Question about trenches domination 1914 no mans land

wc_sumpton

@Ramon said:

Is there a mechanic or attachment that allows a 0 attack unit to destroy a 0 defense construction?

The "trench", a 0 defense construction unit, could give the "conscript", a 0 attack unit, a plus 1 attack using support attachments. The problem with this is that the support should be applied only when the "trench" is defending and only the "conscript" is attacking.

	<attachment name="supportAttachment_Trench" attachTo="trench" javaClass="UnitSupportAttachment" type="unitType">
		<option name="faction" value="enemy"/>
		<option name="unitType" value="conscript"/>
		<option name="side" value="defence"/>
		<option name="dice" value="strength"/>
		<option name="bonus" value="1"/>
		<option name="number" value="1"/>
		<option name="bonusType" value="Trench"/>
		<option name="players" value="$All-Players$"/>
	</attachment>

To do this a plus and minus support attachment would have to be created for every attacking/defending land unit to create a counter to the "trench".

	<attachment name="supportAttachment_InfantryAttack" attachTo="infantry" javaClass="UnitSupportAttachment" type="unitType">
		<option name="faction" value="allied"/>
		<option name="unitType" value="conscript"/>
		<option name="side" value="offence"/>
		<option name="dice" value="strength"/>
		<option name="bonus" value="1"/>
		<option name="number" value="-1"/>
		<!-- All positive supports are "Trench" -->
		<option name="bonusType" value="Trench"/>
		<option name="players" value="$All-Players$"/>
	</attachment>
	<attachment name="supportAttachment_InfantryAttackDebuf" attachTo="infantry" javaClass="UnitSupportAttachment" type="unitType">
		<option name="faction" value="allied"/>
		<option name="unitType" value="conscript"/>
		<option name="side" value="offence"/>
		<option name="dice" value="strength"/>
		<option name="bonus" value="-1"/>
		<option name="number" value="-1"/>
		<!-- All negative supports are "Debuf" -->
		<option name="bonusType" value="Debuf"/>
		<option name="players" value="$All-Players$"/>
	</attachment>
	<attachment name="supportAttachment_InfantryDefend" attachTo="infantry" javaClass="UnitSupportAttachment" type="unitType">
		<option name="faction" value="enemy"/>
		<option name="unitType" value="conscript"/>
		<option name="side" value="defence"/>
		<option name="dice" value="strength"/>
		<option name="bonus" value="1"/>
		<option name="number" value="-1"/>
		<!-- All positive supports are "Trench" -->
		<option name="bonusType" value="Trench"/>
		<option name="players" value="$All-Players$"/>
	</attachment>
	<attachment name="supportAttachment_InfantryDefendDebuf" attachTo="infantry" javaClass="UnitSupportAttachment" type="unitType">
		<option name="faction" value="enemy"/>
		<option name="unitType" value="conscript"/>
		<option name="side" value="defence"/>
		<option name="dice" value="strength"/>
		<option name="bonus" value="-1"/>
		<option name="number" value="-1"/>
		<!-- All negative supports are "Debuf" -->
		<option name="bonusType" value="Debuf"/>
		<option name="players" value="$All-Players$"/>
	</attachment>

It can get slightly complicated.

Cheers...

Ramon

@wc_sumpton

Hi WC!

Thanks a lot for your time and effort!

If i understand correctly you can basically give conscripts 1 attack, and make every unit (except trenches) debuff them with 1?

I have 2 more questions:

-can i make tech dice basically hit every time (so they hit at 1 or higher, basically you pay 20 ipcs for guarenteed tech unlock)
-for a unit such as a marine can i give it +1 amphibious attack?

~Ramon

Ramon

found the marine!

sometimes it can be so easy

beelee

@Ramon said:

-can i make tech dice basically hit every time (so they hit at 1 or higher, basically you pay 20 ipcs for guarenteed tech unlock)

Hi

The answer is yes but I can't find an example at the moment. Roger, The Dog or the Master wc will clue you in most likely

but it has something to do with "rolls" and "chance' if i remember right.

From POS2

Screenshot from 2026-09-18 08-49-37.png

so something like that

wc_sumpton

@Ramon said:

-can i make tech dice basically hit every time (so they hit at 1 or higher, basically you pay 20 ipcs for guarenteed tech unlock)

  <property name="Low Luck for Technology" value="true" editable="true">
     <boolean/>
   </property>

Give the player the number of dice equal to "diceSides".

@Ramon said:

<option name="isMarine" value="true"/>

"isMarine" takes a number value. "isMarine"=true is converter to "isMarine"=1. "isMarine" can also be set to negative values.

@Ramon said:

If i understand correctly you can basically give conscripts 1 attack, and make every unit (except trenches) debuff them with 1?

Yea.. but upon further testing, because both units are 0, the buff was not applied, so I'm still working on this.

wc_sumpton said:

It can get slightly complicated.

Cheers...

Ramon

@wc_sumpton

Hi Wc,

Thanks a lot for your time!

I hope im not asking too much but i still cant figure the tech dice system.

I understand that i have to turn on low luck for tech.
We use 6 diceSides so 20 ipc cost should give 6 dices.

I first tried this:

To be honest i tried to copy it straight from the production rule for "normal" units.

But this doesnt work, the engine doesnt recognize the property definition for the option "resource Count"

Im kinda lost now, do you know how to implement this? We basically want 20 IPC to give the player enough tech dice for a guaranteed unlock.

Another question:

We want to create an unit called the Flying Boat, which is basically an airplane but the airplane:

Can land only on water, not on land
move through hostile sea zones, ignoring enemy ships
be able to move after fighting in a battle (if they still have range left over)
be able to attack land territories

So far i figured out how to make planes "land" on sea (putting their carriercost at 0)

Now obviously this is still considered a air unit by the engine, it can move through hostile seazones, it can move after fighting in a battle and it can attack land territories.

The problem is that it can obviously still land on land, which we dont want.

but do you know if its theoretically possible to make the unit unable to land on land?

~Cheers!

beelee

@Ramon

you might be able to use a negative terrain resource. I think that's how you do it. Might check Total World War. Pretty sure they have certain territories that certain units can't go to depending on terrain and or weather.

wc_sumpton

@Ramon said:

<attachmentList>
<attachment name="techAttachment" attachTo="Japanese" javaClass="TechAttachment" type="player">
<cost resource="PUs" quantity="20"/>
<result resourceOrUnit="techTokens" quantity="6"/>
<option name="resourceCount" value="6"/>
</attachment>

Is this trying to setup techTokens for purchase through the purchase screen or is this trying to give Japanese 6 techTokens and remove 20 PUs. Either way this has nothing to do with techs.
To give Japanese 6 techTokens:

	<attachment name="triggerAttachment_Give_Japanese_6_techTokens" attachTo="Japanese" javaClass="TriggerAttachment" type="player">
		<option name="conditions" value="conditionAttachment_Give_Japanese_6_techTokens"/>
		<option name="resource" value="techTokens"/>
		<option name="resourceCount" value="6"/>
		<option name="when" value="before:JapaneseTech"/>
	</attachment>

To remove 20 PUs:

	<attachment name="triggerAttachment_Take_20_PUs_From_Japanese" attachTo="Japanese" javaClass="TriggerAttachment" type="player">
		<option name="conditions" value="conditionAttachment_Give_Japanese_6_techTokens"/>
		<option name="resource" value="PUs"/>
		<option name="resourceCount" value="-20"/>
		<option name="when" value="before:JapaneseTech"/>
	</attachment>

For this to work correctly, it has to be in 2 different attachments. Combining them will use only the last "resourceCount":

	<attachment name="triggerAttachment_Give_Take_From_Japanese" attachTo="Japanese" javaClass="TriggerAttachment" type="player">
		<option name="conditions" value="conditionAttachment_Give_Japanese_6_techTokens"/>
		<option name="resource" value="techTokens"/>
		<option name="resourceCount" value="6"/>
		<option name="resource" value="PUs"/>
		<option name="resourceCount" value="-20"/>
		<option name="when" value="before:JapaneseTech"/>
	</attachment>

Will subtract 20 PUs and subtract 20 techTokens.

Cheers...

wc_sumpton

@Ramon said:

The problem is that it can obviously still land on land, which we dont want.

but do you know if its theoretically possible to make the unit unable to land on land?

Sorry, but this is going to have to be player enforce. There is only one way, that I know of, that allows air units to fly over a territory that could block the landing of that air unit in the same territory and it deals with relationshipTypes.

Cheers...

VictoryFirst

@ramon Yeah the fact that they can attack land but cannot land on it makes it virtually impossible. It can be done, but it will result in any air unit not being able to land on land, not just the Flying Boat. The other option would be to disallow the Flying Boat to enter land altogether.

Ramon

@wc_sumpton

Hi WC,

Thanks a lot for your response!

If i understand correctly this forces the japanese player to buy 6 dice for 20 ipc each round right?

Is it possible to give the player a choice? either buy 6 dice or dont buy any?

Cheers!

Ramon

@VictoryFirst

Hi Victory,

Thanks for your response!

Is disallowing the flying boats to attack and land on land altogether relatively easy? If so how can this be done?