TripleA Logo TripleA Forum
    • TripleA Website
    • Recent
    • Popular
    • Register
    • Login

    Flames and Steel (official thread)

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Maps & Mods
    322 Posts 8 Posters 768 Views 5 Watching
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • K
      KurtGodel7 Lobby Moderators @Cernel
      last edited by

      @Cernel said:

      @KurtGodel7 said:

      @Cernel said:

      @KurtGodel7 said:

      Also, some planes were harder to shoot down than others, and this is reflected in me giving some airplanes more hitpoints than others.

      I guess your are not doing it, but it would be good if you split the heavy bombers available since start game at least into two different units, one mainly representing the Avro Lancaster and the other one mainly representing the B-17 (and the B-24 too if you don't want to split in 3) (I'm not talking about other future/tech ones like the B-29). The B-17 should have more hit-points and more defensive power than the Avro Lancaster, but the Avro Lancaster should have a slightly bigger bombing power (not much). This can be balanced by making the Avro Lancaster cheaper (whether or not this is the case) or just letting the United States have an advantage in heavy bombers over Britain.

      The initial strategic bomber is the same for all nations. The final version is different for each. (This includes America Pacific vs. America Atlantic.)

      America Pacific's final strategic bomber is the Liberator. America Atlantic's is the Flying Fortress. And Britain's is the Avro Lancaster. Of the three, the Avro Lancaster has the hardest hitting power, due to the "Tall Boy and Grand Slam" tech. Uniquely among the three, it can benefit from Window tech, which adds -1 to the interception value of enemy air. The Flying Fortress has the most ability to defend itself against interception. The Liberator has a longer range than a Flying Fortress. Germany, Japan, and the Soviet Union each also get their own final version of strategic bombers, though their final versions are below those of the U.K. and U.S. Japan's version is a little better than Germany's version or the Soviet Union's version.

      Wait. I saw that you had the "Superfortress" as "Strategic Bombers" tech. That would be the B-29. How is the "Flying Fortress" the final strategic bomber? That is the B-17, right?

      Ok for the Avro Lancaster and the B-24 I guess, but the B-17 in mid-to-late 1941 should be already available for purchase. I mean, I certainly agree with the United States starting with zero of them (since they were very few before Pearl Harbour) but with the ability to purchase them (unless maybe you have a progressive tech and the B-17 is like at 95% development completion or something).

      I guess you are taking into account the possibility of USA Pacific sending B-24 to fight in Atlantic, right? They have been quite important in the Mid-Atlantic gap and very important in bombing Germany.

      Some thoughts on this.

      1. For America Pacific, the final strategic bombing tech is the Superfortress. A Superfortress is a special unit: an SPC produces one every two turns. For normal bombers--i.e., those which can be purchased with PUs--the final bomber is the Liberator for America Pacific and the Flying Fortress for America Atlantic.

      2. Some of my techs have anachronistic names. Japan needs to research "Kate" tech, even though it already had Kates as of June 1941. The U.S.S.R. needs to research "KV-2" tech, even though it had KV-2s in June 1941. I hate wasting opportunities to give players tech to research. In any case, and in answer to your question, both halves of America are able to build strategic bombers at the start of the game. But those strategic bombers don't get upgraded into Flying Fortresses or Liberators until the U.S. has researched tech. Another anachronism, granted.

      V C 2 Replies Last reply
      Reply Quote 0
      • V
        Vendetta @KurtGodel7
        last edited by

        @KurtGodel7 Do you have the full tech trees written up yet or are they still work in progress?

        K 1 Reply Last reply
        Reply Quote 0
        • K
          KurtGodel7 Lobby Moderators @Vendetta
          last edited by KurtGodel7

          @Vendetta said:

          @KurtGodel7 Do you have the full tech trees written up yet or are they still work in progress?

          image.jpeg

          1 Reply Last reply
          Reply Quote 0
          • K
            KurtGodel7 Lobby Moderators
            last edited by

            image.jpeg

            image.jpeg

            image.jpeg

            image.jpeg

            image.jpeg

            1 Reply Last reply
            Reply Quote 0
            • K
              KurtGodel7 Lobby Moderators
              last edited by

              image.jpeg

              image.jpeg

              image.jpeg

              image.jpeg

              C 1 Reply Last reply
              Reply Quote 0
              • C
                Cernel Moderators Lobby Moderators @KurtGodel7
                last edited by

                @KurtGodel7 Maybe having an option like in Classic (but historical) that the game can be started with techs already got? Meaning that, if that option is enabled, United States start with the B-17 tech already in the bag, and other players also have tech too if those tech were already got or mostly developed by the time the game starts?

                (Even though the B-17 did very little in Pacific, it feels a bit wrong that is not going to be there as part of the Pacific forces, though I guess USA Atlantic can send B-17 in Pacific if wanted.)

                1 Reply Last reply
                Reply Quote 1
                • K
                  KurtGodel7 Lobby Moderators
                  last edited by

                  Apparently I've uploaded too many files at one time and should try again later. But the above is a lot of the techs.

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  Reply Quote 0
                  • C
                    Cernel Moderators Lobby Moderators @KurtGodel7
                    last edited by

                    @KurtGodel7 Sorry to repeat, but the B-17 was way more protected and protective than the Avro Lancaster. It was way harder to down a B-17 than an Avro Lancaster. I suggest it having +2 hit-points. (Also, the B-17 was some more of a fortress than the B-24, but the difference here is much less than with the much weaker Avro Lancaster.)

                    1 Reply Last reply
                    Reply Quote 0
                    • V
                      Vendetta
                      last edited by

                      @KurtGodel7 said:

                      Apparently I've uploaded too many files at one time and should try again later. But the above is a lot of the techs.

                      Cool.

                      Rail Guns should definitely be Railway guns - they’re two rather different things 😉

                      Mobile warfare and armored warfare make those two sound a little better

                      If you want some flavor on the Italian/Japanese tank unlock tech, use Carro Armato for Italy and Sensha for Japan (just means tank but in the local language).

                      Pershing tank could be M26 Pershing and Britain could use their A numbers (A22 Churchill, A34 Comet, A41 Centurion) if you want them to look a little more polished. KV-1 is a better fit than KV-2, lot more of the -1 were built.

                      Merchant Marine -> Propulsion Advancements (merchant marine sounds like transport tech)
                      Fleet Action -> Advanced Fire Control
                      Improved Sub -> Improved Submarines
                      Shipyards -> Shipyard Improvements
                      Dockyards -> Dockyard Expansion
                      Undersea War -> Undersea Warfare

                      Kate -> B5N Kate
                      Jill -> B6N Jill
                      Emily -> H8K Emily

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      Reply Quote 1
                      • K
                        KurtGodel7 Lobby Moderators
                        last edited by

                        image.jpeg

                        image.jpeg

                        image.jpeg

                        image.jpeg

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        Reply Quote 0
                        • K
                          KurtGodel7 Lobby Moderators
                          last edited by

                          image.jpeg

                          image.jpeg

                          image.jpeg

                          image.jpeg

                          image.jpeg

                          Upload limit reached.

                          V 1 Reply Last reply
                          Reply Quote 0
                          • K
                            KurtGodel7 Lobby Moderators
                            last edited by

                            Recent changes:

                            Created the "colonial militia" unit. This is for Britain only, and is basically a conscript by another name. Britain cannot build this unit. But by researching tech it receives this unit for free for India. Three per turn with the Raj tech. Once Britain researches Expand India Army (or whatever I decided to call that tech) it gets six of these a turn for free, on India.

                            @vendetta suggested better names for some of the techs. Rail guns tech is now railway guns. (Good call on that, btw.) Other tech names have changed as well, reflective Vendetta's suggestions.

                            @cernel suggested the idea of starting the game with certain techs already researched, much like Classic would do depending on the option you chose. I have this on my list of needed changes.

                            @schulz suggested changes to the map itself, and provided example maps to use. I devoted precious weekly usage to this task. (Even though I was already at 40% of weekly usage just 24 hours into my week.) I have had AI alter the Europe/Mediterranean/West Russia part of my map using the example Schulz provided.

                            Earlier in this thread someone mentioned an incorrect border in Europe, which I think is now fixed. But there is also the problem of territory labels: West Prussia, Posen, etc. The problem I'm running into is that I want a territory to have the name Danzig, given the importance of Danzig to the start of the war. Labeling a territory Danzig maybe displaces where you might want the West Prussia label, so then the latter finds its way into the second-best location.

                            @cernel wants the differences between the Lancaster, Flying Fortress, and Liberator to be accurately reflected in the stats for those three bomber types. Claude believes this is already achieved by current unit stats. I will have to double check Claude on this. America Pacific gets the Liberator, America Atlantic gets the Flying Fortress, and Britain of course gets the Lancaster.

                            Light tanks were too easily confused with tanks, so I've used scout car logo art for light tanks. I hate doing that, but if I'm confused by a light tank icon versus a normal tank icon, other people will be confused too.

                            The reason why I consumed so much weekly usage so quickly was in large part to fix GUI problems associated with changes to the air system. Those GUI problems appear to be solved.

                            1 Reply Last reply
                            Reply Quote 1
                            • V
                              Vendetta @KurtGodel7
                              last edited by

                              @KurtGodel7
                              Hilfswilliger was the name for the local auxiliaries that Germany recruited in Russia, would be a good fit for "Crush communism."

                              Panzerschreck for Advanced Panzerfaust?

                              Sturmgewehr for assault rifle

                              The B-52 is way too far ahead of the timeline, didn't enter service until the 1950s. Use the B-45 Tornado, that was America's earliest jet bomber.

                              Go 229 is the flying wing model.

                              K 1 Reply Last reply
                              Reply Quote 1
                              • K
                                KurtGodel7 Lobby Moderators
                                last edited by

                                image.jpeg

                                What Claude had to say about territory names:


                                Renaming Pomerania to West Prussia: I’d advise against it. Your map’s Pomerania sits on the coast just northeast of Berlin and west of Danzig. That’s the Stettin–Köslin area, which really was the Prussian province of Pomerania. West Prussia was the Vistula region around Danzig, Thorn and Bromberg, south of Danzig and west of Warsaw. That’s exactly where your West Prussia territory already is. Only one of your names is debatable: the coastal strip between Danzig and Koenigsberg (Elbing, Marienburg) was West Prussian before 1920 and became part of East Prussia from 1920. For a 1941 map, “East Prussia” is right.


                                C 1 Reply Last reply
                                Reply Quote 0
                                • K
                                  KurtGodel7 Lobby Moderators
                                  last edited by

                                  image.jpeg

                                  image.jpeg

                                  image.jpeg

                                  image.jpeg

                                  Note that Britain's list is now replaced with some new techs. "Raj" gives one colonial militia for each of India's three most valuable territories. Increased Indian Army means those territories now produce 2 colonial militia each turn.

                                  image.jpeg

                                  image.jpeg

                                  Marines (America Pacific) can be built from the start. America Atlantic cannot research Superfortress or B-52.

                                  image.jpeg

                                  That's it for the tech list for now. Expect this list to become out-of-date soon after being posted, however.

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  Reply Quote 0
                                  • M
                                    malmessi @KurtGodel7
                                    last edited by

                                    @KurtGodel7 said:

                                    On TripleA, I will sometimes be a spectator for Total World War (TWW). I saw the exact same type of thinking which led to Totaler Krieg. Terrain effects. Lots of special rules. I've been told that TWW takes about 2 - 3 times longer to play than Domination 1914 No Man's Land (NML). But, a game of TWW doesn't give you any more strategic depth than NML. TWW asks for double or triple the player's time, without providing anything more in exchange for all that extra time.

                                    Please. let me disagree.
                                    TWW is the best game on TripleA at the moment. I have played a lot of games and we (me and 2 italian friends) all agree that TWW is the top.
                                    Maybe there is soem Player Enforced Rule that requires edit mode nbut this is a techical issue of the engine.
                                    I strongly suggest you to give TWW a try, I'm offering to help you, you will appreciate it !
                                    Terrain effects are realistic and add no extra brain-effort, you just have to use BATT CALC before every battle, but I use B.C. every time even when playing other games.
                                    About special rules, I think that tech in TWW are easier than in Flames&Steel (if I undesrtood F&S tech rules) and also the part about airplanes, in TWW it is like in any other TripleA game so the effort to understand rules regarding air battles in F&S is higher than in TWW. In TWW you just have 4 standard fighting type of planes instead of basic 1/2 in other games.

                                    Please let me know if you want to try TWW and you won't be disappointed, trust me.

                                    K 1 Reply Last reply
                                    Reply Quote 0
                                    • C
                                      Cernel Moderators Lobby Moderators @KurtGodel7
                                      last edited by

                                      @KurtGodel7 How about if I make a full set of names changes for the Great German Realm and you ask Claude about what it thinks on the whole new set of names compared to the current one for 1941 Germany? Would that be feasible? (I mean not name per name but all together.)

                                      K 1 Reply Last reply
                                      Reply Quote 1
                                      • SchulzS
                                        Schulz
                                        last edited by

                                        AI does not look good at drawing maps, territories, and naming things. Like Krakow being connected to Konigsberg through the northeast while bypassing Warsaw makes no sense at this map's scale. Or Kiev bordering Krakow.

                                        Also, for consistency, it is better to name every land territory with its biggest city, like Prague instead of Bohemia. Having impassable Pripet Marshes would be great, too.

                                        K V 2 Replies Last reply
                                        Reply Quote 1
                                        • K
                                          KurtGodel7 Lobby Moderators
                                          last edited by

                                          Recent changes to Flames and Steel:

                                          1. SPCs have been nerfed. They now produce 1 special unit every two turns. (Or one every four turns if it's Superfortresses.)
                                          2. Speer's industrialization has been nerfed. An SPC produces a free Panther once every two turns.
                                          3. SPC maxes have been changed. When the U.S. got chopped in half it gained +1 to the SPC limit. Britain and Germany have now each gained +1 to the limit as well. The new limits are these:
                                            America Atlantic: 3
                                            Britain: 2
                                            USSR:3
                                            Germany: 5
                                            Japan: 3
                                            America Pacific: 2
                                          4. Bomber stats have been changed, as per @cernel 's way of thinking. The final version of the Flying Fortress has 4 hitpoints, compared to 3 each for the Liberator and the Lancaster. The Flying Fortress and Liberator have an air defense value of 2, compared to 1 for the Lancaster. The Liberator has a range of 10, compared to 8 for the other two. The Lancaster does 5 PUs of damage for strategic bombing raids, compared to 4 PUs for the other two. The Lancaster has Window (-1 to interception value for each enemy air), the other two do not.
                                          5. Bombers can no longer be mixed nation for strategic bombing raids. Therefore, American bombers can no longer benefit from Window.
                                          6. Nerf to late game air techs, most notably for Germany and the U.S. German jets are still the best in the late game, but not to the same degree they had been. American jets lose their afterburner tech. America loses its Stratofortress tech. German flying wings are now a little easier to kill (-1 hitpoint). Germany's swept back wings tech is now nerfed. Also, a small nerf to the final version of the King Tiger.
                                          7. There is a player-selectable option for the game to start with some tech already researched. Japan gets Kate and Long Lance torpedoes, Germany gets the Stuka, the USSR gets the KV-1, Britain gets radar, America Pacific gets the Dauntless dive bomber and the Norden bombsight, America Atlantic gets the Norden bombsight and the Flying Fortress.
                                          8. Alterations to the Pacific map to create more accurate island shapes.
                                          9. Bombardment is limited to one bombardment shot per unit unloaded. (As per Anniversary Edition rules.) There is now a tech which allows this to be upgraded to two bombardment shots per unit unloaded.
                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          Reply Quote 0
                                          • K
                                            KurtGodel7 Lobby Moderators @Cernel
                                            last edited by

                                            @Cernel said:

                                            @KurtGodel7 How about if I make a full set of names changes for the Great German Realm and you ask Claude about what it thinks on the whole new set of names compared to the current one for 1941 Germany? Would that be feasible? (I mean not name per name but all together.)

                                            Yeah I'll take you up on this.

                                            1 Reply Last reply
                                            Reply Quote 0

                                            Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                            Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                            With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                            Register Login
                                            • 1
                                            • 2
                                            • 12
                                            • 13
                                            • 14
                                            • 15
                                            • 16
                                            • 17
                                            • 14 / 17
                                            • First post
                                              Last post
                                            Powered by NodeBB Forums