Roger's Scenario Thread

RogerCooper

@Schulz The old attachment misspelling for the Great War. I will post the fix this weekend.

Lord Bevan

I meant Great war ultimate which i cannot find anywhere now.
It has a lot of special units for Germany and sea zone worth like 32PU>

Cernel

@RogerCooper said in Roger's Scenario Thread:

Scenario Blood & Iron
Description World War II on a medium-size map
Download Download

Good Points

A different map

Altered unit values make defense easier

Bad Points

None

You already reviewed this here:
@RogerCooper said in Roger's Scenario Thread:

@rogercooper
Game Blood and Iron
Description World War II on a world map
Download Blood_and_Iron

Good Points

Interesting looking map

Moderate map size makes for fast play

High unit costs decrease unit density

Bad Points

No victory conditions

Nothing exceptional, but worth checking out

RogerCooper

@Lord-Bevan I have posted Great War-Ultimate at www.rogercooper.com/GreatWar-Ultimate.zip

RogerCooper

Scenario Ultimate Pants WW2v3
Description World War 2 on a large map with many nations
Download Repository/Experimental/Ultimate World Variants

Good Points

Many nations create many options

Bad Points

A lot of nations and units to keep track of.

The AI should be set to Fast, to avoid slow AI turns.

RogerCooper

Scenario Apocalypse 2012
Description World War in 2012 on a large map
Download Download

Good Points

Interesting hypothetical situation
New unit types to reflect modern warfare
Force strengths and economic values based upon reality

Bad Points

No victory conditions
Slow, even with fast AI due to large number of units
Neutrals are impassable even though they have been assigned forces. This blocks NATO and Russia from fighting.

I will make a fix on this scenario.

Cernel

@RogerCooper You could add to the negative points that the map drawing (clearly a modification of Domination) has some borders giving a pre-WW1, rather than 2012, flavour; for example the border between Libya and Algeria.

Lord Bevan

@RogerCooper
The SZ between 72 and 159 is not drawn properly.
Also if there are too many units, the display gets pushed into another SZ.

RogerCooper

@Lord-Bevan When I am fixing other people's scenarios, I take a minimalist approach and don't generally fix the actual map. I just adjust the xml and add in missing images. Feel free to create your own version of the scenario

RogerCooper

Scenario Domination 1914 No Man's Land
Description World War 1 on a large scale world map
Download Download

Good Points

Conflict in many places

Bad Points

No victory conditions
AI plays Americans poorly, building large numbers of useless fighters.

RogerCooper

**Scenario ** Six Army 3 Alliance
Description Fictional 3 way struggle on the Revised map
Download Link

Good Points

Fast-playing game with an interesting 3 way conflict

Bad Points

The AI does not handle the initial bid well, building too many aircraft

RogerCooper

Scenario Classic-Gold
Description A particular set of optional rules for the Classic edition of A&A
Download link

Good Points

Fast-playing

Bad Points

A bit on the simple side compared to the later editions

RogerCooper

Scenario Revised with Cavalry
Description The revised edition with cavalry added
Download link

Good Points

Fast-playing implementation of board game

Bad Points

The cavalry unit isn't worth buying

RogerCooper

Scenario Rome Total War
Description Another version of the 270BC map
Download Repository/Experimental/Rome Total War

** Good Points

Nice unit art
Historically-inspired situation

** Bad Points

Tough scenario for Romans
TripleA not a good fit for ancient warfare

Cernel

@RogerCooper said in Roger's Scenario Thread:

Bad Points

The cavalry unit isn't worth buying

Are you sure that is a bad point? Assuming that is true (never played any Revised), maybe it was just intended as to represent it as obsolete, since many believe that cavalry was not anymore something worth investing money on during WW2 (I'm not saying that is what I believe too; just saying it may be intended).

RogerCooper

@Cernel said in Roger's Scenario Thread:

@RogerCooper said in Roger's Scenario Thread:

Bad Points

The cavalry unit isn't worth buying

Are you sure that is a bad point? Assuming that is true (never played any Revised), maybe it was just intended as to represent it as obsolete, since many believe that cavalry was not anymore something worth investing money on during WW2 (I'm not saying that is what I believe too; just saying it may be intended).

Cavalry being not worth it is realistic, but what was the point of creating a scenario with an added unit that no one will buy. This scenario is included for completeness only.

RogerCooper

Scenario Pacific 1942
Description The Pacific war after the initial Japanese Conquests using the AAP map and rules
Link Wiki

Good Points

Fast-playing historical game

Bad Points

Transports only move at 1, slowing the game
With slow transports, it is hard to prevent a Japanese victory

RogerCooper

Scenario NWO_Vichy
Description World War 2 in Europe starting in June 1941 with Vichy France is a German ally
Link link

Good Points

Well-balanced

Bad Points

No victory conditions implemented

RogerCooper

Scenario Camp David-1956
Description The Suez Crisis of 1956
Link link

Good Points

Some political restrictions to show the limited war situation of 1956

Bad Points

Lack of victory conditions is particular problem given the limited war situation
The Axis & Allies production model is a poor match for war that lasted only 9 days

RogerCooper

ScenarioWWIIv3 1942-11 Nations Mod
Description AA50 with a lot of minor nations
Link link

Good Points

Fast-playing, easy to follow rules

Bad Points

Russia tends to be overrun quickly
The rules for the minor nations are not explained
Some of the minor nations are pretty arbitrary