-
5 Votes6 Posts2k Views
-
0 Votes2 Posts930 Views
-
0 Votes3 Posts1k Views
-
0 Votes2 Posts789 Views
-
0 Votes2 Posts734 Views
-
1 Votes58 Posts24k Views
-
5 Votes19 Posts3k Views
-
0 Votes4 Posts978 Views
-
2 Votes20 Posts4k Views
-
3 Votes1 Posts554 Views
-
0 Votes8 Posts4k Views
-
1 Votes7 Posts1k Views
-
1 Votes10 Posts2k Views
-
0 Votes103 Posts63k Views
-
0 Votes1 Posts384 Views
-
0 Votes9 Posts2k Views
-
4 Votes96 Posts55k Views
-
0 Votes1 Posts580 Views
-
2 Votes4 Posts1k Views
-
1 Votes2 Posts587 Views
Recent Posts
-
@Stohrm Torpedo Boats or other cheap naval units are an interesting balance challenge for the exact reason you brought up, they’re liable to be built in swarms and used to obsolete the larger warships unless you add some special modifiers.
The coastal zones distinction was one that came to mind for me when I was drafting an outline for an expanded WWII unit roster. Mine wouldn’t be hard locked from entering ocean zones but would get a -1 combat penalty in those.
I actually considered Attack 2 / Defense 1 a more natural profile for a TB. That makes them more initiative dependent, and harder to use when combined with the penalty outside coastal zones.
You could throw in the Submarine’s inability to hit aircraft as an additional nerf to make planes an easy counter for torpedo boat spam. While a sub can hide, a torpedo boat doesn’t have that option.
Cruisers and battleships can handle TB spam much easier if they get two attack rolls per round, although that has strong balance implications - it makes them much better against planes as well, unless you can code the second attack roll to be incapable of hitting aircraft.
One final possibility is giving the cruiser and battleship pre-battle AA style shots against TBs to help thin out a swarm before it can attack.
-
@KurtGodel7 You could try running both in manual tests and time out which way takes longer for you to play through a single complete game turn. If I’m reading this right, combat outcomes should still be the same either way, it’s more about which will move faster and feel better to play with?
-
I've been busy replying to older posts, as it's been a long time since I've actually had a chance to go through them.
I have been playing this particular game and making my own adjustments. I suppose the biggest of them was defining Open Ocean Sea Zones and NOT allowing the Torpedo Boat units to venture into them.
The reason for this is because the AI was using them in mass to assist with transport convoys. Why use a 1 shot 2 Hit Battleship when you can use 4 Torpedo Boats, especially when they defend at 2?
The biggest drawback with this particular map is that it still uses the old overlay. Several of the territories were historically of greater value than those currently set, but changing them does not get reflected due to the overlay.
Other than that, it's a really nice map.
-
JSYK there is a Sea Zone connection near Java that was missing. I don't recall the exact one, as I simply fixed it on my own version of the map. But it was annoying.
Granted, this has nothing to do with your post other than the title. But the title reminded me to say something about it.