Subcategories
-
8 Topics201 Posts
-
54 Topics423 Posts
Recent Posts
-
If there is no agreement, it may be just better to go with the official terms.
"Player" is the official term in TripleA (within the game file at least).
"Power" is the official term in the games to which TripleA is inspired the most.
-
@cernel
The term Nation will stay.Not only because i like it, and it fits 95% of maps.
But also the examples you made are only based on the ethnocultural definition. But civic nations are a thing. Switzerland despite having four national languages and distinct cultural communities, constitutes a nation.
Most importantly games like Hoi4 and EuV use the term nation so many people are familiar with it .
If you want something like that, I would rather suggest "country". I do not like it very much, but it is very akin to "nation" but better.
From Cambridge:
Nation:
a country, especially when thought of as the people who live there, often with its own culture, language, and customs
Country:
an area of land with fixed borders that has full or limited control over its own government and laws
As you can see, using "country" eliminates the idea of being one people (not peoples) with shared "culture, language, and customs" which is at the root of the idea of "nation" (as well as "nationalism").
-
@RogerCooper To clarify, I agree with @rogercooper that "power" is much better than "nation" in general. Moreover, during the Second World War, the Tripartite parties themselves self-identified as powers in the name of the alliance itself, the "Dreimächtepakt".
However, I do not like "power" very much because that is the same name which which you may (and TripleA does in the battle-calculator) define the hitting power (the sum of all dice strength), but I agree that it is one of the best picks, I tend to think better than "faction".
In my opinion, "player" per se is a better pick (Germany, Japan and so on were indeed "players"), but I see that one may want to reserve the term to the human players. I think this can be addressed by just agreeing to call one "player" and the other one "participant". I do not think that players being sometimes unplayable is a problem: those are clearly fake players, and it is clear enough if they are assigned to Does Nothing.
An other good term is "belligerent". You may argue that in some games it may happen not to be at war with anyone, but I think that in virtually any game whatever real player will eventually be a "belligerent", so it is fitting also when it is not yet.
Good terms are also "polity" or "civilization". Depending on maps, one or the other one may be better, the former being better for World War maps.
Starting from the fact that you have alliances, also "member" would be a good term, but it would become weird when you have single-member alliances. However, for something making the game-file, that is a particularly good term because that is how it actually works: when you do not have an alliance but a single power on its own, you have actually to define an alliance of a single member anyway.
-
The term Nation will stay.
Not only because i like it, and it fits 95% of maps.
I disagree. It does not even fit all players in World War 2 maps: the British Empire and the Soviet Union were not nations (they were very much multi-nations) as I said.