Roger's Scenario Thread

RogerCooper

@rogercooper
Scenario Camp David 1956
Download Repository
Description The Suez crisis of 1956

Good Points

Shows some of the political constraints of the actors in the crisis
Low unit density

Bad Points

Victor conditions not implemented
Political constraints confuse AI
The Jordanian front is too important

RogerCooper

Scenario WWIIv3 1941 Free Tech
Download from Repository as WW2v3_Variants
Description The AA50-41 scenario with each power getting a free tech on turn 1 and other techs on later turns

Good Points

You get to see some tech

Bad Points

The tech tends to be more useful to the Axis and the Russian get little free tech (only 1 every 8 turns compared to 1 every 3 turns for Germany)

RogerCooper

Scenario Camp David-1967
Download from Repository as Camp David
Description The 1967 Arab-Israeli War (6 day war)

Good Points

No unusual units or rules
AI plays well
Interesting situation, Israelis start stronger and have central position, Arabs have higher production
Small board, fast play time

Bad Points

TripleA system not a good match for a brief war
Israel;s advantage in air power and command control not reflected.
Victory conditions not implemented

RogerCooper

@rogercooper
Scenario Fantastic Forces
Download Download
Description An iincomplete fantasy scenario

Good Points

Some nice unit art

Bad Points

Most features not implemented
All units have same stats

RogerCooper

@rogercooper
Scenario Russian Civil War (3 players)
Download Download
Description The Russian Civil War

Good Points

Interesting historical situation
Unusual units used in the war such as Armored Trains and Tanchakas

Bad Points

Can build in any territory
Excessive unit density
No victory conditions implemented

Cernel

@rogercooper I don't think being able to build in any territories should be, per se, a bad point. It's a choice. I'm also making a medieval map, in which you can do that, as that seems at least more reasonable than having 1 or 2 territories raising armies and all the other ones not.

RogerCooper

@cernel Having factories in every territory essentially eliminates logistics. The need to wait for your reinforcements to reach the front creates a de facto logistics limitation. This is an important part of the game.

Factories also provide an important and interesting intermediate level target. The decision to build a factory becomes an important strategic decision.

As for realism, centralized factories are even more realistic in the medieval period. Consider how the need to march armies from southern England to Scotland made the conquest of Scotland difficult for the English. Even in the 16th century, the Ottoman empire had to assemble its forces in Edirne for its campaigns against Austria, resulting in a short campaign season and Austrian victory. Only the most sophisticated pre-industrial states could assemble large armies at a location other than a capital.

So I think from both realism and game interest, expensive factories add to the game. Note that the Russian Civil War was full of major offensives that collapsed partially because of logistical problems.

RogerCooper

@rogercooper
Scenario Pact of Steel V3 Rules
Download In repository under Pact of Steel Variations
Description Modified version of AAR

Good Points

Fast-playing straightforward scenario

Bad Points

Axis is too strong

Cernel

@rogercooper Wasn't Fantastic Forces just the old name of Elemental Forces? I don't think a map has to be considered unfinished if during the development its name was changed, thus not further developed with the old name (tho I cannot say if the current 1.0 is that finished). Mostly assuming here, as the Download link doesn't work for me.

RogerCooper

@cernel said in Roger's Scenario Thread:

@rogercooper Wasn't Fantastic Forces just the old name of Elemental Forces? I don't think a map has to be considered unfinished if during the development its name was changed, thus not further developed with the old name (tho I cannot say if the current 1.0 is that finished). Mostly assuming here, as the Download link doesn't work for me.
Yes, Elemental Forces does seem to be the developed version of the same mod.

RogerCooper

Added to Wiki, World War II Global 1940 Balanced Mod3

RogerCooper

@rogercooper
Scenario World in Conflict-1941
Download Download
Description A WW2 scenario on a new map

Good Points

Interesting Map
Plays fairly fast

Bad Points

Too many unit types
Unit types not well balanced
Sea Areas show black
No victory conditions

RogerCooper

Added article on Tiberian Conquest EU to wiki

redrum

@rogercooper Download doesn't seem to work for World in Conflict-1941.

RogerCooper

@redrum I need to World in Conflict, then I will reload it,

RogerCooper

@RogerCooper

Scenario Great War-TLS-March 1918

Download Download

Description The last year of World War One

Good Points

Interesting situation, with the Bolsheviks as an AI-controlled wild card, spamming infantry and attacking both sides
The US has a factory in France, rather than conducting long convoys.

Bad Points

Slow-moving units on a large map
The map uses insets, which is either irrelevant (Germany's African colonies) or disruptive, an inset map dividing Eastern France into many small areas.

This game idea would have worked better on a conventional European map, with faster movement but limited combat rounds.

RogerCooper

@RogerCooper
Scenario The Rising Sun

Download In repository under high quality mods

Description The Pacific War from 1941 on

Good Points

A detailed Pacific War scenario
Income spread through out the map

Bad Points

Many ahistorical elements such as
Russia in the war immediately
US lacks a big income advantage
The logistical difficulties of interior Asia are not reflected
The lack of naval bases slows down naval movement

RogerCooper

@RogerCooper
Scenario NSP v4

Download link text

Description An alternate history scenario where Russia is in the Axis & Japan with the Allies, using AA42 map

Good Points

Simple, fast-playing scenario

Bad Ppints

Favors the Allies

RogerCooper

Scenario Cold War-1965

Download download

Description A hypothetical World War III in 1965 with China as a third side

Good Points

Distinctive unit art
Some WW3 specific units
Arab League as Soviet ally diversifies play some
Map follows power-war boundaries

Bad Points

Large, slow-playing map
No victory conditions
Nuclear weapons are in the game, but not cost-effective
It is hard to stop the Soviets from overrunning Europe and then hard for the Americans to get back in.

RogerCooper

My complete scenario list:

Scenario
=ATARI=
=TC.ARENA_FFA=
=TC.BLITZKRIEG2=
=TC.EUTOPIA=
=TC.FRONT=
=TC.ISLANDS.FFA=
=TC.ISLANDS=
=TC.NAVAL ARENA FFA=
=TC.NAVAL ARENA=
=TC.RIVER=
=TC.SEABLITZ North VS South=
1914-COW-Empires
1939_Pact_of_Steel_Big_World
1941
2013 Conflict
2013 Conflict FFA
2013 Conflict FFA-Error
2020
270BC
270BC 40%
270BC Cernel Mod
270BC Cernel Variant
270BC Tertiered
300BC
41 Oztea
41 Oztea Island
41 Oztea Militia
41 Oztea SBR
41 Oztea SBR Militia
4th Ed. Cold War 1950
5 If By Sea
AA Enhanced Revised
AA41-2 FreeCiv Art
AA42-2_FreeCiv_Art
AA42-2_Military_Symbols
AA42-BuildCaps
AA50-41-Build Caps
AA50-42-Build Caps
AA50-Europe
AA50-realistic
AAC-BuildCaps
AAR-BuildCaps
Age of Tribes: Classical
Age of Tribes: Cold War
Age of Tribes: Modern
Age of Tribes: Primeval
Age of Tribes: Renaissance
Age_Of_The_Sturlungs_0.0.2
Age_Of_The_Sturlungs_0.0.3
Alagaësia (2 players)
Alagaësia (4 players)
Ancient Times
Anglo-American_Nazi_War
Another World
Anti Imperialism
Apocalypse: 2012
Arnhem
Axis and Allies Global 1939-Midnight Express
Axisgeneral's 1939 v2.0
Bad-Ass 4-Nation FFA
Barbarossa
Battle of Aventurica
Battle of Iwo Jima
Battle of Jutland
Belgium Provincial war
Belgium Provincial war-2A
Big World : 1942
Big World : 1942 - Factions
Big World : 1942 - Factions (Allies)
Big World : 1942 - Factions (Axis)
Big World : 1942 v3 Rules
Big World : June 1942
Big World : NekahNet's 1939
Big World : Small's 1939
Big World 2 : Balance of Power
Big World 2 : Rise of the Axis
Big World: 1942 - Logistics Mod
Big World: 1942 - Logistics Mod (No Supply Lines)
Big World: April 1940
Blood and Iron
Blue vs. Gray
Britannia: Roman_Invasion
Britannia: Roman_Invasion-Alliances
Britannia: Roman_Invasion-Alliances Alternative
Broken Earth
Camp David: 1948 Arab-Israeli War
Camp David: 1956 Suez Crisis
Camp David: 1967 Six-Day War
Camp David: 1973 Yom Kippur War
Capture The Flag
Caravan
Caribbean Trade War
CCLXXbc
Chess
China vs Russia
Civil War: A House Divided
Civil War: Eastern Campaigns
Classic: Anzio
Classic: Battleship Row
Classic: Four If By Sea
Classic: Gold
Classic: Iron Blitz 1939A Historical
Classic: Iron Blitz 1939B RussiaInTheAxis
Classic: Iron Blitz 1939C US Stands Apart
Classic: Iron Blitz 1942A Russia Neutral
Classic: Iron Blitz 1945A Russia And Japan
Classic: Iron Blitz 1945B Aggressive Russia
Classic: Iron Blitz 2rd Edition
Classic: Iron Blitz 3rd Edition
Classic: Iron Blitz Cold War
Classic: Kremlin
Classic: Omaha
Classic: Sword
Classic: Utah
Cold War
Cold War Asia: 1948
Cold War Asia: 1948+Japan
Cold War: 1965
Cold_War_1950_4th_edition
ColdWar-Revised
command and conquer
CTF2 Colors
CTF2 Future Warfare
CTF2 Good Versus Evil
CTF2 Medieval
CTF2 WW2
Cybertank
Darkest Hour
D-Day
D-Day 2
Death From Above
Diplomacy
Diplomacy: FFA Great War
Diplomacy: FFA V3 Rules
Diplomacy: WW1
Domination
Domination 1901
Domination 1914 NML Navalland
Domination 1914 No Man's Land
Domination 1914-Weltpolitik
Domination_1914_Blood_And_Steel
Downfall-July1944
Dragon War
Eastern Front vs AI
Eastern Front vs Humans
Eight Army Free For All
Eight Army Free For All-adoY
Election_Usa 2 Player Game
Election_Usa 3 Player Game
Election_Usa Base Game
Elemental_Forces
Eleven Army Free For All
Empire
empty hexes 65x20 modding resource
Europe - Alpha
Europe - Alpha v3 Rules
Europe - Revised
European War
Fantastic Forces
Feudal Japan
Feudal Japan 2
Feudal Japan Warlords 3 Player
Feudal Japan Warlords 4 or 2 Player
Feudal Japan Warlords 5 Player
Finnish Winter War
First Punic War
Franco-Prussian War
Game_of_Thrones
Game_of_Thrones_v2
GangLandNYC
Genuine 39
Gilbert-1939-AAE-3A
Gilbert-1939-AAE-4P
Gilbert-1939-AAE-6P
Global 1940 House Rules
Global 1940 House Rules with Canada
Global 40 House Rules
Global 40 House Rules with Canada
Global War
Global War 2
Global War v3 Rules
GoT
Great Lakes War WW2v2
Great Lakes War WW2v3
Great Lakes War WW2v3-Alliances
Great War
Great War-TLS-March1918
Greyhawk
Greyhawk Wars
Hearts of Iron 2: Clash Of The Titans-Winter1942
Hearts of Iron 2: Turning tide-1943
Hearts of Iron: Awakening the giant
Hearts of Iron: Fatherland
Hearts of Iron: The Rising Sun 1942
Hearts of Iron2_Lion's Den_1944
Hearts of Iron2_Operation Barbarossa
HeartsOfIron2-Europe
Hellas: Athens vs. Sparta (beta)
HellGate Europe 1944
HexGlobe FFA
HexGlobe FFA w TWW
Hot War-1956
House of Habsburg
Imperialism FFA
Invasion U.S.A.
Invasion U.S.A. - Apocalypse
Iron War
Iron War (BETA)
Iron War: Europe
Jurassic
Kremlin-AAC
Large Middle Earth - Third Age All Stars
Lord of the Rings: Middle Earth
Lord of the Rings: Middle Earth - Fords
Master of Empire
Master of Europa
Medieval_Europe
mewww
mewww-Alliances
Middle Earth - Battle for Arda
Middle Earth 2 - Tofumod
Middle East
Minimap
Napoleonic Empires
Napoleonic Empires: FFA 5 Player
Napoleonic Empires: FFA 8 Player
Nazi Soviet Pact
NekahNet's 1939
Neusch. DH's Ultimate FFA
Neuschwabenland
Neuschwabenland FFA
Neuschwabenland North vs South
New World Order
New World Order 1939 Lebowski
New World Order 5 Nations
New World Order Variant - Neutrals
NewWorldOrder1915Lebowski
newyawk
newyawk-Law and Order
Nine Army Free For All
NM'sL-wip
NM'sL-wip (blank slate)
No Man's Land Navalland
Nova Games Edition
NSP v4
NWO CANADA 1939
NWO DoomsDay
NWO Smalls
NWO VICHY 1941
NWO:Finest Hour_The Tipping point 1942
NWO_Andrew's
NWO_Eastern_Front
Oil Wars
Ozteas 1941 Global Setup
Pacific
Pacific - Alpha
Pacific Theater Solo Challenge
Pacific: 1942
Pacific-The Rising Sun 1941
Pact of Steel
Pact of Steel 2
Pact of Steel v3 rules
Pact of Steel: China Added
Pearl Harbor 1941
Peninsula_Campaign
RC_Example_FFA
RC_Example_Teams
Red Sun Over China
Revised Middle Earth
Revised With Cavalry
Risk
Rome Total War
Russian Civil War (2 players)
Russian Civil War (3 players)
Russian Civil War (6 players)
Russian_Spring
Second World War
sengokuJidai
Seven Army Free For All
Six Army 2 Alliance
Six Army 3 Alliance
Six Army Free For All
Six Army Free For All: Classic
Sleeping Giant
Small Balanced 2 Player across
Small Balanced 2 Player sidebyside
Small Balanced 4 Player
Small Balanced 4 Player Teams
Small's 1939
Spoils of War
Stalingrad
Star Trek: Dilithium War
Star Wars: Galactic War
Star Wars: Galactic War (4 teams)
Star Wars: Galactic War (FFA)
Star Wars: Tatooine War
Star Wars: Tatooine War (4 teams)
Star Wars: Tatooine War (FFA)
Steampunk 1915
Stellar Forces
TAW_Carthage_Campaign
TAW_Roman_Campaign
TD-Kings Hill
Ten Army Free For All
TerrraFirma
Test1
The Grand War
The Grand War Free for All
The Great Northern War
The Great War-Ultimate
The Rising Sun
The Rising Sun WW2v2 paratrooper edition
The Rising Sun WW2v3
The Rising Sun WW2v3 AA boats edition
The World At War 1939
The World At War 1941
Thirteen Army Free For All
Tiberian Conquest AU
Tiberian Conquest EU
Tiberian Conquest SA
Total World War: December 1941
Total World War: December 1941 BETA
Total World War: USA
Total_Ancient_War
TripleA Classic Revised
Tutorial
Twelve Army Free For All
Twilight Imperium 1v1
Twilight Imperium 5player
U-Boat's 1939
Ultimate P Talibush 7 Alliances
Ultimate P Talibush FFA
Ultimate P Talibush Mod
Ultimate Pants
Ultimate Pants: ww2v3
Ultimate World
Ultimate World v3 Rules
Ultimate World: Expanded
Ultimate World: Revised
UNDER SIEGE: America
Ur-Quan Slave War: Masters Edition
V3_VC_Factories
V3_VC_Factories_China_to_USA
V3_VC_Factories_China_to_USA-Error
Vietnam
Viking
Viking 2
War of Nations 3.0 Final
War of the Lance
War of the Relics
Warlords FFA
WAW 1940
wd_Libya
Wolfy's 1939,First Strike
World At War
World At War Variant - FUEL-AA-Range
World At War Variant - v3
World At War Variant - vXXX
World At War Variant - vXXX old
World in conflict-1941
World War 2010
World War I 1914
World War II Classic
World War II Classic 3rd Edition
World War II Empty Start
World War II Europe 1940 2nd Edition
World War II Europe 1940 Original
World War II Global 1940 2nd Edition
World War II Global 1940 Alpha 3
World War II Global 1940 Balanced Mod
World War II Global 1940 Balanced Mod3
World War II Global 1940 Original
World War II Global 1940 Ryuzaki's Special Setup
World War II Global 1942 2nd Edition
World War II Pacific 1940 2nd Edition
World War II Pacific 1940 Original
World War II Revised
World War II Revised LHTR
World War II Revised: Death's Hand Mod
World War II v3 1941
World War II v3 1941 v2
World War II v3 1941-Build Caps
World War II v3 1942
World War II v3 1942-Build Caps
World War II v4
World War II v4-New Art
World War II v5 1942 2nd Ed. (High Production Mod)
World War II v5 1942 Second Edition
World War II v6 1941
WW2 NWO 2.0 Neutrals
WW2 NWO 2.0 Neutrals Assigned
WW2 NWO 3.0 Neutrals
WW2 NWO 3.0 Neutrals-Assigned
WW2 NWO Neutrals Politics
WW2 Phillipines - v2
WW2v4 Six Army Free For All
WW2v4 Six Army Free For All v2
WW3 Circa 1955
WWII Europe 1940 Original SeaLion-Balanced
WWII Nazi Threat
WWII Pacific 1940 Original J1-Balanced
WWII Revised 7 powers by hoshi head
WWII Revised 7 powers by hoshi head-error
WWIIv3 1939 - 11 Nations Mod
WWIIv3 1940 - 11 Nations Mod
WWIIv3 1941 - 11 Nations Mod
WWIIv3 1941 China Mod
WWIIv3 1941 Free Tech
WWIIv3 1941 Move-Buy-Move
WWIIv3 1941 Move-Then-Buy
WWIIv3 1941 Tech Advance
WWIIv3 1941 UK Factory
WWIIv3 1942 - 11 Nations Mod
WWIIv3 1942 Move-Buy-Move
WWIIv3 1942 Move-Then-Buy
WWIIv3 3 Alliances
WWIIv3 FFA
WWIIv6 Factory
WWIIv6 No Capital
Zombieland
ZombielandUSA