TripleA Logo TripleA Forum
    • TripleA Website
    • Recent
    • Popular
    • Register
    • Login

    Download Maps has map Tags

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Player Help
    80 Posts 7 Posters 153 Views 5 Watching
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • xxXEddieXxxX
      xxXEddieXxx @Cernel
      last edited by

      @Cernel

      Personally, I’d keep the categories simple and use “1946+ Atomic” and “Futuristic.” I can see the reasoning behind separating “Near Future” and “Far Future,” but the distinction could be subjective and may add more complexity than we need.

      C 1 Reply Last reply
      Reply Quote 0
      • C
        Cernel Moderators Lobby Moderators
        last edited by

        Are you sure about the name of the "A&A Style" category? I would rename that category as "Basic".

        Moreover, instead of having them all at 4 stars, I would just leave those games without a "Quality" value at all.

        Also, "world_war_ii_v3" belongs to that category (not to 1931-1945 WW2 Global). Whatever the case, it should obviously be in the same category as Classic and Revised. I would say as Global 1940 too.

        C 1 Reply Last reply
        Reply Quote 0
        • TheDogT
          TheDog @Cernel
          last edited by TheDog

          @Cernel
          I will get back to you.

          @ All
          There is a Genre called &&& Style EDIT
          I intended this to be just pure A&A maps with its TripleA closest map
          There are a lot players who want to play just the &&& style maps. EDIT

          But there are so many variations on these &&& maps. EDIT
          What to do, how to group?

          All in one Group ?
          Split out with pure(ish) in one, revisions in another ?

          Whatever the above what to call theses group(s) ?

          Thoughts ?

          https://forums.triplea-game.org/tags/thedog
          https://forums.triplea-game.org/topic/3741/curated-best-top-maps-triplea-guides

          C 1 Reply Last reply
          Reply Quote 0
          • C
            Cernel Moderators Lobby Moderators @xxXEddieXxx
            last edited by

            @xxXEddieXxx said:

            @Cernel

            Personally, I’d keep the categories simple and use “1946+ Atomic” and “Futuristic.” I can see the reasoning behind separating “Near Future” and “Far Future,” but the distinction could be subjective and may add more complexity than we need.

            Would you put "world_war2010", "2013Conflict" or an hypotetical map I'm releasing now for a World War in 2029 in “1946+ Atomic” or “Futuristic”? Such maps are mostly why I suggested a "Near Future" section.

            If right now I release a map starting 3 years from now, the tech of that map is not going to be much different from current, and it will be ideally in the past 3 years from now.

            1 Reply Last reply
            Reply Quote 0
            • C
              Cernel Moderators Lobby Moderators @TheDog
              last edited by Cernel

              @TheDog I would go for a "Basic Original", in which to put everything from Classic to V6 comprising Europe, Pacific and the 1940 series and "Basic Variant" for very close variants of those. Of course, it will always be disputable how close to the originals you have to be to stay in "Basic Variant". My metre would be having in "Basic Variant" only any kind of modifications which keep functionally the same map elements as the original. For example, yes for a mod of Revised which turns the game into a FFA but not for a mod of Revised which adds Italians to the game or split even only one territory into two (or merge two into one).

              However, that would currently unfortunately necessitate a third category for "Basic Original + Variant" for all those maps having both originals and variants in the folder. For example, "world_war_ii_global" has both original and variant games, so it should go in "Basic Original + Variant" or split into two maps, one for the originals and the other one for the variants.

              Is "world_war_ii_global" the only basic map with both originals and variants inside? If so, I guess the "Basic Original + Variant" would be a single-map category. In this case, I guess we can avoid having that category and instead just putting Global into the "Basic Original" category just to avoid having a category for a single map.

              C TheDogT 2 Replies Last reply
              Reply Quote 0
              • C
                Cernel Moderators Lobby Moderators @Cernel
                last edited by Cernel

                Alternatively, calling the category just "Basic" and having Classic to V6 comprising Europe, Pacific and the 1940 series into that, whereas whatever variant is just treated as whatever other non-basic map - not having a dedicated category for the basic variants. This would avoid the problem of deciding at what point a map stops being a variant.

                There would be still the problem that the Global map has many games which are not actually basic originals.

                C 1 Reply Last reply
                Reply Quote 0
                • TheDogT
                  TheDog @Cernel
                  last edited by TheDog

                  @Cernel
                  Thanks!
                  I will give it a few days to see other opinions
                  &&& Basic Original EDIT
                  &&& Basic Variant

                  Could we shorten it to ?
                  &&& Original
                  &&& Variant

                  If there is an Original & a Variant in one map, then I would put it in the 1st group, yes? (if there is only one map that does this)

                  @ All
                  Genre, currently Im going for these
                  1946+ Atomic (for near our current tech levels)
                  Futuristic (includes Dune, Star Wars, Star Trek etc)
                  Again, I will give it a few days to see other opinions

                  Thanks all

                  https://forums.triplea-game.org/tags/thedog
                  https://forums.triplea-game.org/topic/3741/curated-best-top-maps-triplea-guides

                  C 2 Replies Last reply
                  Reply Quote 0
                  • C
                    Cernel Moderators Lobby Moderators @Cernel
                    last edited by

                    To account for global (and maybe others) having variants, the category could be called "Basic Original/Variant" instead of just "Basic" (to warn the user that he/she may or may not get variants together with the originals).

                    xxXEddieXxxX 1 Reply Last reply
                    Reply Quote 0
                    • C
                      Cernel Moderators Lobby Moderators @TheDog
                      last edited by

                      @TheDog said:

                      Could we shorten it to ?
                      A&A Original
                      A&A Variant

                      That is not what I proposed. There is no "A&A" in my proposal.

                      "Original" alone does not imply it is a basic game. Any new map is an original if it is not a variant.

                      As I see it, for example, "World At War" is the original and "WAW 1940" is a variant of it. Neither is basic though.

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      Reply Quote 0
                      • C
                        Cernel Moderators Lobby Moderators @TheDog
                        last edited by

                        @TheDog said:

                        Genre, currently Im going for these
                        1946+ Atomic (for near our current tech levels)
                        Futuristic (includes Dune, Star Wars, Star Trek etc)
                        Again, I will give it a few days to see other opinions

                        Yes, I would agree that, if we do not want to have a "Near Future" category, better to have it as part of 1946+ than Futuristical. For example, if I now make a map for a World War in 2050, I think that would be better as 1946+ than staying together with Star Trek and such. However, this has the risk of the distinction being lost over time: without a "Near Future" category, every time a new map in the near future would be released, it may end up going one way or the other. Thereby, if not having a "Near Future" category, I suggest that the "Futuristical" category is named either "Far Future" or "Hyperfuturistical" to make that clear enough.

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        Reply Quote 0
                        • O
                          Ondis Lobby Moderators @TheDog
                          last edited by Ondis

                          @TheDog

                          I know I can search for them but the whole point of a category system is to not need to search for them and for people to be able to find things that they want to play in the same style. As map variety expands you'd want to be able to make to filter for category.

                          So for example someone looking for Domination maps might stumble on the "Steampunk" one which they otherwise wouldn't. Or if Im a fan of Total War I might stumble upon Total Ancient War. There are currently dozens of maps that are not searchable based on common map packs and these would benefit from a categorization system immediately.

                          For example Battle For Arda is a Middle-Earth variant, Operation Unthinkable and Ozeta's maps are Global variants, Steampunk is a Domination variant. These categories have actual utility.

                          Year just doesn't make any sense, it's not related to the actual thing people are searching for. There's for example 100 WW2 maps. What is "Year" going to do for anyone looking thorugh 1939-1945? Does a player playing Revised care about Total War?

                          Edit: An other variant instead of either of these two would be to simply have it be "Complexity". So Total War goes into 5 (most complex) Domination 4, Global/NWO 3, Revised 2, Classic 1. Non A&A would go into "Unclassified" category. Like Relic or Chess.

                          This would automatically group maps of the same style at least somewhat.


                          Regarding ratings Im fine either way, but I thought the whole reason you removed them was that people did complain. You've already rated some maps that are finished as 2. What would you rate the Capture the Flag map for example? Its (Approved/Finished) but you're rating it a 3. So its not really an equivalent of what I suggested, though it may have its own merit.

                          Never had a problem with the old system personally. But it was useful partly because it was so stringent 😛 So it depends on if people like that or not.

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          Reply Quote 1
                          • C
                            Cernel Moderators Lobby Moderators @Cernel
                            last edited by Cernel

                            To be clear, my starting suggestion was to have "Basic" instead of "A&A Style". Whether or not then also divide between originals and variants was merely an added item and maybe not worth it. There can be just the "Basic" category only and forget about the variants, let them be normal non-Basic maps like anything else.

                            1 Reply Last reply
                            Reply Quote 0
                            • xxXEddieXxxX
                              xxXEddieXxx @Cernel
                              last edited by

                              @cernel
                              Grouping the same map with different versions can also be a solution, I do it in my mobile port.

                              TheDogT 1 Reply Last reply
                              Reply Quote 1
                              • TheDogT
                                TheDog @xxXEddieXxx
                                last edited by

                                @ All
                                I have finished my first pass of the 300+ maps

                                As these are pull down menu selections, choices are limited in style.

                                Quality
                                4=Excellent, a few maps, well 30ish
                                3=Good, most maps are rated this
                                2=Experimental, all new maps will be Experimental, after a revision or two, will be Good
                                1=Unplayable for one reason or another

                                image.jpeg

                                Year,Genre
                                Basic Original=that famous boxed version
                                Basic Variant= is a variant of the boxed version
                                I will need help moving the maps into these two, please advise

                                Historic year bands
                                Futuristic=Dune, Star Trek, Star Wars
                                Fantasy=Dragons & Magic
                                Abstract-Alternate=catch all, if it does not easily fit into the above

                                Solo/PvP
                                Solo=Designed/best for Solo play
                                PvP=too complex for AI to handle, so only PvP
                                Blank=can be played Solo or PvP

                                What needs to change or improve ?

                                https://forums.triplea-game.org/tags/thedog
                                https://forums.triplea-game.org/topic/3741/curated-best-top-maps-triplea-guides

                                xxXEddieXxxX C 3 Replies Last reply
                                Reply Quote 1
                                • xxXEddieXxxX
                                  xxXEddieXxx @TheDog
                                  last edited by xxXEddieXxx

                                  @TheDog great work!

                                  I really like the overall structure.

                                  A map can have multiple categories right?
                                  Wouldn't it be good to not only have categories for what these maps are but for who?

                                  I'm thinking for simple maps maybe "beginner friendly" or "deep gameplay" for some of the harder ones. And the most played could also get something like "recommended".

                                  Also the pull down menu should be reworked in a multiple selection menu.

                                  TheDogT 1 Reply Last reply
                                  Reply Quote 0
                                  • TheDogT
                                    TheDog @xxXEddieXxx
                                    last edited by

                                    @xxXEddieXxx

                                    A map can have multiple categories right?

                                    Sadly no, One pulldown = only one choice

                                    .

                                    Wouldn't it be good to not only have categories for what these maps are but for who? I'm thinking for simple maps maybe "beginner friendly" or "deep gameplay" for some of the harder ones. And the most played could also get something like "recommended".

                                    Recommended is 4=Excellent I guess

                                    .

                                    Also the pull down menu should be reworked in a multiple selection menu.

                                    IFAIK cannot be done.

                                    .
                                    The system must be easy to maintain. Compared to what this replaces, this is so much easier to maintain.

                                    Also being a thankless task and people cannot agree its hard to get something useable.
                                    So something is better than nothing.

                                    https://forums.triplea-game.org/tags/thedog
                                    https://forums.triplea-game.org/topic/3741/curated-best-top-maps-triplea-guides

                                    RogerCooperR 1 Reply Last reply
                                    Reply Quote 2
                                    • RogerCooperR
                                      RogerCooper @TheDog
                                      last edited by

                                      @TheDog There is a useful piece of information that is completely objective, the number of territories. I have this information on https://axisandallies.fandom.com/wiki/Axis_%26_Allies_Wikipedia

                                      C 1 Reply Last reply
                                      Reply Quote 0
                                      • C
                                        Cernel Moderators Lobby Moderators @RogerCooper
                                        last edited by

                                        @RogerCooper Number of territories? I assume you mean number of zones? I mean, are you excluding sea zones without a territory attachment? I guess not: that makes the map bigger too.

                                        Assuming we are talking of zones (and it would be better to exclude impassable territories from the total), that is an important information to be sure to gauge if that is a big map or a small map.

                                        However, this is a map list, so how do you get the information?

                                        If you get it in the game-file, how about if the map has multiple game-files? My suggestion, in this case, would be to check every game file, and to give the one having the biggest number of territories if not the same for all.

                                        Alternatively, you could simply look at the number of territories in something like the centers.txt in the map folder, but, in this case, there may be games having unused such references, for example "World At War" and "WAW 1940" having more zones in the original skin (meaning the main map folder) than in either game because some territories are called differently in one and the other one and the original skin has both to support both games.

                                        Moreover, I can have a map like "Civil War", in which one of the two games use only a small part of the total territories.


                                        My conclusion is that it would be better to reserve such information in the "Select Game" menu that you get after having downloaded the map (preferably subtracting impassable territories), as such information is better given per game rather than per map.

                                        RogerCooperR 1 Reply Last reply
                                        Reply Quote 0
                                        • V
                                          Vendetta
                                          last edited by

                                          Why not just put year and genre in separate columns so people can sort by either?

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          Reply Quote 0
                                          • RogerCooperR
                                            RogerCooper @Cernel
                                            last edited by

                                            @Cernel I got the information by looking in the XML file for each mod and classifying mods by map (unique geographic information). I include the impassable territories and sea zones.

                                            Look at https://axisandallies.fandom.com/wiki/Category:TripleA_Maps. Scroll down to see the links.

                                            C 2 Replies Last reply
                                            Reply Quote 0

                                            Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                            Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                            With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                            Register Login
                                            • 1
                                            • 2
                                            • 3
                                            • 4
                                            • 2 / 4
                                            • First post
                                              Last post
                                            Powered by NodeBB Forums