• New Steampunk Advance Thread

    94
    2 Votes
    94 Posts
    48k Views
    board 3659B
    Hello, I'm back. So uh idk if I'll do much but probably will do something like maybe get a game set up (idk if like via forum or online depending on time constrants).
  • War Plan Red-Orange

    8
    4
    3 Votes
    8 Posts
    213 Views
    M
    @TheDog thanks
  • North Africa - TripleA Module

    66
    1
    5 Votes
    66 Posts
    33k Views
    B
    @VictoryFirst I think my 1 pixel idea will fail, although I haven't tried it. Reason being, when you go to "Add Units" you only got a 1 pix spot for it to find. Idk, maybe a 5 spot ? I guess I just gotta try it
  • World War I with more territories?

    59
    1
    1 Votes
    59 Posts
    12k Views
    SchulzS
    @iratoric That's great. I can't wait to produce the game, but I'm so busy nowadays and don't have much time. But it will have to be created one day.
  • Pregunpowder Experiment

    1
    3 Votes
    1 Posts
    70 Views
    No one has replied
  • 💀 Settlers: Fallen Empire - Official Thread

    maps thedog
    15
    6
    3 Votes
    15 Posts
    7k Views
    TheDogT
    Latest version v020 ready for download within TripleA. In TripleA Click Download Maps Button Click Installed tab Click ** Settlers: Fallen Empire** Click Remove Button Click Yes button to remove Click Ok button (Successfully removed) Click Close (To force the map list to refresh) Click Download Maps Button............................<= new players start here Find & Click ** Settlers: Fallen Empire** Click Install button Enjoy! Settlers Fallen Empire Manual pdf unchanged Settlers_Fallen_Empire_Manual.pdf v020 Sea Zone PU collection is now working as intended It currently requires the following steps player none=Neutral must be have an initial relationship of Neutral with the Player factions, see lines 6977 etc player none=Neutral start of turn 1 is changed to War, see lines 5913-5931 Define All-SZ (Sea Zones) & All-Players required for #4 foreach to work A foreach to convert currentowner = originalowner, this allows PU to be collected, see lines 5899-5911 (#1 & #2 are are a bizzare requirement that should not exist. ) Turn placementAnyTerritory True and False, allows placement of isAI unplaced Factories, makes for a better player experience (thanks to @wc_sumpton) Link to 1st post https://forums.triplea-game.org/topic/2467/settlers-fallen-empire-official-thread
  • Domination 1914 No Man's Land - Official Thread

    256
    1
    5 Votes
    256 Posts
    264k Views
    SchulzS
    Late fighters are balanced around with other units and techs.
  • Religions and beliefs

    11
    1 Votes
    11 Posts
    362 Views
    M
    @TheDog I have a specirfic TripleA version with some specific xml files for games like TWW and I have 2/3 curent games so it is not so easy....
  • 🏯 Shogun Advanced - Official Thread

    thedog
    26
    1
    2 Votes
    26 Posts
    6k Views
    TheDogT
    @malmessi It is in game in the usual place Help> Game Notes
  • How to add to Big World Variations

    15
    1 Votes
    15 Posts
    3k Views
    RogerCooperR
    I put it onto github under https://github.com/triplea-maps/thehobbesians_1939. I will add to the in-game downloader tomorrow.
  • TripleA Maps List

    4
    1
    3 Votes
    4 Posts
    292 Views
    RogerCooperR
    @TheDog said: @rogercooper Cant find Ansalon/Analon on Github maps Missing from your list, but on Github maps Settlers: Fallen Empire Shogun Advanced Ansalon was superseded. https://axisandallies.fandom.com/wiki/Master_of_Ansalon Settlers: Fallen Empire uses the Fallen Empire Map Shogun Advanced is under The Shogun Map
  • Middle Earth: Battle For Arda - Official Thread

    588
    2
    3 Votes
    588 Posts
    1m Views
    R
    Interesting video, and welcome back! I think the changes are interesting. Regarding tactics I do think that having 5 levels is a lot. I think that @shorogyth 's system seems reasonable. I'd also pull the plains bonus out of the tactics system (call it "defensive tactics") and have a separate plains attack bonus. That way horses can have a bonus there, and rangers won't automatically be good attacking on plains. I know it's a third number, but I think it'll be less confusing than tactics being mostly defense bonuses but also one attack bonus. Also, can you have more than a +-1bonus on some terrains? I feel like most flying units would need more than a -1 bonus on caves, especially because tactics give them bonuses. I agree with the relentless issue. I think it's cool for some units to ignore your defensive terrain advantage, but they should be rare and therefore scary. Having basically all orcs be relentless is pretty silly and makes plains better for defense than cities. Regarding unit abilities, I don't think rock paper scissors is necessarily bad, especially because not all factions are equally strong in each. If each faction has different strengths and weaknesses, it forces factions to collaborate more, and stops things from snowballing as much if one faction falls. Eg Gondor would spam rangers because they have good defense bonuses and would kill the winged nazgul (thereby denying mordor's leadership), so you could send flanking cavalry from Rhun or harad to eliminate them. Elven archers were much stronger than the spearmen, but fell very quickly to wargs, which forced the elves to diversify more. In particular, Isengard had no ranged units, so Rohan's flank cavalry was especially dangerous since it would directly target the fires of orthanc, and so isengard had to spend a lot of effort screening its siege forces. I think ranged support feels reasonable. I like all abilities that encourage using a variety of units. Eg the galadhrim archers are one of the most powerful units in the game, but they require you to buy the weaker elven spearmen to unlock their full value. I like the change to charge, since before formation made those units a liability because you couldn't make them not charge. Eg the warg riders were essentially useless for angmar because of this and rohan suffered hard. I do like the new ambush mechanic since it encourages more diversity in unit selection. I do think it should be allowed in cities though (that was the whole siege of osgilliath), and the fact that only a certain number of units can ambush will balance it. I'm not sure I like scouting as it is though. If scouting eliminates ambush, then you just need 1-2 units with scouting in your army and you're fine. And if those units are otherwise useful (eg rangers) then it makes ambushers useless. Maybe scouting should be like spearwall? Just decreasing the effectiveness of ambush so it's less good but still useful? So maybe barrow wights would have an ambush of 6, then eg warg scouts could have a scouting of 2, rangers 3, and wizards 6x2 or sth? I feel like something missing in the game is some notion of hit and run tactics for cavalry. Cavalry is expensive and strong and excels at taking out small groups, but you often can't take advantage of this because if you do it exposes your cavalry to counterattack where they won't make up their PU values. Meanwhile air units can do this which gives angmar and mordor a big advantage. Maybe some cavalry could have an ability wherein they (and only they) can independently retreat after the first round of combat, even if there's a win? This still requires some thought, since if you don't have a win in your first round you have to decide if it's worth leaving your cavalry open to guarantee the win, and cavalry is still worse than flying units since they don't get the whole combat or a noncombat move. But it makes cavalry much more tactically interesting Also a general thought, but I think rangers need to be a higher tier of ranged unit. They have excellent tactics, mountaineer, high movement, anti-flying, scouting, ambush, support, and maybe more. And given the lore this makes sense, but also in the lore they aren't common at all - the Dunedain are solitary and dying out. So I think buffing them and treating them more like weak creatures than elite infantry would make more sense. And then you could maybe have some weaker version for gondor representing Faramir's rangers which are just elite infantry
  • Pact of Steel 2 mods for new Version

    6
    0 Votes
    6 Posts
    271 Views
    TheDogT
    @djggml So here is a working map.yml (remove the .txt to use it. map.yml.txt map_name: the_pact_of_steel games: - {game_name: Pact of Steel, file_name: pact_of_steel.xml} - {game_name: Pact of Steel 2, file_name: pact_of_steel_2.xml} - {game_name: Pact of Steel 233, file_name: pact_of_steel_233.xml} Note it has the version line removed.
  • Warcraft: Lordaeron Wars - Official Thread

    37
    8 Votes
    37 Posts
    24k Views
    Z
    @gr8gamerguy It has certainly been a long time since I worked on this project but I really want to finish it and condensed things down. With the advent of chatgpt I think ill come to finish it. (In case you ever see this message, thank you for all.the big reports)
  • Jurassic v2.0

    39
    1
    3 Votes
    39 Posts
    12k Views
    G
    UPDATED: http://john.gregorek.com/Games/Generic.zip Added caveER_png to help identify territories for removal/addition. Shifted place_txt values to represent top-left corner of unit images. Corrected polygons_txt fragments for defining territories across map borders. Not happy with glyph branding. It's optional. Still have an issue with border fragments that requires your inspection. The reliefTiles hide the map border edge well, but note the dinosaur has been beheaded. [image: tripleAbeheaded.png]
  • WW1 contour baseline map 4000px

    16
    2
    3 Votes
    16 Posts
    8k Views
    SchulzS
    I like maps that are aesthetically pleasing to look at. Map rotations, curves, extreme squeezings/stretches, and abnormally big Scandinavia, Eastern Europe, or Africa are just not good. Standard maps aren't suitable either because they make Europe too small. It’s better to use an equirectangular projection, get rid of all the unpleasant stuff I listed, and subtly shrink non-European territories.[image: wwi_more territories.png]
  • world_war_ii_v5_1942 is incorrectly linked and installed

    15
    1 Votes
    15 Posts
    5k Views
    PantherP
    I can confirm that it downloads fine now. That already was a good example for the workflow. Thank you
  • Power of Politics 1914 : A WWI scenario

    264
    3
    6 Votes
    264 Posts
    292k Views
    ubernautU
    @RogerCooper @thedog i was thinking i might try to recruit @wc_sumpton to help us but the basic problem is the version that we have does not appear to be very far along compared to some of the posts so it’s kind of hard to tell what they were thinking with the map also some of the territories are sort of microscopic i think there might be a problem with unit stacking as it stands as well
  • Proposed Map: Domination 1941

    498
    2 Votes
    498 Posts
    784k Views
    TheDogT
    @Schulz Been a while. If you want to use this threads map you are welcome to use it. It is used in 1941 Global Command Decision, but be aware it has nearly 800 locations so is probably best for solo play.
  • War Plan Red-Orange

    10
    2
    4 Votes
    10 Posts
    3k Views
    M
    Another update, version 0.3.0! [image: 0.3.0 jpg smaller.jpg] The technology system has been reworked, every country now has a unique ladder of techs to climb and you unlock tech with tech tokens. Plus, the Portuguese and the Dutch have been added! Download it here: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1EowcYb0cA0qfcVIqZaasKfUgzp_aBd9G?usp=drive_link Download instructions: Download the “war_plan_red_orange” folder contained in the link Add this to C:/Users/(your username)/triplea/downloadedMaps Once you hit “select maps” in TripleA, the file should automatically be unzipped and it should just work. If you are still running into issues, please report them to me! Also, we have a Discord server now! https://discord.gg/78EEWmuK7C

Recent Posts

  • @Schulz Both could go 1 or even 2 IPCs cheaper, I think.

    With strategic bombing, a damage range of 5-10 gives an average of 7.5 PU per raid.

    We can compare that to the average damage from other models:
    Classic -> 1d6 -> 3.5 -> 7 PU per raid
    Global 40 -> 1d6 +2 -> 5.5 -> 11 PU per raid

    So your Bomber is slightly stronger than the Classic one on raids but a good deal weaker than the G40 one.

    read more

  • @Vendetta

    I gave 5 IPCs to Germany, Japan, Britain, and the USA. Both the British and Japanese mainlands are now worth 15 IPCs, which is well-rounded compared to a bomber's average 7.5 damage.

    Do you think fighters and bombers should be 1 IPC cheaper?

    read more

  • Name WWIIv3 1940 - 11 Nations Mod
    Description Anniversary edition with a lot of minor powers
    https://axisandallies.fandom.com/wiki/WWIIv3_1940_-_11_Nations_Mod
    image.jpeg

    Good Points

    Reasonably balanced Easy to understand rules

    Bad Points

    Minor powers don't have much to do or add to the game
    read more

  • @Schulz
    All right, so unit costs are around double the base game's, though some are a bit cheaper or more expensive relative to the standard game.

    I'm going to compare your starting incomes to the ones from the Larry Harris AAG 1942 setup, which I've doubled to account for the relative cost differences.

    Germans: 90 vs 108
    Japanese: 45 vs 96
    Italians: 25 vs 20

    Americans: 85 vs 100 (130 with bonus income)
    British: 65 vs 82 (62 Europe / 20 Pacific) or 102 with ANZAC included
    Soviets: 45 vs 58

    Most of the world is poorer now; Italy is the only country that actually increased in purchasing power (with a 25% gain).

    The rest lost purchasing power by the following amounts:

    Germans (-16.7%)
    Soviets (-22.4%)
    Americans (-34.6%)
    British (-36.3%)
    Japanese (-53.1%)

    China had a 12 IPC income in AAG 42 (so 24 adjusted), which offsets only about half of Japan's 51 IPC loss in relative purchasing power.

    The Axis is much stronger in Europe in your variant (Italy gained while Germany lost less than the Soviets and only half as much as the Americans and British) but far weaker in the Pacific.

    Britain could use that income buff you're thinking of, but the US and Japan probably deserve that extra 5 more than Germany and Italy, unless Germany is already struggling for some reason in your test games.

    Onto your unit lineup. Infantry and Artillery stayed constant from the base game, but there will be fewer of them since overall purchasing power has declined. The Tank is the unit that gained the biggest buff by becoming 17% cheaper. It lost its support functions since you axed the Mechanized and the Tactical Bomber, but it's a better buy for combat on its own now.

    The Fighter lost 33% of its attack value and 25% of its defense value, while becoming only 10% cheaper, so it suffered a major nerf.

    The Bomber also lost 25% of its attack value for an 8% discount, but it's probably increased in desirability as a combat purchase versus the Fighter because it's the only unit besides a Tank that attacks at a 3 in land combat.

    AA Guns gained nothing and went up 20% in price while planes got cheaper. The planes having weaker stats also reduces the value of having a specialist unit to kill them, so the AA Gun, which was already a bad purchase in the original game, has become an even worse one in every way. It should have gotten cheaper, not more expensive.

    At sea, Carriers cost more, Fighters are weaker, and Tactical Bombers are absent, while Destroyers, Cruisers, and Battleships all got relatively cheaper. Keep an eye out in test games on whether carrier air groups have become a losing buy versus surface fleets.

    A loaded Carrier with two Fighters in your setup costs 76 IPC, the same value as two Battleships. In both your game and the original, the Carrier group gets demolished if attacks the two Battleships. However, in the base game, a Carrier + 2 Fighters actually wins 50% of the time when defending against two battleships (and achieves mutual wipeout 8% of the time) while costing 4 IPC less than them; in your mod, the carrier only wins 34% of the time on defense (and gets a mutual wipe out 7% of the time), and it's no cheaper at all. Carriers also become weaker on the offense without the option to load a Tactical Bomber, and ships have all gotten faster while the range of planes stayed the same, so it's harder for a carrier to launch air strikes from beyond an enemy fleet's retaliation range. Battleships are therefore a winning buy both for offense and for defense at sea.

    The only thing the Carrier is efficient for now is providing Fighter support to land battles, and that air support is a lot weaker than it was in the base game.

    read more