-
5 Votes6 Posts2k Views
-
0 Votes2 Posts930 Views
-
0 Votes3 Posts1k Views
-
0 Votes2 Posts789 Views
-
0 Votes2 Posts734 Views
-
1 Votes58 Posts24k Views
-
5 Votes19 Posts3k Views
-
0 Votes4 Posts978 Views
-
2 Votes20 Posts4k Views
-
3 Votes1 Posts554 Views
-
0 Votes8 Posts4k Views
-
1 Votes7 Posts1k Views
-
1 Votes10 Posts2k Views
-
0 Votes103 Posts63k Views
-
0 Votes1 Posts384 Views
-
0 Votes9 Posts2k Views
-
4 Votes96 Posts55k Views
-
0 Votes1 Posts580 Views
-
2 Votes4 Posts1k Views
-
1 Votes2 Posts587 Views
Recent Posts
-
@Schulz
All right, so unit costs are around double the base game's, though some are a bit cheaper or more expensive relative to the standard game.I'm going to compare your starting incomes to the ones from the Larry Harris AAG 1942 setup, which I've doubled to account for the relative cost differences.
Germans: 90 vs 108
Japanese: 45 vs 96
Italians: 25 vs 20Americans: 85 vs 100 (130 with bonus income)
British: 65 vs 82 (62 Europe / 20 Pacific) or 102 with ANZAC included
Soviets: 45 vs 58Most of the world is poorer now; Italy is the only country that actually increased in purchasing power (with a 25% gain).
The rest lost purchasing power by the following amounts:
Germans (-16.7%)
Soviets (-22.4%)
Americans (-34.6%)
British (-36.3%)
Japanese (-53.1%)China had a 12 IPC income in AAG 42 (so 24 adjusted), which offsets only about half of Japan's 51 IPC loss in relative purchasing power.
The Axis is much stronger in Europe in your variant (Italy gained while Germany lost less than the Soviets and only half as much as the Americans and British) but far weaker in the Pacific.
Britain could use that income buff you're thinking of, but the US and Japan probably deserve that extra 5 more than Germany and Italy, unless Germany is already struggling for some reason in your test games.
Onto your unit lineup. Infantry and Artillery stayed constant from the base game, but there will be fewer of them since overall purchasing power has declined. The Tank is the unit that gained the biggest buff by becoming 17% cheaper. It lost its support functions since you axed the Mechanized and the Tactical Bomber, but it's a better buy for combat on its own now.
The Fighter lost 33% of its attack value and 25% of its defense value, while becoming only 10% cheaper, so it suffered a major nerf.
The Bomber also lost 25% of its attack value for an 8% discount, but it's probably increased in desirability as a combat purchase versus the Fighter because it's the only unit besides a Tank that attacks at a 3 in land combat.
AA Guns gained nothing and went up 20% in price while planes got cheaper. The planes having weaker stats also reduces the value of having a specialist unit to kill them, so the AA Gun, which was already a bad purchase in the original game, has become an even worse one in every way. It should have gotten cheaper, not more expensive.
At sea, Carriers cost more, Fighters are weaker, and Tactical Bombers are absent, while Destroyers, Cruisers, and Battleships all got relatively cheaper. Keep an eye out in test games on whether carrier air groups have become a losing buy versus surface fleets.
A loaded Carrier with two Fighters in your setup costs 76 IPC, the same value as two Battleships. In both your game and the original, the Carrier group gets demolished if attacks the two Battleships. However, in the base game, a Carrier + 2 Fighters actually wins 50% of the time when defending against two battleships (and achieves mutual wipeout 8% of the time) while costing 4 IPC less than them; in your mod, the carrier only wins 34% of the time on defense (and gets a mutual wipe out 7% of the time), and it's no cheaper at all. Carriers also become weaker on the offense without the option to load a Tactical Bomber. Battleships are therefore a winning buy both for offense and for defense at sea.
The only thing the Carrier is efficient for now is providing Fighter support to land battles, and that air support is a lot weaker than it was in the base game.
-
@Karl582003
Hopefully not speaking out of turn here, but @alkexr is busy in real life and an infrequent visitor here.So if you could copy/paste or screen shot the chat on discord Im sure that would help him and save him time.
-
Also, we have a community in Discord for TripleA gaming, where we've playtested this map, in case you're interested for feedback
-
When's a new version coming out. It would be nice to have an update with updated gamenotes to see what changed in bonuses and factions, also some antiair for Gondor.