@cernel said in Map Tags for release 2.6:
As for the "ancient/middle", a way in English to say "non-modern" is "antique", but I was told the term is not good in current English because I understood it is used only for non-modern merchandise.
You could say pre-gunpowder instead of Ancient/Modern for the period before guns became the leading factor in warfare.
could just have the half dozen most popular auto dl. Used to be something similar. If people like it, they can figure it out from there. 
Or do they select from pull down menus?
@TheDog Neither.
Right now there is just one column in the download screen for 'map name'. Each additional tag will add a new column. Players can click on the column name to then sort by that column. There will be no logic to do a number sort, it will be an alpha sort. That means a value like "20" will go after "100" So, this is another peril with using numbers/dates (won't sort correctly). I do recommend just picking some era names, it's easier to categorize and should sort in groups more nicely.
@lafayette said in Map Tags for release 2.6:
Or do they select from pull down menus?
@TheDog Neither.
Right now there is just one column in the download screen for 'map name'. Each additional tag will add a new column. Players can click on the column name to then sort by that column. There will be no logic to do a number sort, it will be an alpha sort. That means a value like "20" will go after "100" So, this is another peril with using numbers/dates (won't sort correctly). I do recommend just picking some era names, it's easier to categorize and should sort in groups more nicely.
That's rather easy to work around: have "0020" instead of "20" if the greatest number is greater than 999 but lesser than 9999 (like 2022). I realize this is obvious, but it reminded me that I did the same in my "270BC Wars" game (all sea zones are two digits, also the ones from 01 to 09).
This reminds me that TripleA has a bunch of maps which start with "The". Also in this case, it is pretty bad that they are grouped as if their name starts with "T".
Namely:
The Pact of Steel
The Rising Sun
The Grand War
The Great Northern War
The Rising Sun Variants
The Shogun
In my opinion, mapmakers should write titles capitalizing only nouns, pronouns, verbs, adjectives, and adverbs.
Then, the engine should also capitalize the first letter of every title regardless.
Then, the engine should order titles completely ignoring every non-capitalized word and also ignoring the first word if it got capitalized by the engine itself.
For example:
So, in the example, the user would see the title "The Pact of Steel" but it would see it listed between the titles starting in "P9" and the ones starting in "Pb".
I actually had this issue when I was trying to download the "The Shogun" map: I was searching it in the "S" bunches of titles instead of in the "T" ones.
@LaFayette
Could this be one option?
Tags entered into GitHub? look like this, with a prefix of 3 characters, to force the order to be displayed on the download screen.
03-****
04-***
05-**
06-*
10-Ancient-Medieval
20-Early Modern
30-Revolutionary
40-WW1
50-WW2-Alternate
52-WW2-Europe
54-WW2-Global
56-WW2-Pacific
60-Nuclear
70-Future
80-Fantasy
90-Abstract
Tag tabs will look like this on screen, with the prefix removed
**** *** ** * Ancient-Medieval Early Modern Revolutionary WW1 WW2-Alternate WW2-Europe WW2-Global WW2-Pacific Nuclear Future Fantasy Abstract
Where
**** Showcase maps, the ones a new player should download first, perhaps one from each Tag group
*** Excellent map
** Good map
* Experimental map
Abstract is a catch all for a map that does not fit any of the above.
Thoughts?
@thedog The set of available tags live in database tables. Once there, they can be applied to individual maps from the lobby toolbox admin menu.
I would not prefix the stars, those might already sort correctly.
I'm nervous to have one star be experimental. My 2 cents any experimental or abandonned maps we should just archive. A map that is barely playable (but otherwise complete) gets 1 star maybe. I do have a pretty significant concern that the download list is a bit of a dumping ground, I'm not sure the point to show so many abandonned and bad maps to the average player (it buries the good maps, less is more)
The number prefixes on era's is pretty legit to get that to sort correctly. The era's look pretty good too.
@lafayette
For reference I have 199 maps in my map tag spreadsheet, with 81 of them being 1 *.
I would like to keep the truly bad maps available for download. Perhaps we could redefine the stars.
where
no stars = newly uploaded map
* Abandoned or unplayable
** Experimental
*** Good
**** Excellent
***** Best
This way the new maps would put in * or ** and ** would actually mean experimental.
Would that work for you?
EDIT: Correction, almost 75% of the maps are 1 *, there are 145 (not 81) of them. So I agree there is a lot of clutter.
@thedog Sure.. I wonder if some of those 81 break along "just half done" and/or "just broken" vs "not quite done and/or barely playable." So, the former, the maps that are just not at all there, those are the ones I wouldn't mind seeing archived.
I don't think it matters too much, the ranking definitions look good and I like the era names. Is your previous post @TheDog a good list to use for era names?
@All @lafayette @Cernel @RogerCooper
Hopefully Last call
Tags will look like this, some with a prefix of 3 characters, to force the order to be displayed on the download screen.
where =and after is just a guide
***** =Best/Showcase maps (maybe one from each of the eras/genres below, so could be 5-12 maps)
**** =Excellent
*** =Good
** =Experimental
* =Abandoned or unplayable (could be archived in the future)
10-Ancient-Medieval =(pre 1450)
20-Early Modern =(1451-1764)
30-Revolutionary =(1765-1869)
40-WW1 =(1870-1930)
50-WW2-Global =(1931-1945)
52-WW2-Europe =(1931-1945)
54-WW2-Pacific =(1931-1945)
56-WW2-Alternate =(1931-1945) WW2 theme that does not fit into the other 3 WW2
60-Nuclear =(1946-2100) includes near future
70-Future =(2100+) Star Trek, Star Wars, Sci-Fi
80-Fantasy = theme Magic, Mythical Creatures like Dragons
90-Abstract-Alternate = a catch all that does not fit the above list, like Steampunk, War of the Relics
.
Tag tabs will look like this on screen, ideally with the prefix removed
***** **** *** ** * Ancient-Medieval Early Modern Revolutionary WW1 WW2-Global WW2-Europe WW2-Pacific WW2-Alternate Nuclear Future Fantasy Abstract
.
@LaFayette I have a Lobby sign in TheDog, so when your ready I will start experimenting/entering the tags.
@cernel said in Map Tags for release 2.6:
As for the "ancient/middle", a way in English to say "non-modern" is "antique", but I was told the term is not good in current English because I understood it is used only for non-modern merchandise.
You could say pre-gunpowder instead of Ancient/Modern for the period before guns became the leading factor in warfare.