Roger's Scenario Thread

Cernel

@rogercooper said in Roger's Scenario Thread:

No victory conditions

From the page you linked:
https://axisandallies.fandom.com/wiki/World_At_War

Unconditional Surrender: Victory is achieved at any moment the enemy alliance owns only 5 capitals or less

RogerCooper

Name World War II Global 1940 2nd Edition
Description Port of boardgame
link

**Good Points

Port of the Axis & Allies Global 1940 game
Lots of interesting options

**Bad Points

Favors the Axis
Japan gets too strong

RogerCooper

Name CTF2 Good Versus Evil
Description Fantasy Warfare on an abstract map
link

**Good Points

Fast-playing even with Hard AI
Challenging puzzle-like situation
Balanced
AI hard to beat

**Bad Points

Bland, symmetric situation limits replay value

RogerCooper

Name Axis General
Description The Big World map starting in 1939
link

Good Points

Fast-playing
Rules similar to v3

Bad Points

Axis is too weak to launch an effective offensive

RogerCooper

Name World War II v3 1942
Description TripleA version of the Anniversary edition, 1942 scenario
link

Good Points

Accurate port of the boardgame
Plays fast
Action all over the map

Bad Points

Tough scenario for the Russians

RogerCooper

Name The Rising Sun WW2v3 - AA Boats Edition
Description The Pacific War on a large map
link

Good Points

Well-balanced
Not too slow despite the large map
Lots of options

Bad Points

Not historical, Japan divided into 3 players, Thailand & Dutch are viable, Russia is at war from day 1

RogerCooper

Name WWIIv3 1941 - 11 Nations Mod
Description Anniversary Edition with extra nations

Good Points

Fast-playing
Easy understand rules

Bad Points

Some of the new nations are fairly arbitrary and don't have much to do

RogerCooper

Name Big World
Description World War 2 in 1942 on a large (but not huge map)
link

Good Points

Easy to understand rules
Balanced
Plays reasonably fast with Fast AI

Bad Points

None really, this was once the showcase scenario for TripleA

RogerCooper

Game Hearts of Iron: Awakening the giant
Description The Big World map starting in Spring 41
link

Good Points

Not too many units
Fairly historical economic strengths
Interesting special units
Extra nations with stuff to do

Bad Points

Rules glitches
No victory conditions
The tremendous economic strength of the US, makes it hard for the Axis to win

RogerCooper

Name World War II Global 1940 Balanced Mod
Description Global game with new objectives and deployments to improve balance
link

Good Points

Balanced version of the boardgame
Plays fast

Bad Points

AI has some glitches dealing with some of the special rules

RogerCooper

Name Big World : 1942 - Factions (Allies)
Description Big World Map with lots of countries and unit types

link

Good Points

Interesting unit types
Balanced

Bad Points

Too many unit types are similar

RogerCooper

Description AA50-42-Build Caps
Description Anniversary Edition limited to units that came in the box
link

Good Points

Armies can't be built endlessly
Unit diversity is forces

Bad Points

Favors the Axis
The build limits can be awkward, especially for the AI

RogerCooper

Name Settlers: Fallen Empires
Description Fantasy warfare with a randomized setup
link

**Good Points

Interesting units
Clever method of randomizing setup
Upkeep costs prevent super stacks
Event-based reinforcements to help AI
Plays fairly fast even with Hard AI

**Bad Points

The lack of capitals results in unaggressive AI play
Too many 0 income areas
Low unit density can be an issue
Air transport is important to the game, but the AI doesn't utilize it
With few ground units that move more than 1 (and none that can Blitz) the game is slow going

Note: This mod is innovative but has problems. It would play better if the players had fixed capitals for the AI to respond to. Most 0 income areas should have an income of 1. Air Tranports puts the AI at a disadvantage. Each player should have at least 1 unit type that moves 2 and can blitz (or simply faster movement without blitz).

TheDog

@rogercooper
Thanks for the fair and overall good review.

However the Lgt-Cavalry can already move 3 and Blitz.
Hvy-Cavalry, Commanders, Necromancers, Sorcerers, Wizards can all move 2, but not Blitz.

The Wizards, cast Haste to increase the move of lots of unit types so they move 2, so players could daisy chain their Wizards to get units to the battle front quickly.

But otherwise fair comments.

I have another map, The Settlers : Age of Tribes is a smaller map and land territories don't have 0 production, so mitigate some of Rogers issues.
https://forums.triplea-game.org/topic/2399/settlers-age-of-tribes-official-thread

EDIT 11th June 2021 added
The map have been updated;

with the 0 income area now 1 income
unity density increased dramatically over turns 1-5
and a lot more fixes

Download from Google Drive v2020.04
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1eS1gIRyMDA23DKlP71AFYmvJiXSBZZAZ/view?usp=sharing

See post 1 in the Official Thread for more details and how to install.
https://forums.triplea-game.org/topic/2467/settlers-fallen-empire-official-thread

RogerCooper

@thedog That looks more manageable. However without capitals the AI will always be unfocused.

You should take a look at Conquest of Nerath. It would be highly suitable for a TripleA conversion.

TheDog

@rogercooper
I dont think you can have all random territories/setup and have have capitals.

The only way I thought of coding it was having one fixed territory per faction, the capital, but decided to go with completely random and use TUV for the towns and cities.

Thanks the link for Conquest of Nerath at first glance, it looks very interesting!

RogerCooper

Name Twelve Clans-Sekigahara
Description The Sengoku period in Japan, inspired by the Samurai Swords series of boardgames
link

Good Points

An interesting, historically based situation
Nice unit art

Bad Points

Unit count rises quickly as many units spawn other units
Mega-stacks are overly favored
Not much sense of the actual history, where the need to pay soldiers and fortified mountain passes was important

RogerCooper

Name New World Order 1939 Lebowski
Description World War 2 in Europe
link

Good Points

Playable with Fast AI
Balanced

Bad Points

Despite 1939 starting point, Russia & US are active immediately and Turkey is in the Axis

Cernel

@rogercooper Wow. The description says "World War 2 in Europe", and Turkey is waging war as a member of the Axis?

Really, the description should be changed. I know that no wargame is realistic, but that's beyond the pale.

Nevertheless, I would not say it is a "bad point" per se. The bad point is rather the description not telling the game is not really WW2.

Nothing wrong with making any kind of alternate history as long as it is intended and documented.

RogerCooper

@cernel If a scenario is not described as alternate history or hypothetical, then having countries in the wrong alliance is an error. I have seen a number of scenarios where Turkey is in the Axis just to have more fighting in the MIddle East. Historically, Turkey was neutral, declaring war on Germany in March 45 without participating in any military operations. The Turkish government had close ties to Britain and good relations with Russia.