TripleA Logo TripleA Forum
    • TripleA Website
    • Recent
    • Popular
    • Register
    • Login

    My map editor for TripleA

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Map Making
    70 Posts 7 Posters 200 Views 6 Watching
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • V
      Vendetta @RogerCooper
      last edited by

      One more quality of life suggestion would be sorting options for things like production orders for units or the list of game rules. Up and down arrows to move an item within the list would be a good minimum, even better if there's some quick one click options (i.e. sort units by type, by cost/value, by A-Z).

      1 Reply Last reply
      Reply Quote 1
      • C
        Cernel Moderators Lobby Moderators @RogerCooper
        last edited by Cernel

        @RogerCooper said:

        @TheDog said:

        Nations
        I call Nations; factions, gangs of New York, Tribes, local forces, Kingdoms etc. sometimes they are not Nations, so what to call them ?
        Most maps are WW2 global maps and so Nations does hold true.

        I would suggest the word "powers" rather than "nations'. However, on my wiki I do use the term "nations".

        (This is not actually an answer to @rogercooper. I'm just talking in general, arguing against the use of the term "nation", not arguing against any forum user or anyone else. When I say "you", I do not actually mean anyone specifically: for example, "you are" has here the meaning of "someone is".)

        "Nation" is not a good term. I guess that, if you are a United-States-American, nation may seem a good term as it almost unambiguously identifies the whole Union, however nation just happens to be that for the USA. In reality, the term nation traditionally identifies a people, and it is not even necessarily defined by geography, though usually it is as it is most commonly understood.

        (I said almost because, actually, each aboriginal (or indigenous or "Indian") people within (or without) the United States of America is a stateless nation, so there are actually many nations within the United States of America. Now, one may argue that this is stretching the meaning of nation, and indeed such stateless nations are not commonly considered nations, right or wrong.)

        To make more examples, Scotland is quite certainly a nation no matter if it is part of the State known as the United Kingdom. In this case, the nation is the sub-set of the State, not vice versa.

        Obviously, one may argue that the nations of the United Kingdom are so similar that the United Kingdom itself is one nation. This is just a matter of personal opinions.

        Obviously, calling something like the World War 1 or 2 British Empire a nation is possibly the worst possible use of the term, the Mongol Empire being a close contender. If you want to intend it as everything subjected to a nation, then you should call it the English Empire, because Britain is already not a nation but the union of at least the nations of England and Scotland (and a sub-set of the United Kingdom), without opening the question on whether or not others like Wales are nations too (for which my answer would be yes, but it's disputable especially going back but not too back).

        If you think that is strange, it's not. Especially in the past, it was pretty common for empires to be made up of multiple nations. For example, in a World War 1 map, the Austro-Hungarian empire is made up of many nations, chiefly (but not only) the nations of Austria and Hungary. Calling the Austro-Hungarian Empire a nation would be straight-up nonsensical: the diffusion of the term nation itself has its roots in opposing polities like the Austro-Hungarian Empire. That is why we have the term "nation-state" (which the Austro-Hungarian Empire was a very good example of not being).

        Of course, as per the meaning of the term, there may as well be stateless nations. For example, the Kurds are a stateless nation, actually a nation split amongst several independent states and a minority in each of them.

        I'll just also remind everyone that neither the Russian Empire nor Soviet Union nor the current Russian Federation are nations: they are unions of many nations (with a massive prevalence of the Russian nation).

        Even in nation-states like Italy, some may argue that some territories like Corsica or Nice are part of the Italian nation albeit not of the Italian State, and some inverse opinions may exist for the Alto Adige. Are the Sardinians different enough from the rest of the Italians to be their own nation? It's disputable, but they are certainly traditionally less Italian than the Corsicans.

        I could go on for much longer, but I suppose I made it clear.

        Here are the first two definitions of "nation" from Cambridge.

        https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/nation

        a country, especially when thought of as the people who live there, often with its own culture, language, and customs

        a large group of people of the same race who share the same language, traditions, and history, but who might not all live in one area

        As a bonus, this is the first definition of "nation-state".

        a country, usually with its own culture, language, or customs, that is not part of or controlled by any other country

        RogerCooperR 1 Reply Last reply
        Reply Quote 1
        • xxXEddieXxxX
          xxXEddieXxx
          last edited by xxXEddieXxx

          Update 0.2.1

          Today was bug fixing day! (yay)
          As i said before, i will now take this all somewhat more serious and test changes that where made more carefully.

          Some of the QoL improvements are on my bucket list for tomorrow, as i really like them and think they are a good addition to the project.

          • Publish said "No version yet" though the game file had one. It now shows both versions, map.yml's whole number and the game file's own, and Raise raises both: 1 and 0.020 become 2 and 0.021.
          • Backup files cluttered your map folder and went into uploads The first version of each changed file now goes to eddies-map-editor/Backups in your home folder.
          • Names, PUs and flags sat off from where the game draws them. Places and the Game view now draw them at TripleA's positions, so what you see is what players see.
          • Resources table cut off headings and values Columns now fit their content.

          Edit:
          @cernel
          The term Nation will stay.

          Not only because i like it, and it fits 95% of maps.

          But also the examples you made are only based on the ethnocultural definition. But civic nations are a thing. Switzerland despite having four national languages and distinct cultural communities, constitutes a nation.

          Most importantly games like Hoi4 and EuV use the term nation so many people are familiar with it .

          C 2 Replies Last reply
          Reply Quote 2
          • RogerCooperR
            RogerCooper @Cernel
            last edited by

            @Cernel Again, I suggest the word power. Many of the powers in TripleA are actually alliances like the Commonwealth. In some mods, they are different military commands of the same sovereign power, such as the three Israeli commands in Camp David. I don't like the word player as many of the "players" are unplayable such as in the World War II Global game.

            C 1 Reply Last reply
            Reply Quote 0
            • C
              Cernel Moderators Lobby Moderators @xxXEddieXxx
              last edited by

              @xxXEddieXxx said:

              The term Nation will stay.

              Not only because i like it, and it fits 95% of maps.

              I disagree. It does not even fit all players in World War 2 maps: the British Empire and the Soviet Union were not nations (they were very much multi-nations) as I said.

              1 Reply Last reply
              Reply Quote 0
              • C
                Cernel Moderators Lobby Moderators @RogerCooper
                last edited by

                @RogerCooper To clarify, I agree with @rogercooper that "power" is much better than "nation" in general. Moreover, during the Second World War, the Tripartite parties themselves self-identified as powers in the name of the alliance itself, the "Dreimächtepakt".

                However, I do not like "power" very much because that is the same name which which you may (and TripleA does in the battle-calculator) define the hitting power (the sum of all dice strength), but I agree that it is one of the best picks, I tend to think better than "faction".

                In my opinion, "player" per se is a better pick (Germany, Japan and so on were indeed "players"), but I see that one may want to reserve the term to the human players. I think this can be addressed by just agreeing to call one "player" and the other one "participant". I do not think that players being sometimes unplayable is a problem: those are clearly fake players, and it is clear enough if they are assigned to Does Nothing.

                An other good term is "belligerent". You may argue that in some games it may happen not to be at war with anyone, but I think that in virtually any game whatever real player will eventually be a "belligerent", so it is fitting also when it is not yet.

                Good terms are also "polity" or "civilization". Depending on maps, one or the other one may be better, the former being better for World War maps.

                Starting from the fact that you have alliances, also "member" would be a good term, but it would become weird when you have single-member alliances. However, for something making the game-file, that is a particularly good term because that is how it actually works: when you do not have an alliance but a single power on its own, you have actually to define an alliance of a single member anyway.

                1 Reply Last reply
                Reply Quote 0
                • C
                  Cernel Moderators Lobby Moderators @xxXEddieXxx
                  last edited by

                  @xxXEddieXxx said:

                  @cernel
                  The term Nation will stay.

                  Not only because i like it, and it fits 95% of maps.

                  But also the examples you made are only based on the ethnocultural definition. But civic nations are a thing. Switzerland despite having four national languages and distinct cultural communities, constitutes a nation.

                  Most importantly games like Hoi4 and EuV use the term nation so many people are familiar with it .

                  If you want something like that, I would rather suggest "country". I do not like it very much, but it is very akin to "nation" but better.

                  From Cambridge:

                  Nation:

                  a country, especially when thought of as the people who live there, often with its own culture, language, and customs

                  Country:

                  an area of land with fixed borders that has full or limited control over its own government and laws

                  As you can see, using "country" eliminates the idea of being one people (not peoples) with shared "culture, language, and customs" which is at the root of the idea of "nation" (as well as "nationalism").

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  Reply Quote 0
                  • C
                    Cernel Moderators Lobby Moderators
                    last edited by

                    If there is no agreement, it may be just better to go with the official terms.

                    "Player" is the official term in TripleA (within the game file at least).

                    "Power" is the official term in the games to which TripleA is inspired the most.

                    1 Reply Last reply
                    Reply Quote 0
                    • xxXEddieXxxX
                      xxXEddieXxx
                      last edited by

                      Update 0.2.2

                      Today i incorporated some of the enhancements you guys asked for. 😄
                      Tomorrow i will hopefully tackle the "draw mode".

                      Also the next update will show when there is a new update available so you do not need to keep track on this Forum post.

                      • Reorder lists
                        Production › Buy, Units and Game options have ▲ ▼ beside the list and ⇅ for a one-click order: A to Z, by cost, or by kind as TripleA's buy tabs sort units. Pick an entry, click ▲ or ▼; or open ⇅ and choose an order. Undo takes it back.

                      • $Variables$ in Choose.
                        Every Choose list whose names go into an attachment ends with the game's variables of that kind under a Variables heading. Tick one like any name; hover it to see its elements.

                      • Flags in Nations and Politics
                        The Nations list shows each nation's colour and flag; the Politics matrix shows the flag before each row and above each column.

                      • What a change of relationship costs.
                        Politics › Relationship types › pick a type: the section "Changing to it in the game" lists each action that sets it, with cost, chance and who must accept, and a link to Actions. TripleA knows no length of a change; a :3 at the end of relationshipChange makes the file unloadable.

                      • How the game shows a terrain effect.
                        Terrain effects › pick an effect: the line "In the game: …" says whether this map shows the name on the status bar, a picture there, or the picture on the map, and what the next way needs. Choose… a picture or set map.useTerritoryEffectMarkers to move up.

                      • Publish
                        Publish › Write it. The checklist names description.html; Write it, or Shorten it when the text is too long, jumps to the Description box and marks it.

                      TheDogT C 2 Replies Last reply
                      Reply Quote 3
                      • TheDogT
                        TheDog @xxXEddieXxx
                        last edited by TheDog

                        @xxXEddieXxx
                        version 0.2.1 & 0.2.2
                        Using 11 Ring of Power
                        As you hope to tackle the "draw mode" soon have this;

                        .
                        Pixel mapping is off between TripleA & Map Editor
                        Image is from Triple 11 RoP, Whispering Woods, NW of map

                        Notice 7pu sits on top of the flag pole
                        image.jpeg

                        .
                        Image from Map Editor, notice the PU overlapping the Flag pole
                        image.jpeg

                        .
                        The PU icon comes from 11_rings_of_power\map\PUs
                        The Flag icon comes from 11_rings_of_power\map\units\WoodElf
                        Vertically one of the two is out by about 10px

                        https://forums.triplea-game.org/tags/thedog
                        https://forums.triplea-game.org/topic/3741/curated-best-top-maps-triplea-guides

                        xxXEddieXxxX 1 Reply Last reply
                        Reply Quote 1
                        • xxXEddieXxxX
                          xxXEddieXxx @TheDog
                          last edited by

                          @TheDog
                          I tested this so much on 1941 GCD. 😞
                          i will try to fix this ASAP thank you.

                          TheDogT 1 Reply Last reply
                          Reply Quote 1
                          • TheDogT
                            TheDog @xxXEddieXxx
                            last edited by

                            @xxXEddieXxx
                            11 Rings of Power, 1888A and the two Shoguns have very precise postioning of Flags.

                            11 RoP is the simplier map, so test with that, using the example given. Ebbe has not finished the micro positioning, he is waiting for the app to settle and have fewer changes. 🙂

                            Keep up the amazing work 🤯

                            https://forums.triplea-game.org/tags/thedog
                            https://forums.triplea-game.org/topic/3741/curated-best-top-maps-triplea-guides

                            TheDogT 1 Reply Last reply
                            Reply Quote 0
                            • TheDogT
                              TheDog @TheDog
                              last edited by TheDog

                              @xxxeddiexxx
                              version 0.2.2
                              Terrain Effect text/icon is not working as intended
                              Greyhawk Wars, has a blank icon, it should just be the text used in the terrain list, eg forest
                              image.jpeg

                              image.jpeg

                              Total World War displays correctly
                              image.jpeg

                              But large label icons are compressed into probably 48x48px and not shown as their true pixel width of say 390px as in GCD
                              Currently look like this
                              image.jpeg

                              Should look like this
                              Forest.jpeg

                              https://forums.triplea-game.org/tags/thedog
                              https://forums.triplea-game.org/topic/3741/curated-best-top-maps-triplea-guides

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              Reply Quote 0
                              • V
                                Vendetta
                                last edited by

                                Is a built-in updater that can install the new versions from within the program feasible?

                                1 Reply Last reply
                                Reply Quote 2
                                • C
                                  Cernel Moderators Lobby Moderators @xxXEddieXxx
                                  last edited by

                                  @xxXEddieXxx I proposed so many good alternatives... You actually do not like a single one of them? You believe "nation" is actually better than them all?

                                  Asking Google AI

                                  Between the terms "nation", "country", "power", "faction", "player", "participant", "belligerent", "polity", "civilization" and "member", what is the best to label the British Empire in a World War 2 war-game, listing them best to worst?

                                  the answer is

                                  The best label for the British Empire in a World War II war-game is "power". It accurately reflects a global, multi-territorial alliance led by a major imperial state without falsely compressing dozens of distinct nations into a single country.

                                  Ranked Labels (Best to Worst)

                                  1. Power: This is the historical standard for World War II diplomacy and grand strategy. It naturally encompasses a dominant core state along with its dominions, colonies, and mandates (e.g., "Allied Powers" or "Major Powers").
                                  2. Faction: This is the strongest game-design term for a unified playable group. It cleanly treats the United Kingdom, the Raj, Canada, Australia, and other territories as a single coordinated team on the map.
                                  3. Belligerent: This is technically accurate for any active combatant in a conflict. However, it feels overly legalistic and clinical for a game's primary UI label.
                                  4. Participant: This works well for scenario briefings or historical overviews. Like "belligerent," it lacks the thematic punch and structural clarity needed for an active game piece.
                                  5. Player: This is functional in multiplayer contexts where a human controls the entire empire. It becomes confusing in single-player modes or when distinguishing between the human user and the historical entity.
                                  6. Polity: This is technically correct because it describes any politically organized society. However, it sounds far too academic and dry for a World War II game.
                                  7. Member: This only makes sense if the label is explicitly framed as part of a larger coalition, such as "Allied Member." On its own, the word is too vague and incomplete.
                                  8. Nation: The British Empire was a vast collection of many distinct nations, not a single unified one. Using this label creates immediate historical friction for places like India, Canada, or Australia.
                                  9. Country: This is factually inaccurate because the British Empire spanned dozens of separate countries and territories. This label should be reserved strictly for the United Kingdom itself.
                                  10. Civilization: This term belongs to sweeping, multi-millennia games spanning ancient to modern eras. It is entirely out of scale for a focused, six-year conflict like World War II.

                                  You might notice that only "contry" and "civilization" are ranked below "nation". (I agree that they are all very bad, though I would personally pick "country" over "nation".)

                                  (If you want, I can write my own ranking, but I think that the one made by the AI is actually quite good: I'm not sure I would have made a much better one.)

                                  V xxXEddieXxxX 2 Replies Last reply
                                  Reply Quote 0
                                  • V
                                    Vendetta @Cernel
                                    last edited by Vendetta

                                    Faction is probably the best universal label, but I don't think it's such a big deal to get hung up on since the term will only appear in the editor anyway, not in the final export.

                                    1 Reply Last reply
                                    Reply Quote 1
                                    • xxXEddieXxxX
                                      xxXEddieXxx @Cernel
                                      last edited by

                                      @Cernel
                                      yes

                                      • Established convention: Hearts of Iron, Europa Universalis and Victoria all use "nation" despite featuring multinational empires and other unconventional political entities.

                                      • Clear distinction: A player controls a nation, while nations form alliances. This avoids confusing the controller with the controlled entity.

                                      • Political identity: Unlike "faction", which can imply a subdivision of a larger group, "nation" conveys an independent collective political identity.

                                      • Broad applicability: Under its civic and political definitions, a nation does not require ethnic, linguistic or cultural homogeneity.

                                      • Accessibility: "Nation" is more immediately understandable to casual players than "polity" and more immersive than "participant" or "member".

                                      • Neutrality: Unlike "power" or "belligerent", it does not necessarily imply geopolitical influence or participation in a war.

                                      Ultimately, my priority is intuitive, familiar terminology rather than exhaustive political-scientific accuracy.

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      Reply Quote 0

                                      Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                      Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                      With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                      Register Login
                                      • 1
                                      • 2
                                      • 3
                                      • 4
                                      • 2 / 4
                                      • First post
                                        Last post
                                      Powered by NodeBB Forums