul Gondor defend with 2 dromunds Mordor roll dice for 1 winged_nazgul in sz 22, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0,67 expected hits Gondor roll dice for 2 dromunds in sz 22, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0,67 expected hits Units damaged: 1 winged_nazgul owned by the Mordor retreated to sz 22 Battle in Nindalf Mordor attack with 1 olog_hai and 1 orc_marauder Gondor defend with 1 spearman trample fire in Nindalf : 0/1 hits, 0,50 expected hits Mordor roll dice for 1 olog_hai and 1 orc_marauder in Nindalf, round 2 : 1/0 hits, 1,00 expected hits Gondor roll dice for 1 spearman in Nindalf, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0,08 expected hits 1 spearman owned by the Gondor lost in Nindalf Mordor winGondor win with 2 dromunds remaining, taking Nindalf from Gondor with 1 olog_hai and 1 orc_marauder remaining. Battle score for attacker is 5 Casualties for Gondor: 1 spearman Battle in Henneth Ann没n Mordor attack with 2 olog_hais Gondor defend with 1 factory and 1 spearman trample fire in Henneth Ann没n : 1/0 hits, 1,00 expected hits 1 spearman owned by the Gondor lost in Henneth Ann没n Mordor win, taking Henneth Ann没n from Gondor with 2 olog_hais remaining. Battle score for attacker is 5 Casualties for Gondor: 1 spearman Battle in South Undeep Mordor attack with 2 snaga_skirmishers and 2 uruk_warriors Neutral defend with 1 bowman and 1 scout flank fire in South Undeep : 0/1 hits, 0,17 expected hits Mordor roll dice for 2 snaga_skirmishers and 2 uruk_warriors in South Undeep, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 1,17 expected hits Neutral roll dice for 1 bowman and 1 scout in South Undeep, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0,25 expected hits 1 scout owned by the Neutral lost in South Undeep Mordor roll dice for 2 snaga_skirmishers and 2 uruk_warriors in South Undeep, round 3 : 1/1 hits, 1,17 expected hits Neutral roll dice for 1 bowman in South Undeep, round 3 : 1/1 hits, 0,25 expected hits 1 snaga_skirmisher owned by the Mordor and 1 bowman owned by the Neutral lost in South Undeep Mordor loses 0 PUs for violating South Undeeps neutrality. Mordor win, taking South Undeep from Neutral with 1 snaga_skirmisher and 2 uruk_warriors remaining. Battle score for attacker is 6 Casualties for Neutral: 1 bowman and 1 scout Casualties for Mordor: 1 snaga_skirmisher Battle in Crossings of Poros Mordor attack with 1 orc_marauder, 2 snaga_skirmishers and 1 winged_nazgul Gondor defend with 2 rangers antiair fire in Crossings of Poros : 0/1 hits, 0,33 expected hits Mordor roll dice for 1 orc_marauder, 2 snaga_skirmishers and 1 winged_nazgul in Crossings of Poros, round 2 : 2/1 hits, 1,58 expected hits Gondor roll dice for 2 rangers in Crossings of Poros, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0,67 expected hits 2 rangers owned by the Gondor lost in Crossings of Poros Mordor win, taking Crossings of Poros from Gondor with 1 orc_marauder, 2 snaga_skirmishers and 1 winged_nazgul remaining. Battle score for attacker is 12 Casualties for Gondor: 2 rangers Non Combat Move - Mordor 1 winged_nazgul moved from sz 22 to sz 23 1 winged_nazgul moved from Crossings of Poros to East Osgiliath 1 winged_nazgul moved from Cair Andros to East Osgiliath Place Units - Mordor 1 orc_marauder, 1 uruk_pikeman and 3 uruk_warriors placed in Minas Morgul 3 uruk_pikemen placed in Cirith Ungol 1 uruk_warrior placed in Morannon Turn Complete - Mordor Mordor collect 79 PUs; end with 79 PUs 5 units repaired.Combat Hit Differential Summary :
Mordor : -1,00 Neutral : 0,50 trample fire in Nindalf : : -0,50 Gondor : -0,67 flank fire in South Undeep : : -0,17 antiair fire in Crossings of Poros : : -0,33 trample fire in Henneth Ann没n : : 0,00 siege fire in East Osgiliath : : 0,00 -
TripleA Turn Summary: Arnor round 2
TripleA Turn Summary for game: Middle Earth - Battle for Arda, version: 2.0.6
Game History
Round: 2 Combat Move - Arnor 2 dunadan_guards moved from Amon S没l to Midgewater 1 bowman moved from Mitheithel Bank to Midgewater 1 dunadan_guard moved from Amon S没l to Weathertop 1 man_at_arms moved from Hoarwell Bank to West Rhudaur Arnor take West Rhudaur from Angmar 1 dunadan_guard moved from North Arthedain to North Arnor Purchase Units - Arnor Arnor buy 6 bowmen and 1 man_at_arms; Remaining resources: 0 PUs; Combat - Arnor Battle in North Arnor Arnor attack with 1 dunadan_guard Angmar defend with 1 snaga_skirmisher Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in North Arnor, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in North Arnor, round 3 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in North Arnor, round 4 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in North Arnor, round 5 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in North Arnor, round 6 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in North Arnor, round 7 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in North Arnor, round 8 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in North Arnor, round 9 : 1/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits 1 snaga_skirmisher owned by the Angmar lost in North Arnor Arnor win, taking North Arnor from Angmar with 1 dunadan_guard remaining. Battle score for attacker is 4 Casualties for Angmar: 1 snaga_skirmisher Battle in Midgewater Arnor attack with 1 bowman and 2 dunadan_guards Angmar defend with 1 orc_marauder and 2 snaga_skirmishers Arnor roll dice for 1 bowman and 2 dunadan_guards in Midgewater, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0.75 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 1 orc_marauder and 2 snaga_skirmishers in Midgewater, round 2 : 1/1 hits, 0.25 expected hits 1 snaga_skirmisher owned by the Angmar and 1 bowman owned by the Arnor lost in Midgewater Arnor roll dice for 2 dunadan_guards in Midgewater, round 3 : 0/1 hits, 0.50 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 1 orc_marauder and 1 snaga_skirmisher in Midgewater, round 3 : 0/1 hits, 0.17 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 2 dunadan_guards in Midgewater, round 4 : 0/1 hits, 0.50 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 1 orc_marauder and 1 snaga_skirmisher in Midgewater, round 4 : 1/1 hits, 0.17 expected hits 1 dunadan_guard owned by the Arnor lost in Midgewater Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in Midgewater, round 5 : 0/1 hits, 0.25 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 1 orc_marauder and 1 snaga_skirmisher in Midgewater, round 5 : 0/1 hits, 0.17 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in Midgewater, round 6 : 0/1 hits, 0.25 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 1 orc_marauder and 1 snaga_skirmisher in Midgewater, round 6 : 1/1 hits, 0.17 expected hits 1 dunadan_guard owned by the Arnor lost in Midgewater Angmar win with 1 orc_marauder and 1 snaga_skirmisher remaining. Battle score for attacker is -17 Casualties for Arnor: 1 bowman and 2 dunadan_guards Casualties for Angmar: 1 snaga_skirmisher Battle in Weathertop Arnor attack with 1 dunadan_guard Angmar defend with 1 snaga_skirmisher Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in Weathertop, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 1 snaga_skirmisher in Weathertop, round 2 : 0/1 hits, 0.08 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in Weathertop, round 3 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 1 snaga_skirmisher in Weathertop, round 3 : 0/1 hits, 0.08 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in Weathertop, round 4 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 1 snaga_skirmisher in Weathertop, round 4 : 0/1 hits, 0.08 expected hits Arnor roll dice for 1 dunadan_guard in Weathertop, round 5 : 0/1 hits, 0.33 expected hits Angmar roll dice for 1 snaga_skirmisher in Weathertop, round 5 : 1/1 hits, 0.08 expected hits 1 dunadan_guard owned by the Arnor lost in Weathertop Angmar win with 1 snaga_skirmisher remaining. Battle score for attacker is -8 Casualties for Arnor: 1 dunadan_guard Non Combat Move - Arnor 2 dunadan_lancers moved from Baranduin East Bank to Fornost 1 dunadan_lancer moved from Brandywine East Bank to Fornost 1 dunadan_lancer moved from East-West Road to Fornost 1 bowman, 2 dunadan_guards and 3 man_at_armss moved from North Arthedain to Baranduin East Bank 1 man_at_arms moved from South Lh没n to North Arthedain 1 man_at_arms moved from Lh没n Tributary to North Arthedain 1 bowman and 1 man_at_arms moved from Brandywine Bridge to Baranduin East Bank 1 dunadan_guard and 1 man_at_arms moved from Hoarwell Bank to Amon S没l Place Units - Arnor 5 bowmen placed in Fornost 1 bowman and 1 man_at_arms placed in Amon S没l Turn Complete - Arnor Arnor collect 32 PUs; end with 32 PUsCombat Hit Differential Summary :
Arnor : -4.25 Angmar : 2.75TripleA Developer with a Passion for AI: https://forums.triplea-game.org/topic/105/ai-development-discussion-and-feedback
-
TripleA Move Summary: Gondor round 2
TripleA Move Summary for game: Middle Earth - Battle for Arda, version: 2.0.6
Game History
Round: 2 Combat Move - Gondor 6 rangers moved from An贸rien to Cair Andros 3 tower_guards moved from West Osgiliath to Cair Andros 8 tower_guards moved from Minas Tirith to Cair Andros 3 man_at_armss moved from Lossarnach to Cair Andros 5 man_at_armss, 4 spearmen, 6 tower_guards and 2 trebuchets moved from Pelennor Fields to Cair Andros -
@alkexr Need OOL for Cair Andros.
TripleA Developer with a Passion for AI: https://forums.triplea-game.org/topic/105/ai-development-discussion-and-feedback
-
@redrum damage spider, snaga, uruk, kill spider
-
@redrum BTW I dare you to do this in high luck
-
@alkexr Yeah, this is a very good example of where LL and dice differ in strategy. Though I would still attack in dice just with less units.
-
TripleA Turn Summary: Gondor round 2
TripleA Turn Summary for game: Middle Earth - Battle for Arda, version: 2.0.6
Game History
Round: 2 Combat Move - Gondor 6 rangers moved from An贸rien to Cair Andros 3 tower_guards moved from West Osgiliath to Cair Andros 8 tower_guards moved from Minas Tirith to Cair Andros 3 man_at_armss moved from Lossarnach to Cair Andros 5 man_at_armss, 4 spearmen, 6 tower_guards and 2 trebuchets moved from Pelennor Fields to Cair Andros Purchase Units - Gondor Gondor buy 1 man_at_arms and 10 tower_guards; Remaining resources: 0 PUs; Combat - Gondor Battle in Cair Andros Gondor attack with 8 man_at_armss, 6 rangers, 4 spearmen, 17 tower_guards and 2 trebuchets Mordor defend with 5 snaga_skirmishers, 1 spider and 5 uruk_pikemen Gondor roll dice for 8 man_at_armss, 6 rangers, 4 spearmen, 17 tower_guards and 2 trebuchets in Cair Andros, round 2 : 10/1 hits, 10.58 expected hits Units damaged: 1 spider owned by the Mordor Mordor roll dice for 5 snaga_skirmishers, 1 spider and 5 uruk_pikemen in Cair Andros, round 2 : 3/1 hits, 3.17 expected hits 3 man_at_armss owned by the Gondor, 4 uruk_pikemen owned by the Mordor and 5 snaga_skirmishers owned by the Mordor lost in Cair Andros 5 man_at_armss owned by the Gondor, 2 trebuchets owned by the Gondor, 17 tower_guards owned by the Gondor, 4 spearmen owned by the Gondor and 6 rangers owned by the Gondor retreated to Pelennor Fields Mordor win with 1 spider and 1 uruk_pikeman remaining. Battle score for attacker is 40 Casualties for Gondor: 3 man_at_armss Casualties for Mordor: 5 snaga_skirmishers and 4 uruk_pikemen Non Combat Move - Gondor 1 man_at_arms moved from Lossarnach to An贸rien 1 spearman moved from Sirith to Pelennor Fields 1 man_at_arms and 3 spearmen moved from Lebennin to Minas Tirith 1 spearman moved from West Gondor to Pinnath Gelin 1 spearman moved from Dunharrow to West Gondor 1 oathbreaker moved from Harrowdale to Paths of the Dead 7 oathbreakers moved from Harrowdale to Entwade 5 swan_knights moved from Lebennin to Sirith 9 man_at_armss and 1 spearman moved from Gilrain to Sirith 2 dromunds moved from sz 22 to sz 21 Place Units - Gondor 8 tower_guards placed in Minas Tirith 2 tower_guards placed in Edhellond 1 man_at_arms placed in Edhellond Turn Complete - Gondor Gondor collect 63 PUs; end with 63 PUs 1 unit repaired.Combat Hit Differential Summary :
Mordor : -0.17 Gondor : -0.58
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 馃挆
Register Login